List Mgmt. Gibbs - 2017 Trade Discussions! V2.0

[Roovolution]

Mind you, Port fans are cheering they only paid pick 31 for Watts.

Watts lol

 

[GROTTO]

**** it, all in

Need to win the premiership next year IMO, otherwise rebuild coming right up

Cameron for 12 must be in the pipeline, now

I think its the Lions 2018 1st to be honest.

 

[Squiba]

This is what we stuffed up with.

Carlton has a player who is homesick and wants to come home. Carlton stands firm.

Essendon has a player who is homesick and wants to come home. Essendon stands firm.

We have Lever who is "homesick" and wants to come home. So we work hard to get him home.

And Cameron ...

Contracts will do that, though. Particularly 2+ year remaining ones

 

[Murray2503]

Wayne Carey all over again. Rinse repeat.

 

[BACCS]

Why on earth did we even have to send that second, though. That's still a valuable comodity that just adds to the size of the implement used to collectively ream us.

Carlton will finish well below us next season, it's effectively a major pick upgrade, not sure how that's a negative at all.

 

[pjcrows]

All in. Love it.

 

[Crowbling]

Gibbs better win the brownlow, norm smith and find a solution to world hunger for that price.

 

[Rave Slave]

What a ******* joke. Seriously.

 

[GreyCrow]

Club release says " better value deal than last year's offer"

Carlton must have asked for 3 1sts

 

[BACCS]

Gibbs better win the brownlow, norm smith and find a solution to world hunger for that price.

I'll just take a premiership thanks.

 

[Danger in Texas]

I think its the Lions 2018 1st to be honest.

All in for the 2018 flag, and then all in for the 2018 draft?

I like it, but I still think it's pick 12

 

[Sanders]

What's the complete trade in terms of 2018 picks if the teams finish in the same ladder position next year?

10, 16, 35, 73

For

Gibbs, 22, 38,77

It’s really 10 + slight down grade on 2017 first to 2018 second. If draft quality is to be believed 22 in 2018 worth more than 16 in 2017

In effect pick 10 for Gibbs straight up or maybe even a bit less than 10

 

[Magma]

dont have a problem with it. weak draft and we need players now. hawthorn at their peak wouldve done the same. we keep 2 firsts for the better draft and a 2nd rounder that should be low

draft picks are maybe's. gibbs is proven. we need proven

 

[Anzacpaul]

After losing Smith for the year we were desperate I reckon.

Hope Bryce has a massive leg and likes playing off half back then.

Would've rather had Saad.

 

[Mr_Moogle]

Ogilvie really must not rate the 2017 draft. Otherwise I can't imagine this deal would have been done.

Hope Bryce has a massive leg and likes playing off half back then.

Would've rather had Saad.

Saad nominated Essendon and was never going to come here. Can't hang s**t on the club for every player who nominates a different team.

 

[hey shorty]

Wayne Carey all over again. Rinse repeat.

Pick 2 is a long way from 10, and Carey was crocked

But yes it's the same.

 

[Elite Crow]

So let’s look at this, had we done the deal last year:

Lose Galluci and pick 16.

Now we’ve lost 10 & 16 without Gibbs for the 2017 campaign.

No matter what you think of this years trade, that in itself makes it a shocker.

 

[PrideOf]

All in. Love it.

Yep. And, as someone else has already posted, Ogilvie must clearly know what he's after this year and thinks he can get it. Considering his raft of knowledge, I'm happy to go with that.

 

[Samcro24]

I wanted players & I wanted Gibbs.

But yuck.

 

[Squiba]

Carlton will finish well below us next season, it's effectively a major pick upgrade, not sure how that's a negative at all.

Best it can be in theory is pick 36 downgraded to pick 19. Realistically it is likely going to be 34 upgraded to 28 or something after free agent compensation.

Reamed.

 

[Murray2503]

he will be a very good player for you. Good luck Bryce.

*off.

 

[Sanders]

So basically we paid 2x1st for Gibbs

Nah we paid #10 flat (ish) once you unwind it all

 

[Large 1]

DISASTER.

Reid needs to fall in his sword and go.

I know it's not just him but this deal is terrible. I'm not one to throw my toys out of the cot but I'm throwing the whole cot out the f@&king window.

 

[DD#23]

Carlton will finish well below us next season, it's effectively a major pick upgrade, not sure how that's a negative at all.

they should be sending us that without getting ours back

 

[Bonkers000]

People need to stop looking at the draft rounds and look at the numbers of the draft pick and the year of that draft pick. The trade was win-win in my opinion.