Recent content by Walsh Bay

5 Dale 4 Treloar 3 Naughton 2 Macrae 1 Johannisen 3 Darcy 2 Gallagher 1 -

It's not an either/or. We can have challenges with our list composition whilst acknowledging the revitalisation a new coach would bring. The mistake is to focus on one wholly and not recognise the other. Any discussion of our current plight, in my opinion, has to incorporate this: We have...

Our list is way over-rated, in my opinion. English - Nice contested mark in the forward line, but so he should be at that height. Underwhelming at best as a ruck. Gardner - Honest trier with self-evident limitations. Would be depth at any club. Keath - Body gone. Depth at best. L Smith - Long...

Assuming we're a professionally-run outfit, there must have been a list management plan for our wings. So, who were they meant to be? Who was planned to be there? What went wrong? On SM-S916B using BigFooty.com mobile app

5 - 4 - 3 Treloar 2 Khamis 1 Darcy 3 Darcy 2 Ugle-Hagan 1 Sanders

5 Liberatore 4 Bontempelli 3 Jones 2 Treloar 1 West 3 Darcy 2 Sanders 1 -

Liberatore, Bont and Treloar play like that and we still can't get it done. Our forward line doesn't scare anyone. And it should.

Every single one of us posting tonight could offer more insight, coherence and nuance than Jobe Watson.

Good oppositions aren't worried by our forward line.

Dale, Johannisen, Baker, Williams are senior players. check out their combined tackles. Hint. It's not pretty.

Hard to love our forward line atm. For all its potential.

Geelong's tackling and close pressure on the ball carrier is simply superior.

Every time I feel like venting over the state of our list and the quality of our 'bottom six' or whatever, I will remind myself that an insanely rich, powerful football club with a supine, complacent, massive fan base could allow itself to have a list the standard of West Coast's. And I will...

5 Treloar 4 English 3 Williams 2 Vandermeer 1 Naughton 3 Gallagher 2 Sanders 1 Ugle-Hagan

5 Liberatore 4 Jones 3 Weightman 2 Bontempelli 1 Treloar 3 Darcy 2 Sanders 1 Poulter