2018 Rolling State of Origin Thread (performance based)

Remove this Banner Ad

Log in to remove this ad.

Dav

Hotel? Trivago.
10k Posts Koala SFA State of Origin Coney Island Warriors - Sweet F.A. Pantskyle SFA Fight For MND SFA Daffodil Day Fund Raiser Brisbane Dolphins Player - BFFCL BFFCL Club Captain Blue Mountain Bounders Player - BFFCL
Jul 23, 2015
19,042
37,273
Adelaide
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Other Teams
Brighton, McLaren F1
What's with the 3 man interchange?

Basically because the tables I use have 3 columns. It's lazy on my behalf and I might change it.
 

Dav

Hotel? Trivago.
10k Posts Koala SFA State of Origin Coney Island Warriors - Sweet F.A. Pantskyle SFA Fight For MND SFA Daffodil Day Fund Raiser Brisbane Dolphins Player - BFFCL BFFCL Club Captain Blue Mountain Bounders Player - BFFCL
Jul 23, 2015
19,042
37,273
Adelaide
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Other Teams
Brighton, McLaren F1
Jun 6, 2016
19,309
12,031
Perth
AFL Club
Collingwood
Other Teams
Pines Football Club
Beams was born in Victoria but played football from ages 13 to 17 in Queensland, which is where State of Origin eligibility comes from. Cyril Rioli hasn't played overly well and is from the NT anyway. And like I've said multiple times, it's a rolling team of the season based on performance only so of course it's not gonna be 100% yet, it's gonna be heavily skewed towards players who did well in the first two weeks funnily enough.



Can't stress this enough - based purely on performance. Someone like Ed Curnow will more than likely not be in the squad later on but his start to the season warrants his inclusion. Also I have no idea why multiple people think Cyril would play for Western Australia when he was born and raised in the Territory, played footy from 14 to 18 for Scotch College, and as far as I know never played for a WA side.

Fair enough, got me there. I will say the thread title does not immediately give the idea of a week to week best side from each state, when you put in "state of origin" guess what the immediate thought is? And I know I'm not the only one who has read the title not as it is intended.

How about "Best performers each round from each state" - take out the "State of Origin"

BTW I still maintain from the 1st 3 rounds you should have Danger, Dusty and Pendles and add Sides and GAJ in the Vic side.
 

Dav

Hotel? Trivago.
10k Posts Koala SFA State of Origin Coney Island Warriors - Sweet F.A. Pantskyle SFA Fight For MND SFA Daffodil Day Fund Raiser Brisbane Dolphins Player - BFFCL BFFCL Club Captain Blue Mountain Bounders Player - BFFCL
Jul 23, 2015
19,042
37,273
Adelaide
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Other Teams
Brighton, McLaren F1
Fair enough, got me there. I will say the thread title does not immediately give the idea of a week to week best side from each state, when you put in "state of origin" guess what the immediate thought is? And I know I'm not the only one who has read the title not as it is intended.

How about "Best performers each round from each state" - take out the "State of Origin"

BTW I still maintain from the 1st 3 rounds you should have Danger, Dusty and Pendles and add Sides and GAJ in the Vic side.

Yeah those players will more than likely be there after this week.
 

Dav

Hotel? Trivago.
10k Posts Koala SFA State of Origin Coney Island Warriors - Sweet F.A. Pantskyle SFA Fight For MND SFA Daffodil Day Fund Raiser Brisbane Dolphins Player - BFFCL BFFCL Club Captain Blue Mountain Bounders Player - BFFCL
Jul 23, 2015
19,042
37,273
Adelaide
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Other Teams
Brighton, McLaren F1
Gonna revive this thread as we're a little further into the season and picking the teams is a hell of a lot easier. I'll backdate it to Round 5, which I'll reveal soon.
 

