List Mgmt. Trade & F/A - 2018/2019 - Part 3

[DaVe86]

Guess I can tune out for the Day.

but Why simple trade take to last hour or so?

Shows the Mega Deal is Holding everything up.

Guess be no trades be done until This evening/Night

I just don't understand how teams trade.

The Roughead deal is simple. It's just a late pick. I have no idea why we can't just get it done, signed off and then move on as opposed to having to rush to do it at the end.

Hawthorn gets all their small deals done quickly. Scully and Scrimshaw just got done. No need to wait for Wingard of the other dominos to fall.

My opinion is to get your deals done quickly, so you have more time to address other list areas.

Perhaps teams aren't as concerned about pick swaps this year as there is live trading....but I'd still think you want to leave yourself a few hours at the end to see if any last minute options are available.

 

[Unknown Identity]

Can't believe Hawks are trading Burton.
Going to be a gem of a player.

 

[ottoman]

Anywho....
Trade week really is a bit of a joke.
This "it will all come down to the last minutes" stuff, really? why?
I know some are saying it is for the TV broadcast but it happens every year.
If they don't cut it down to 3 days next year then I'm done...

 

[Cousin of Daicos]

Anywho....
Trade week really is a bit of a joke.
This "it will all come down to the last minutes" stuff, really? why?
I know some are saying it is for the TV broadcast but it happens every year.
If they don't cut it down to 3 days next year then I'm done...

As far as I’m concerned make it one day.

 

[ash84]

Not bothered if we get beams or not, I think its negligent list managing if we spend 2 firsts on a 29 year old.

We get Beams cool.
We don't and draft Collier-Dawkins, cool.

 

[ottoman]

As far as I’m concerned make it one day.

Everything would still get done.
They would prepare in advance and get it sorted.

 

[Scribe26]

I can't believe these blokes are sitting in a studio at 10am wearing suits and bow ties. You've got to be kidding.

That's the gag mate. They're taking the piss out of themselves.

 

[Scribe26]

Anywho....
Trade week really is a bit of a joke.
This "it will all come down to the last minutes" stuff, really? why?
I know some are saying it is for the TV broadcast but it happens every year.
If they don't cut it down to 3 days next year then I'm done...

Done with what?

 

[Baltimore Jack]

Guess I can tune out for the Day.

but Why simple trade take to last hour or so?

Shows the Mega Deal is Holding everything up.

Guess be no trades be done until This evening/Night

Dave, I think you have hit 200

200 what, you say?

200 times you have complained about a trade not getting done

Do you think you have it covered by now?
Do you think that by mentioning it 200 times, it will speed things up?

 

[The Dawes]

Geelong want Pick 20, 22 and 2019 First round pick for Tim Kelly.

Hahahaaaaaaa..

The Geelong Bears!

picks 20 & 22 is more than fair for a player who is at the end of the day a one season wonder.

Geelong are being knobs.

 

[jackcass]

Guess I can tune out for the Day.

but Why simple trade take to last hour or so?

Shows the Mega Deal is Holding everything up.

Guess be no trades be done until This evening/Night

Imagine how excited you'll be when we end up with pick 2 at the draft.

 

[ottoman]

I'm thinking about buying a car today.
I know exactly which make and model I want, but instead of going to the dealer in the afternoon I've decided to wait till they are just about to close up for the day then I'm going to quickly rush in and do the deal.
Makes sense. I'm going to pay the same price get the same car but I'm going to leave it to the last second. That'll show em.

Anywho...
What's the latest on the Monopoly deal.

 

[MagpieJoel]

Imagine the melts if the Beams trade isn't done by 6pm tonight.

 

[The Dawes]

Brisbane giving up 5 and Beams for Neale and Thomas is fairly ridiculous.

agreed - virtually saying Josh Thomas is worth pick 5.

 

[swoop42]

So if it gets to 6pm and a deal for Beams looks very unlikely can anyone think of a realistic trade for pick 18 and a future selection that could be of benefit?

Any teams have high calibre FS/Academy prospects next season?

Perhaps if Geelong or West Coast did we could land picks 20 and 22 for pick 18 and a future 2nd.

Pick 20 would cover a bid for Quaynor from pick 15 onwards while 22 should remain live before a bid for Kelly came.

Adelaide with pick 21 though could potentially be a problem with 1 Kelly brother already on the list.

