Deliberate is now OK if you need to kick the ball

Remove this Banner Ad

Arc1

Club Legend
Jul 5, 2009
2,110
4,262
AFL Club
Hawthorn
Not sure many people will have watched the non-top 8 clash last night, but there was a quite extraordinary moment late on - an Adelaide player was tackled near the boundary, facing the crowd, in their back pocket. He kicked it directly out of bounds, about 150 degrees away from the Adelaide goal.

Decision: throw it in.

When the Hawthorn players complained wanting ‘deliberate’, the umpire’s response (I think Razor Ray) was “He had to kick it”.

The umps had been quite sharp on incorrect disposal (a welcome return to actual footy instead of everyone just dropping the ball), but what a bizarre decision.

Kind of like saying you it’s OK to fend off high if you’d otherwise get caught holding the ball.

I’ve got to assume it’s just one of those brain fart moments rather than a correct decision?
 
Umm, what?

The player has the right to the dispose of the ball, and if they happen to be facing the boundary at the time while being tackled it would be absolutely ludicrous to penalise someone for 'deliberate' when they are trying to get rid of the ball.

Ray made the absolute correct decision, and if we ever got to a stage where players cannot dispose of the ball when being tackled near the boundary for fear of it rolling out and being judged as "deliberate" the game will be completely cooked.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top