Dav

Hotel? Trivago.
10k Posts Koala SFA State of Origin Coney Island Warriors - Sweet F.A. Pantskyle SFA Fight For MND SFA Daffodil Day Fund Raiser Brisbane Dolphins Player - BFFCL BFFCL Club Captain Blue Mountain Bounders Player - BFFCL
Jul 23, 2015
19,042
37,273
Adelaide
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Other Teams
Brighton, McLaren F1
ROUND 5 STATE OF ORIGIN TEAMS

Victoria

B T.Stewart -- R.Tarrant -- D.Astbury
HB P.Seedsman -- M.Hurley -- K.Simpson
C S.Sidebottom -- J.Selwood (vc) -- S.Ross
HF D.Martin -- T.J.Lynch -- K.Lambert
F R.Gray -- J.Cameron -- C.Petracca
Fo M.Gawn -- T.Cotchin (c) -- P.Dangerfield
IC J.Steven, S.Martin, G.Ablett, A.Treloar

Western Australia
B N.Wilson -- A.Rance (c) -- B.Stratton
HB E.Yeo -- J.McGovern -- B.Sheppard
C S.Coniglio -- N.Fyfe (vc) -- D.Sheed
HF M.Walters -- L.Franklin -- B.Acres
F J.Darling -- J.Hogan -- Je.Garlett
Fo A.Sandilands -- P.Cripps -- T.Mitchell
IC D.Swallow, J.O'Meara, S.Hill, N.Naitanui

South Australia
B S.Hurn (c) -- P.Davis (vc) -- R.Bonner
HB R.Laird -- T.Jonas -- H.Hartlett
C J.Polec -- L.Neale -- G.Hewett
HF S.Edwards -- J.Westhoff -- W.Hayward
F S.Gray -- D.Menzel -- C.Wingard
Fo B.Grundy -- B.Gibbs -- B.Ebert
IC B.Williams, S.Jacobs, J.Redden, C.Daniel

Allies
B D.Rampe -- H.Andrews -- J.Finlayson
HB J.Howe -- A.Pearce -- C.Mills
C J.Harbrow -- M.Robinson -- I.Smith
HF I.Heeney -- C.Dixon (vc) -- C.Cameron
F L.Breust -- B.Brown -- J.Riewoldt
Fo J.Witts -- D.Beams (c) -- B.Parfitt
IC L.Weller, J.Thomas, J.McVeigh, S.Motlop
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Jesslc

Club Legend
Mar 16, 2015
2,923
4,043
AFL Club
North Melbourne
ROUND 5 STATE OF ORIGIN TEAMS

Victoria

B T.Stewart -- R.Tarrant -- D.Astbury
HB P.Seedsman -- M.Hurley -- K.Simpson
C S.Sidebottom -- J.Selwood (vc) -- S.Ross
HF D.Martin -- T.J.Lynch -- K.Lambert
F R.Gray -- J.Cameron -- C.Petracca
Fo M.Gawn -- T.Cotchin (c) -- P.Dangerfield
IC J.Steven, S.Martin, G.Ablett, A.Treloar

Western Australia
B N.Wilson -- A.Rance (c) -- B.Stratton
HB E.Yeo -- J.McGovern -- B.Sheppard
C S.Coniglio -- N.Fyfe (vc) -- D.Sheed
HF M.Walters -- L.Franklin -- B.Acres
F J.Darling -- J.Hogan -- Je.Garlett
Fo A.Sandilands -- P.Cripps -- T.Mitchell
IC D.Swallow, J.O'Meara, S.Hill, N.Naitanui

South Australia
B S.Hurn (c) -- P.Davis (vc) -- R.Bonner
HB R.Laird -- T.Jonas -- H.Hartlett
C J.Polec -- L.Neale -- G.Hewett
HF S.Edwards -- J.Westhoff -- W.Hayward
F S.Gray -- D.Menzel -- C.Wingard
Fo B.Grundy -- B.Gibbs -- B.Ebert
IC B.Williams, S.Jacobs, J.Redden, C.Daniel

