Ah Chee might be good for a 90 I reckon. West Coast need him to be.
2018 Rate My Team (Post JLT)
- Thread starter WaynesWorld19
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
Sicily can gagf just for being a pasty faced flog (good pick tho)
Nic Nat needs to be a watch and act imo
Redden is a passenger on campaigner express
Pendles? hmmmmmm I think Treloar will get the scores he deserves this year.
Pendles over Treloar even when the great man retires.
Redden will come good. Not expecting 115+ more like 100. Durable will become my M9. Still unsure on this pick.
NicNat isn't a problem as everyone will have him.
Sicily is a campaigner like that flopper Oliver but is cheap and DEF selectable.
toxic
Premium Gold
Maynard over Sicily (who'll be a half fwd for the hawks with all their defence returning)
I like the Maynard pick. Should play more mid next year.
croweyrocks
All Australian
- Nov 29, 2014
- 976
- 1,311
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
Look, good luck to Arch. Really nice fella with a good bag of tricks in a football sense but he simply isn't consistent enough to average that. He played an sanfl game this season where he only got 8 touches in the midfield. His best is good but he can go through games sometimes hardly noticing him.
Sicily lol I wasn't being sarcastic, but seriously, hawk's do have a lot of annoying skinny pasty faced players with exceptional talent amiright?
Sicily, Langford, smith, 0'brien, Hartung, glass ...
Top notch.
The only pick I don't like is Cyril.
Also Ryan will play more and score more for us than Willie Rioli will.
I reckon he will ever flop and play WAFL or step up and take his chance.
He asked for only a 1 year contract. He either takes his chance or eats his words and never makes it.
It's been long enough. Release the sneeze.
Cheers. I keep tossing up: Lloyd & Dahlhaus vs Burton & Billings.
Thoughts?
I know Cyril isn’t the greatest pick but at 317k come on?
Bennell & AhChee could be smokies.
The middle column is the worry
Definately Lloyd & Dahlhaus
Problem with Cyril is even when he was winning flags in a top 4 side he didn't play more than 20 games.
Don't think his form/prep going into next year is worth the punt IMO.
Ah Chee is at worst best treated like an expensive rookie. He will get games and make money. Bennell similar except he has "calf problems"
Sicily looked too good down back to move. Would see Gunstan moving fwd before him
Also,Hodge gone, Gibson gone, Burton fwd/mid, Burger only down there to fix holes.
Frawley to FB, Stratton plays as lock down 3rd def on small or tall, Birchall plays higher pushing back in support.
Can easily fit Sicily down back with those guys coming back.
Rd 23 line up.2017
B: Shaun Burgoyne, Kaiden Brand, Blake Hardwick
HB: Luke Hodge, James Sicily, Jack Gunston
C: Isaac Smith, Tom Mitchell, Billy Hartung
Rd 1 2018
B: Ben Stratton,James Frawley, Blake Hardwick
HB: Connor Glass, Kaiden Brand, James Sicily.
C: Isaac Smith, Tom Mitchell, Grant Birchall
Funnily I don't rate Lloyd or billings out of those four, seagull crabs imo but both score well in sc for some reason. Toss a coin Option 1 I spose
Seymour Skinner
Norm Smith Medallist
Big Sissy took that many intercept clunks down back, was leading or close to leading the comp once he made the transition. Would be crazy to move him out of there.
If Venebles plays half as good as he says he is, he's got the rising star in the bag.
Same as Yeo. AA HBF.Big Sissy took that many intercept clunks down back, was leading or close to leading the comp once he made the transition. Would be crazy to move him out of there.
Don't be a stupid campaigner Simmo you stupid campaigner.
stevebbb
Brownlow Medallist
- May 21, 2013
- 22,985
- 57,702
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- Arsenal, Fluminense; Blue Jays
First year in the a while we are going to see a lot of very different teams... it's great!
Defence and Forwards is wide open, not a lot of stand-out picks, a heap of ~90 averaging players to choose from
Going to be an exciting year
Defence and Forwards is wide open, not a lot of stand-out picks, a heap of ~90 averaging players to choose from
Going to be an exciting year
- Banned
- #370
Have seen Worpel in a fair few teams. Is he going to get much gametime?
Great 2008
Cancelled
- Nov 27, 2009
- 5,640
- 6,042
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
O'Meara struggling...
........to do up his belt buckle.
........to do up his belt buckle.
toxic
Premium Gold
DEF - Yeo, Laird, Williams, Coffield, Obrien, Doedee - Smith, Murray
MID - Danger, Dusty, Fyfe, Beams, Rocky, LDU, Brodie, Higgins - Ahern, Holman, Kelly
RUCK - Gawn, NN - Olango
FWDS - Heeney, Gray, Billings, Lobb, Ah Chee, Venables - Ryan, English
MID - Danger, Dusty, Fyfe, Beams, Rocky, LDU, Brodie, Higgins - Ahern, Holman, Kelly
RUCK - Gawn, NN - Olango
FWDS - Heeney, Gray, Billings, Lobb, Ah Chee, Venables - Ryan, English
toxic
Premium Gold
Will Lycett play before Vardy?
Lycett has me tinkering( perfect cover if NutNut misses a week)
- Status
