Favourite player from each team of all time

[jamesg155]

Fairly straightforward. Post your favourite player from each team at any time in their history (including defunct clubs)
For myself

Adelaide: Mark Ricciuto
Brisbane Bears / Lions: Michael Voss
Carlton: Stephen Silvagni
Collingwood: Gordon Coventry
Essendon: John Coleman
Fitzroy: Bernie Quinlan
Fremantle: Nat Fyfe
Geelong: Gary Ablett Snr
Gold Coast: Gary Ablett Jnr
GWS: Josh Kelly
Hawthorn: Leigh Matthews
Melbourne: Norm Smith
North Melbourne: Malcom Blight
Port Adelaide (Since Their introduction to the AFL): Shaun Burgoyne
Richmond: Jack Dyer
St Kilda: Ian Stewart
South Melbourne / Sydney: Bob Skilton
University FC (No one would've seen this but based on records): Roy Park
West Coast Eagles: Chris Judd
Western Bulldogs / Footscray: Ted Whitten

 

[Hard Ball Get]

Adelaide: Modra
Brisbane Bears / Lions: Michael Voss
Carlton: Greg Williams
Collingwood: Nathan Buckley
Essendon: Jo Daniher and James Hird
Fitzroy: Doug Hawkins
Fremantle: Matthew Pavlich
Geelong: Paul Chapman and Ablett Snr
Gold Coast: Gary Ablett Jnr
GWS: Callan Ward
Hawthorn: Roughead and Pritchard
Melbourne: Jeff Farmer
North Melbourne: Wayne Carey
Port Adelaide: Byron Pickett
Richmond: Rory Hilton
St Kilda: Nick Riewoldt
South Melbourne / Sydney: Paul Kelly and Franklin
University FC: No Idea
West Coast Eagles: Chris Judd and Peter Matera
Western Bulldogs / Footscray: Dale Morris, Brad Johnson, Chris Grant

 

[Roylion]

Adelaide: Peter Caven
Brisbane Bears / Lions: Alistair Lynch
Carlton: Clen Denning
Collingwood: Gary Pert
Essendon: Bill Stephen
Fitzroy: Kevin Murray
Fremantle: Dale Kickett
Geelong: Jack Grant / Ken Hinkley
Gold Coast: Brandon Matera
GWS: Luke Power
Hawthorn: John Barker
Melbourne: Martin Pike
North Melbourne: John Blakey
Port Adelaide: Stephen Paxman
Richmond: Paul Broderick
St Kilda: Tim Pekin
South Melbourne / Sydney: Paul Roos
University: Gilbert Barker
West Coast Eagles: Dean Turner
Western Bulldogs / Footscray: Bernie Quinlan

 

[El Gringo]

Adelaide: Rory Sloane
Brisbane: Jonathan Brown
Carlton: Jeff Garlett
Collingwood: Shane Woewoedin
Essendon: Gary Moorcroft
Fremantle: Matthew Pavlich
Geelong: Gary Ablett Snr
Gold Coast: Harley Bennell
GWS: Shane Mumford
Hawthorn: Stuart Dew
Melbourne: David Neitz
North Melbourne: Byron Pickett
Port Adelaide: Kane Cornes
Richmond: Matthew Knights
St Kilda: Lenny Hayes
Sydney: Tony Lockett
West Coast: Ben Cousins
Western Bulldogs: Tony Liberatore

 

[Snake_Baker]

Adelaide: Modra
Brisbane Bears / Lions: Merrett
Carlton: Jesaulenko
Collingwood: Gavin Brown
Essendon: Simon Madden
Fitzroy: Garry Wilson
Fremantle: Nat Fyfe
Geelong: Gary Hocking
Gold Coast: David Swallow
GWS: Josh Kelly
Hawthorn: John Kennedy snr
Melbourne: Robert Flower
North Melbourne: Wayne Schimmelbusch
Port Adelaide: Byron Pickett
Richmond: Kevin Bartlett
St Kilda: Trevor Barker
South Melbourne / Sydney: Laurie Nash
West Coast Eagles: Chris Judd
Western Bulldogs / Footscray: Doug Hawkins

 

[nickcat0]

Adelaide ..... Andrew McLeod
Brisbane ..... Simon Black
Carlton ..... SOS
Collingwood ..... Nathan Buckley
Essendon ..... Gavin Wanganeen
Fitzroy ..... Bernie Quinlan
Freemantle ..... Nat Fyfe
Geelong ..... Gary Ablett Snr
GCS ..... Gary Ablett Jnr
GWS ..... Josh Kelly
Hawthorn ..... Luke Hodge
Melbourne ..... Adam Yze
North Melbounre ..... Glenn Archer
Port Adelaide ..... Gavin Wanganeen
Richmond ..... Dustin Martin
St Kilda ..... Lenny Hayes
Sydney Swans ..... Tony Lockett
WC Eagles ..... Ben Cousins
Western Bulldogs ..... Bont