Allies
B D.Rampe -- H.Andrews -- J.Finlayson
HB J.Howe -- A.Pearce -- C.Mills
C J.Harbrow -- M.Robinson -- I.Smith
HF I.Heeney -- C.Dixon (vc) -- C.Cameron
F L.Breust -- B.Brown -- J.Riewoldt
Fo J.Witts -- D.Beams (c) -- B.Parfitt
IC L.Weller, J.Thomas, J.McVeigh, S.Motlop
WA v VIC would be unreal
 

Dav

Hotel? Trivago.
10k Posts Koala SFA State of Origin Coney Island Warriors - Sweet F.A. Pantskyle SFA Fight For MND SFA Daffodil Day Fund Raiser Brisbane Dolphins Player - BFFCL BFFCL Club Captain Blue Mountain Bounders Player - BFFCL
Jul 23, 2015
19,042
37,273
Adelaide
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Other Teams
Brighton, McLaren F1
P.davis would play for allies as he is from act

Born in Canberra but State of Origin eligibility rules are based around where you played football from the ages of 13-17, which in Davis' case is South Australia.
 

Dav

Hotel? Trivago.
10k Posts Koala SFA State of Origin Coney Island Warriors - Sweet F.A. Pantskyle SFA Fight For MND SFA Daffodil Day Fund Raiser Brisbane Dolphins Player - BFFCL BFFCL Club Captain Blue Mountain Bounders Player - BFFCL
Jul 23, 2015
19,042
37,273
Adelaide
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Other Teams
Brighton, McLaren F1
Worth mentioning that 15 years ago, an Allies midfield would include Michael Voss, James Hird, Nathan Buckley and Shane Crawford. Today it includes Dayne Beams, Brandan Parfitt and Mitch Robinson.
 

Pykie

Cancelled
10k Posts A Star Wars Fan Pokemon is Life North Melbourne - North 2007 Player Sponsor North Melbourne - 2013 Daw, Black and Gibson Player Sponsorship
Sep 17, 2006
20,605
45,615
Lord's
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Other Teams
Leeds United
ROUND 5 STATE OF ORIGIN TEAMS

Victoria

B T.Stewart -- R.Tarrant -- D.Astbury
HB P.Seedsman -- M.Hurley -- K.Simpson
C S.Sidebottom -- J.Selwood (vc) -- S.Ross
HF D.Martin -- T.J.Lynch -- K.Lambert
F R.Gray -- J.Cameron -- C.Petracca
Fo M.Gawn -- T.Cotchin (c) -- P.Dangerfield
IC J.Steven, S.Martin, G.Ablett, A.Treloar

Western Australia
B N.Wilson -- A.Rance (c) -- B.Stratton
HB E.Yeo -- J.McGovern -- B.Sheppard
C S.Coniglio -- N.Fyfe (vc) -- D.Sheed
HF M.Walters -- L.Franklin -- B.Acres
F J.Darling -- J.Hogan -- Je.Garlett
Fo A.Sandilands -- P.Cripps -- T.Mitchell
IC D.Swallow, J.O'Meara, S.Hill, N.Naitanui

South Australia
B S.Hurn (c) -- P.Davis (vc) -- R.Bonner
HB R.Laird -- T.Jonas -- H.Hartlett
C J.Polec -- L.Neale -- G.Hewett
HF S.Edwards -- J.Westhoff -- W.Hayward
F S.Gray -- D.Menzel -- C.Wingard
Fo B.Grundy -- B.Gibbs -- B.Ebert
IC B.Williams, S.Jacobs, J.Redden, C.Daniel

Allies
B D.Rampe -- H.Andrews -- J.Finlayson
HB J.Howe -- A.Pearce -- C.Mills
C J.Harbrow -- M.Robinson -- I.Smith
HF I.Heeney -- C.Dixon (vc) -- C.Cameron
F L.Breust -- B.Brown -- J.Riewoldt
Fo J.Witts -- D.Beams (c) -- B.Parfitt
IC L.Weller, J.Thomas, J.McVeigh, S.Motlop

Seb Ross, Jack Steven and Sidebottom on the field for the Vics? Honestly, WTF is that side, where's Josh Kelly, Toby Greene, etc?