Pick 18 and future 1st to Fremantle for pick 11 and 30.

Potentially risky but a bid for Quaynor unlikely prior to this point. Pick 30 would deliver 620pts.

Pick 18 might be enough for Fremantle to satisfy GWS for Lobb.

 

[ottoman]

Done with what?

Just done re.
You don't ask what?
There is no answer to that.
Seriously if posters on here keep asking questions like this then I'm done...I've f***en had it

 

[MagpieJoel]

Port's 35 to Lions for Mayes is happening apparently.

Lions have 6 instead of 5 too now. So wonder what it impact it will have on Neale trade.

 

[Scribe26]

picks 20 & 22 is more than fair for a player who is at the end of the day a one season wonder.

Geelong are being knobs.

I think, if you've only played one season, you're not a one-season wonder, you're just a wonder.

No doubt, they're asking for more than what we think the guy (who I agree, is overrated), but they're in a position of strength.

Geelong gave the guy a lifeline after 18 clubs overlooked him for 5 years. 12 months later and he's requesting to break a contract and go to the reigning premier.

He can stay, play out his deal and West Coast can have another crack next season if they don't pony up this year. Geelong run the risk of him getting injured or losing value, but I still think it's logical business.

 

[Visions]

https://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/...ive-coverage/f96639ab470fd79b180e8fb9d6b2cf85

So the Dockers have softened on Neale. That means they can accept out future second as part of a Beams deal and Brisbane can keep pick 18 from this year. Easy.


Wouldn’t you love it if it takes all day to agree on this huge multi club mega deal and then at 8.00pm tonight Collingwood refuse to sign off on it and leaves everyone in limbo as they were. That would be sticking it right up the rest of the comp.

 

[Unknown Identity]

PA: 5, 15, Burton, Mayes
Brisbane: 6, 35 and future 3rd
Hawks: Wingard

 

[ottoman]

Wouldn’t you love it if it takes all day to agree on this huge multi club mega deal and then at 8.00pm tonight Collingwood refuse to sign off on it and leaves everyone in limbo as they were. That would be sticking it right up the rest of the comp.

I would love for something like this to happen.
Maybe then in future years clubs wouldn't be so keen to leave it to the last minute.

 

[Kilmo]

So the Dockers have softened on Neale. That means they can accept out future second as part of a Beams deal and Brisbane can keep pick 18 from this year. Easy.



Wouldn’t you love it if it takes all day to agree on this huge multi club mega deal and then at 8.00pm tonight Collingwood refuse to sign off on it and leaves everyone in limbo as they were. That would be sticking it right up the rest of the comp.

Haha I would be disappointed to miss out on Beams but it would be pretty good if we actually had no interest in him the whole time and were bluffing to screw everyone else’s trades

“Beams? What made you guys think we wanted a midfielder?? “

 

[bencoop]

So the Dockers have softened on Neale. That means they can accept out future second as part of a Beams deal and Brisbane can keep pick 18 from this year. Easy.



Wouldn’t you love it if it takes all day to agree on this huge multi club mega deal and then at 8.00pm tonight Collingwood refuse to sign off on it and leaves everyone in limbo as they were. That would be sticking it right up the rest of the comp.

This would absolutely make my day, then low ball brisbane and screw everything up.

 

[The Dawes]

I think, if you've only played one season, you're not a one-season wonder, you're just a wonder.

No doubt, they're asking for more than what we think the guy (who I agree, is overrated), but they're in a position of strength.

Geelong gave the guy a lifeline after 18 clubs overlooked him for 5 years. 12 months later and he's requesting to break a contract and go to the reigning premier.

He can stay, play out his deal and West Coast can have another crack next season if they don't pony up this year. Geelong run the risk of him getting injured or losing value, but I still think it's logical business.

agree that Geelong can quite rightly feel miffed by Kelly wanting out after one year when they were the ones who gave him an AFL opportunity.

But what WC have offered is fair.

Just wonder how Kelly will go next year if a deal isn't done and what his value will be if his second season doesn't live up to the promise of his first.... WC could potentially get him considerably cheaper next year, which is reallly why I reckon Geelong would be advised to take up their offer.

 

[sr36]

I'm hearing rumours about a massive deal involving Peter Jackson suits. Should know more after I talk to a couple of mates in the know.