 

[TMFKAV]

Adelaide: Darren Jarman
Brisbane: Martin Pike
Carlton: Geoff Southby
Collingwood: Josh Fraser
Essendon: Geoff Blethyn
Fitzroy: Harvey Merrigan
Freo: Peter Bell
Geelong: Doug Scale
Gold Coast: Josh Fraser
GWS: Steve Johnson
Hawthorn: Leigh Matthews
Melbourne: RDB
North: Schimma
Port: Damian Hardwick
Richmond: Dusty
St Kilda: Trevor Barker
South: John Pitura
Sydney: Adam Goodes
Eagles: Peter Matera
Footscray: Ted Whitten

On [device_name] using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[AFDogs]

I'll just do current players only cause my footy knowledge doesn't extend too far back.

Adelaide: Eddie Betts
Brisbane Lions: Mitch Robinson
Carlton: Kade Simpson
Collingwood: Steele Sidebottom
Essendon: Michael Hurley
Fremantle: Nat Fyfe
Geelong: Harry Taylor
Gold Coast: Tom Lynch
GWS: Nick Haynes
Hawthorn: Cyril Rioli
Melbourne: Nathan Jones
North Melbourne: Robbie Tarrant
Port Adelaide: Robbie Gray
Richmond: Trent Cotchin
St Kilda: Tim Membrey
Sydney: Dane Rampe
West Coast Eagles: Jeremy McGovern
Western Bulldogs: Jack Macrae/Bont

 

[Andrewy]

Adelaide: Tony Modra
Brisbane Lions: Michael Voss
Carlton: Greg Williams
Collingwood: Nathan Buckley
Essendon: Tim Watson
Fitzroy: Mick Conlan
Fremantle: Aaron Sandilands
Geelong: Stevie Johnson
Gold Coast: Jarrod Witts
GWS: Heath Shaw
Hawthorn: Dermot Brereton
Melbourne: Jim Stynes
North Melbourne: Wayne Carey
Port Adelaide: Stuart Dew
Richmond: Matthew Richardson
St Kilda: Tony Lockett
Sydney: Paul Kelly
West Coast Eagles: Glen Jakovich
Western Bulldogs: Bob Murphy

 

[raskolnikov]

Adelaide: Wayne Weidemann
Brisbane Lions: Chris Johnson
Carlton: Mil Hanna
Collingwood: Gavin Crosisca
Essendon: Sean Wellman
Fitzroy: Mick Conlan
Fremantle: Aaron Sandilands
Geelong: Steve Hocking
Gold Coast: Aaron Hall
GWS: Josh Kelly
Hawthorn: Jarryd Roughead
Melbourne: Ricky Jackson
North Melbourne: Brett Allison
Port Adelaide: Josh Francou
Richmond: Dusty Martin
St Kilda: Stewart Loewe
Sydney: Adam Goodes
West Coast Eagles: Glen Jakovich
Western Bulldogs: Simon Beasley

 

[tropicaltiger]

Adelaide: modra
Brisbane Bears / Lions: voss
Carlton: fev
Collingwood: daicos
Essendon: hird
Fitzroy: flea wilson
Fremantle: pav
Geelong: couch
Gold Coast: Gary Ablett Jnr
GWS: lids
Hawthorn: Leigh Matthews
Melbourne: stynes
North Melbourne: Malcom Blight
Port Adelaide: tredrae
Richmond: richoman
St Kilda: lockett
South Melbourne / Sydney: Bob Skilton
University FC (No one would've seen this but based on records): iva biggun
West Coast Eagles: cousins
Western Bulldogs / Footscray: leon cameron

 

[Mico89]

Adelaide: Nathan Van Berlo
Brisbane: Jonathan brown
Carlton: Brendan fevola
Collingwood: Dane Swan
Essendon: David Zaharakis
Fremantle: Luke Mcpharlin
Geelong: Jimmy Bartel
Gold Coast: Touk Miller
GWS: Jeremy Cameron
Hawthorn: Sam mitchell
Melbourne: Jordan Lewis
North Melbourne: Brent Harvey
Port Adelaide: Robbie Gray
Richmond: Alex Rance
St Kilda: Lenny Hayes
Sydney: Barry Hall
West Coast Eagles: Beau waters
Western Bulldogs: Matthew Boyd

 

[Adelaide Hawk]

