Traded Dayne Beams [traded with #41 and #43 to Collingwood for #18, #56 and future 1st round pick]

[The Plowking]

You will get picks back this year to help you with your bids but Dodongo poses how much is a flag worth to you? 1 first or 2 firsts? With Beams you will be favourites next year. If you had him this year you may have won. For a flag giving up two late teen picks is nothing

So where is this Beams playing?
KPF or KPD? Cos, you know...

 

[The Plowking]

If we have to we can send Frost back - would prefer not as he is a key piece, but you gotta give up quality to get quality in.

We'll do the old switcharoo with his brother at Melbourne. Let them have the dud (but probably nice guy and that)

 

[royboys4eva]

Why would you say that??

Funny ive been called a troll by a Lion and a Magpie??

How does that make sense

Throwing up Oxley and Smith who are not in the Pies best 25 players probably not in the best 28! Greenwood is not of any interest to the Lions and didn't he recently sign a new contract?

Remember what might suit Collingwood will more than likely not interest the Lions and Beams is contracted.

Try again.

 

[Tom14]

We'll do the old switcharoo with his brother at Melbourne. Let them have the dud (but probably nice guy and that)

They are far too busy getting angry at Freo to notice, good plan

 

[The Plowking]

Throwing up Oxley and Smith who are not in the Pies best 25 players probably not in the best 28! Greenwood is not of any interest to the Lions and didn't he recently sign a new contract?

Remember what might suit Collingwood will more than likely not interest the Lions and Beams is contracted.

Try again.

It was a laughable suggestion!

And I don't even want beams back

 

[scoman]

Alright, alright I've heard enough! We'll keep him then.

If only

 

[Tom14]

It was a laughable suggestion!

And I don't even want beams back

Yeah getting Beams but losing Oxley? Not worth it imo

 

[The Plowking]

They are far too busy getting angry at Freo to notice, good plan

Would you be interested in our Hobbit?
He's a premiership player. Really really tries to stick a tackle and nearly does sometimes. Kicked a ripper goal from the boundary whilst getting tackled once? I'm sure he might have done something else once. Maybe.

 

[nahnah]

If he wasn’t worth two firsts when he was 25 how the * is he worth two firsts now dodongo

 

[scoman]

If he wasn’t worth two firsts when he was 25 how the **** is he worth two firsts now dodongo

There is a big difference between pick 5 and pick 18 for starters.

 

[Stifler's mom]

Comes across as a person of extremely s**t character.

Brian Lake s**t?

 

[Tom14]

If he wasn’t worth two firsts when he was 25 how the **** is he worth two firsts now dodongo

Of course he isn't worth two firsts. I'll be happy if we somehow get it though!

 

[TheSandman35]

List cloggers. Considering we're extremely tight for list spots right now I'm pretty sure no players will be involved in this deal. If Beams moves on, that open up a spot for Neale but other than that there's no room for anyone. It will be picks alone.

Pick 18 + Greenwood + Phillips

Final offer

 

[The Plowking]

If he wasn’t worth two firsts when he was 25 how the **** is he worth two firsts now dodongo

Dodrunko.
It's ok.
#metoo

 

[royboys4eva]

If he wasn’t worth two firsts when he was 25 how the **** is he worth two firsts now dodongo

Finished top ten in the Brownlow this year. You got pick 5 (De Goey) a second round pick and a player. So you did fine. I think he is worth a pick in the top ten and I'm not particularly interested in future picks.

Would expect the Lions will drive a hard bargain.

 

[scoman]

Finished top ten in the Brownlow this year. You got pick 5 (De Goey) a second round pick and a player. So you did fine. I think he is worth a pick in the top ten and I'm not particularly interested in future picks.

Would expect the Lions will drive a hard bargain.

Im sure we will try. History suggests we will get what we are given and we will all just have to pretend we like it.

 

[TheSandman35]

Yeah getting Beams but losing Oxley? Not worth it imo

Would you prefer Tom Phillips and pick 18?

 

[Stifler's mom]

I'd take Thomas + 18 if a deal had to be done. He's had a huge impact on our culture and with what he's going through he's earnt a move back if he wants it. Not ideal but that's life.

Thomas is a QLDer and would slot straight into our team.

How would that go for Pies?

Think this would be a fair trade. Thomas is not a list clogger like Oxley or Smith, so I won’t insult you with that type of suggestion.
The fact that Thomas recently signed a contract is proven to count for zero.

If Brisbane want him and sweeten his contract, I’m sure it would be considered by him.

Seems a balanced trade suggestion.
Time would prove who wins that potential deal.

 

[anotherletdown]

My idea of fair is Collingwood future first + 18 for Beams, 32 + 44

 

[SA HAWK]

Brian Lake s**t?

Yes.

 

[schmuttt]

Don't have a dog in this fight at all (Like the lions much more than the pies) but pick 18 and Pies 2019 2nd would be around the mark IMO. The age and injury history of Beams is what drags his value down significantly here.

 

[nahnah]

There is a big difference between pick 5 and pick 18 for starters.

There’s a big difference between a 25 year old and a 29 year old

 

[TheSandman35]

Think this would be a fair trade. Thomas is not a list clogger like Oxley or Smith, so I won’t insult you with that type of suggestion.
The fact that Thomas recently signed a contract is proven to count for zero.

If Brisbane want him and sweeten his contract, I’m sure it would be considered by him.

Seems a balanced trade suggestion.
Time would prove who wins that potential deal.

Your dreaming, no way we trade Jet Thomas, Tom Phillips yes, not Thomas

 

[Tom14]

Would you prefer Tom Phillips and pick 18?

I actually don't mind Phillips but I don't think any players would be involved given they'd have to agree to come to Brisbane and there are 4 days until trade period shuts. Not a lot of time to think about moving cities.

It'll be picks if it happens.

 

[scoman]

There’s a big difference between a 25 year old and a 29 year old

Indeed.