There are better options:

Victoria
B M.Hibberd -- D.Talia -- M.Hurley
HB J.Sicily -- R.Tarrant -- K.Simpson
C J.Kelly -- J.Selwood (c) -- D.Shiel
HF G.Ablett -- T.J.Lynch -- R.Gray
F T.Greene -- J.Cameron -- C.Petracca
Fo M.Gawn -- D.Martin -- P.Dangerfield
IC T.Cotchin, S.Pendlebury , Bontempelli, A.Treloar

Guys like A.Gaff, J.Kennedy, Oliver, Higgins, Whitfield, Boak, Wines, Cunnington, Macrae, Ward unlucky.
 

Dav

Hotel? Trivago.
10k Posts Koala SFA State of Origin Coney Island Warriors - Sweet F.A. Pantskyle SFA Fight For MND SFA Daffodil Day Fund Raiser Brisbane Dolphins Player - BFFCL BFFCL Club Captain Blue Mountain Bounders Player - BFFCL
Jul 23, 2015
19,042
37,273
Adelaide
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Other Teams
Brighton, McLaren F1
Seb Ross, Jack Steven and Sidebottom on the field for the Vics? Honestly, WTF is that side, where's Josh Kelly, Toby Greene, etc?


There are better options:

Victoria
B M.Hibberd -- D.Talia -- M.Hurley
HB J.Sicily -- R.Tarrant -- K.Simpson
C J.Kelly -- J.Selwood (c) -- D.Shiel
HF G.Ablett -- T.J.Lynch -- R.Gray
F T.Greene -- J.Cameron -- C.Petracca
Fo M.Gawn -- D.Martin -- P.Dangerfield
IC T.Cotchin, A.Gaff , S.Pendlebury, A.Treloar

I'm not picking off of ability, I'm picking from performances this season.
 

Pykie

Cancelled
10k Posts A Star Wars Fan Pokemon is Life North Melbourne - North 2007 Player Sponsor North Melbourne - 2013 Daw, Black and Gibson Player Sponsorship
Sep 17, 2006
20,605
45,615
Lord's
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Other Teams
Leeds United
I'm not picking off of ability, I'm picking from performances this season.

Someone like Macrae then would be first picked then, Steven and Ross wouldn't see the side either.
 

Dav

Hotel? Trivago.
10k Posts Koala SFA State of Origin Coney Island Warriors - Sweet F.A. Pantskyle SFA Fight For MND SFA Daffodil Day Fund Raiser Brisbane Dolphins Player - BFFCL BFFCL Club Captain Blue Mountain Bounders Player - BFFCL
Jul 23, 2015
19,042
37,273
Adelaide
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Other Teams
Brighton, McLaren F1
The Allies would beat South Australia

Allies forward line >>>>>>>>> SA's forward line, but everywhere else the Croweaters are far superior. It would be an interesting game.
 

Dav

Hotel? Trivago.
10k Posts Koala SFA State of Origin Coney Island Warriors - Sweet F.A. Pantskyle SFA Fight For MND SFA Daffodil Day Fund Raiser Brisbane Dolphins Player - BFFCL BFFCL Club Captain Blue Mountain Bounders Player - BFFCL
Jul 23, 2015
19,042
37,273
Adelaide
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Other Teams
Brighton, McLaren F1
Someone like Macrae then would be first picked then, Steven and Ross wouldn't see the side either.

Keep in mind that these teams are backdated to Round 5, so it's more than likely Macrae will feature in the Round 6 side.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Back