Adelaide: Darren Jarman
Brisbane Bears / Lions: Simon Black
Carlton: Alex Jesaulenko
Collingwood: Phil Carman
Essendon: Simon Madden
Fitzroy: Garry Wilson
Fremantle: Matthew Pavlich
Geelong: Gary Ablett sr
Gold Coast: Tom Lynch
GWS: Toby Greene
Hawthorn: Peter Hudson
Melbourne: Robbie Flower
North Melbourne: Malcolm Blight
Port Adelaide: Shaun Burgoyne
Richmond: Francis Bourke
St Kilda: Tony Lockett
South Melbourne / Sydney: Bob Skilton
West Coast Eagles: Peter Matera
Western Bulldogs / Footscray: Gary Dempsey

 

[Jade]

Adelaide: Tony Modra . Awesome to watch. I watched Crows games just to see this bloke jumping on peoples heads.

Brisbane Bears / Lions: Roger Merrett - You might think Essendon bias, but actually I just loved watching the big fella run around.

Carlton: Hmmm... Steve Silvagni. Although, I'm not sure its possible for me to have a player I like from the Blues.

Collingwood: Sav Rocca. The big fella scared me, but geez was fun to watch.

Essendon: James Hird. Next.

Fitzroy: Has to be Alastair Lynch.

Fremantle: Matthew Pavlich, tough to go past him.

Geelong: Big fan of Jimmy Bartel.

Gold Coast: Probably Gary Ablett Jr. Don't rate him as a leader, but bloody hell he can play.

GWS: The general Jon Patton.

Hawthorn: Pass.

Melbourne: Allen Jakovich.

North Melbourne: Tough one. John Longmire.

Port Adelaide: Has to be Wanganeen, and yes, full Essendon bias.

Richmond: Matthew Richardson in a canter.

St Kilda: Nick Riewoldt. Easily. EASILY.

South Melbourne / Sydney: I'd probably say Ted Richards.

West Coast Eagles: Ben Cousins.

Western Bulldogs / Footscray: Simon Atkins.

 

[TazHawk15]

Adelaide: Tony Modra . Awesome to watch. I watched Crows games just to see this bloke jumping on peoples heads.

Brisbane Bears / Lions: Roger Merrett - You might think Essendon bias, but actually I just loved watching the big fella run around.

Carlton: Hmmm... Steve Silvagni. Although, I'm not sure its possible for me to have a player I like from the Blues.

Collingwood: Sav Rocca. The big fella scared me, but geez was fun to watch.

Essendon: James Hird. Next.

Fitzroy: Has to be Alastair Lynch.

Fremantle: Matthew Pavlich, tough to go past him.

Geelong: Big fan of Jimmy Bartel.

Gold Coast: Probably Gary Ablett Jr. Don't rate him as a leader, but bloody hell he can play.

GWS: The general Jon Patton.

Hawthorn: Just like Jimmy Hird I am so arse sore about the Hawks I care bare to even think of them

Melbourne: Allen Jakovich.

North Melbourne: Tough one. John Longmire.

Port Adelaide: Has to be Wanganeen, and yes, full Essendon bias.

Richmond: Matthew Richardson in a canter.

St Kilda: Nick Riewoldt. Easily. EASILY.

South Melbourne / Sydney: I'd probably say Ted Richards.

West Coast Eagles: Ben Cousins.

Western Bulldogs / Footscray: Simon Atkins.

Nice.

 

[Adelaide Hawk]

Hawthorn: Pass.

That's fair enough. I had to go back to the 1970s to find an Essendon player I didn't mind as much as the others.

 

[Occidental]

Ad - D Jarman
Br - S Black
Ca - K Hunter
Co - Swanny
Es - L Baker
Fi - G Wilson
Fr - Pav
GC - T Miller
GWS - T Greene
Gee - Ablett sen
Haw - Roughy
Mel - R Flower
NM - G Archer
PA - R Gray
Ric - Richo
StK - Plugger
Syd - P Kelly
WC - Cuz
WB - S West

 

[Wallaby]

I'm going historic

Adelaide - Modra
Brisbane - Aker
Carlton - Jesaulenko
Collingwood - Len Thompson
Essendon - Watson
Fitzroy - Garry Wilson
Fremantle - Hayden
Geelong - Snr
Gold Coast - None spring to mind
GWS - "
Hawthorn - Hudson
Melbourne - Flower
North - Schimmelbusch
Port - Tredrea
Richmond - KB
St Kilda - Bob Murray
Sydney - Kelly
Bulldogs - Dempsey
West Coast - Judd

 

[SouthSwans]

