Recent content by West World

  1. W

    List Mgmt. Trade & Draft UltraThread- Warning, May Contain Speculation #combinethethreads

    Reported CEY is looking elsewhere and will be moving.
  2. W

    Uncontracted Tim Kelly [requested a trade to West Coast]

    Unless GWS can trade down to a top 4 pick they will need their two 1sts to land Green. That will take two 1sts out and the residual would move their 2nd 1st into the mid 2nd round there abouts. Freo also has a top 10 academy pick that will burn up picks likely traded in. The AFL has closed...
  3. W

    Uncontracted Tim Kelly [requested a trade to West Coast]

    If Yeo was equal to Kelly in class that is slightly unders which has been conceeded. Ever team would want 'a bit more'at the trade table for class players. But Yeo is a dual AA, a dual B&F, one of those being in a premiership year and is one of the few mids in the comp who can run both ways...
  4. W

    Uncontracted Tim Kelly [requested a trade to West Coast]

    Riiiiight! Um no! That is tin foil hat stuff.
  5. W

    Uncontracted Tim Kelly [requested a trade to West Coast]

    Go read some of the tripe Geelong posters have posted on here. See you in a month.
  6. W

    Uncontracted Tim Kelly [requested a trade to West Coast]

    What a dead set dumb comment. His kids were diagnosed after he was drafted. How desperate was he? Obviously not desperate enough to go to Freo who showed no interest in him in his draft year and were and still are a rabble on and off field. Remember, the deal last year with the Eagles fell...
  7. W

    Uncontracted Tim Kelly [requested a trade to West Coast]

    Being very close to accepting is very different to the deal being massive under's. If the Eagles offer was ridiculously low (as many Cats fans on here claim) the Cats would never have entertained letting him go. But they admit they were very close to accepting the trade offered.
  8. W

    Uncontracted Tim Kelly [requested a trade to West Coast]

    Neale was under contract and when traded and he was already a better player than Kelly. Neale just got better again in 2019 just as Kelly has. Two firsts with nothing coming back is more than Neale. Neale effectively went for pick 6 and 23ish. Kelly is not worth more than that as he isn't as...
  9. W

    Uncontracted Tim Kelly [requested a trade to West Coast]

    Stop rewritting history. Geelong admitted they almost accepted the Eagles offer. Then at the 11th hour changed their minds and pulled out. Scott admitted that.
  10. W

    Uncontracted Tim Kelly [requested a trade to West Coast]

    Geelong fan mentality. Kelly is worth more than Neale but would settle for the same as Judd. You can fluff on all you like about improvement in the future, look at the Neale, Dangerfield and Judd deals and start pegging back your expectations. Living in fantasy world.
  11. W

    Uncontracted Tim Kelly [requested a trade to West Coast]

    Cats fans dont get trading. They want more for Kelly than any mid ever traded. They would settle for what Judd was traded for. They want more than Neale. So far off the market rate its not funny.
  12. W

    Contracted Shai Bolton [re-signed until 2021]

    Isnt the average wage now $380k pa? $333k x 3 years seems a little short. He is better than average or maybe thats potential being factored in as well. I think he would stay for $1m over 3 years with some form of bonus uplift based on kpi's. $333 kin two years could very well be unders in a...
  13. W

    Uncontracted Tim Kelly [requested a trade to West Coast]

    They are or were best 22 mids. You are shifting goal posts. The discussion is about Freo needing to replace multiple best 22 players due to players leaving, retiring or being sacked. The number of best 22 players they need to replace is not the normal cycle hence they have to be become more...
  14. W

    Uncontracted Sam Powell-Pepper [OOC 2020]

    Stand by. https://wwos.nine.com.au/afl/port-adelaide-reportedly-asking-senior-players-to-roll-over-salary/b3c92222-8d28-467a-80c5-279db207cf41 Pretty clear article on Port simply not having the cash to pay 100% of the cap.

Top Bottom