Adelaide - Matty Mattner
Brisbane Bears - Warwick Capper
Brisbane Lions - Craig Bolton
Carlton - Peter Bedford
Collingwood - Paul Williams
Essendon - Ted Richards
Fitzroy - Paul Roos
Fremantle - Troy Cook
Geelong - Greg Williams
Gold Coast - Nick Malceski
GWS Giants - Shane Mumford
Hawthorn - Josh Kennedy
Melbourne - Gerard Healy
North Melbourne - John Longmire
Port Adelaide - Stuart Dew
Richmond - Stuart Maxfield
St Kilda - Tony Lockett
Sydney - Adam Goodes
West Coast - Callum Sinclair
Western Buldogs - Barry Round

 

[Pumpernickel]

Adelaide - Troy Bond
Brisbane - Voss
Carlton - Bradley
Collingwood - Pendles
Essendon - Allan Ezard
Fitzroy - Mick Conlan
Fremantle - Clive Waterhouse
Geelong - Snr
Gold Coast - Jnr
GWS - Stevie J
Hawthorn - Crawford
Melbourne - Flower
North - Blight
Port - Shane Brewer
Richmond - Richo
St Kilda - Lenny Hayes
Sydney - Jarrod McVeigh
Bulldogs - Teddy
West Coast - Judd

 

[Herne Hill Hammer]

Adelaide : Tony Modra
Brisbane : Michael Voss
Carlton : Greg Williams
Collingwood : Gavin Brown
Essendon : Darren Bewick
Fitzroy : Micky Conlan
Fremantle : Nat Fyfe
Footscray : Jason Akermanis (needed to get him in)
Geelong : Snr
Gold Coast : Steven May
GWS : Steve Johnson
Hawthorn : Jason Dunstall
Melbourne : Peter Moore
North Melbourne : Wayne Carey
Port Adelaide : Chad Cornes
Richmond : Geoff Raines
St Kilda : David Grant
Sydney : Paul Kelly
West Coast : Brett Heady

Couldn't get Darren Jarman or KHunter in. I needed to get Diesel in somewhere and I couldn't have him at Sydney due to Paul Kelly. Love Darren Jarman too but I'd have him behind both Dunstall and Hudson at Hawthorn and I loved watching Godra. I've liked a lot of Footscray players over the years with no real stand out so it was a chance to get Aker in who is in my starting 18 of the best players I've seen over 40+ years.

Gavin Brown and David Grant along with Tony Hall are three of the most courageous players I've ever seen in the air.

 

[Feraligatr]

Adelaide : Tony Modra
Brisbane : Michael Voss
Carlton : Stephen Silvagni
Collingwood :Scott Pendlebury
Essendon : Matthew Lloyd
Fitzroy : Paul Roos
Fremantle : Nat Fyfe
Footscray : Chris Grant
Geelong : Whiskas Hocking
Gold Coast : Aaron Hall
GWS : Dylan Sheil
Hawthorn : Jason Dunstall
Melbourne : David Neitz
North Melbourne : Wayne Carey
Port Adelaide : Robbie Grey
Richmond : Matthew Richardson
St Kilda : Robert harvey
Sydney : Tony Lockett
West Coast : Phillip Matera

 

[Drewie11]

Adelaide : Kane Johnson
Brisbane : Simon Black
Carlton : Patrick Cripps
Collingwood :Gavin Brown
Essendon : Gavin Wanganeen
Fremantle : Nat Fyfe
Footscray : Ryan Hargraves
Geelong : Joel Corey
Gold Coast : Aaron Hall
GWS : Dylan Sheil
Hawthorn : Gary Buckenara
Melbourne : Max Gawn
North Melbourne : Wayne Carey
Port Adelaide : Chad Cornes
Richmond : Dustin Martin
St Kilda : Nick Reiwoldt
Sydney : Michael O’loughlin
West Coast : Chris Judd

 

[Allotan]

Essendon: John Coleman
Melbourne: Jeff Farmer
North Melbourne: Wayne Carey
Gold Coast: Brandon Matera
Western Bulldogs: Tony Liberatore
GCS: Gary Ablett Jnr
Port Adelaide: Robbie Gray
Fremantle - Troy Cook

 

[HairyO]

Only choosing people I have seen play.

Adelaide: D Jarman
Brisbane Bears / Lions: Aker
Carlton: Williams
Collingwood: Daicos
Essendon: Salmon
Fitzroy: Quinlan
Fremantle: Bell
Geelong: Chapman
Gold Coast: None
GWS: None
Hawthorn: Derm
Melbourne: Flower
North Melbourne: Blight
Port Adelaide: S Burgoyne
Richmond: KB
St Kilda: Plugger
South Melbourne / Sydney: Capper
West Coast Eagles: Kerr
Western Bulldogs / Footscray: Johnson