List Records & Bests - Highest Losing Score (ex-fp discussion)

[Mobbs]

[Index of 'Records & Bests']

Thread was originally posted by : Paul Nowland (converted if I know the BF handle) on yuku.

Policies
On the old footypedia forums we argued the toss over what counted. When time allows, those arguments should also be replicated here, for further assessment.
Policy & relevant discussion not yet transferred

Latest Table :
(originally posted by Footypedia on Yuku)

All Regions :
163 - Vic - Geelong 25.13.163 wdb Hawthorn 26.15.171 - VFL - 1989.
159 - Vic - Kangaroos 25.9.159 wdb Essendon 27.9.171 - VFL - 2001.
157 - Vic - Fitzroy 23.19.157 wdb Melbourne 24.23.167 VFL - 1978.
156 - SA - 24.12.156 North Adelaide wdb Norwood 26.22.178 - SANFL - 1975.
155 - Vic - South Melbourne 24.11.155 wdb Geelong 26.11.167 - VFL - 1978.
154 - Vic - South Melbourne 24.10.154 wdb Melbourne 24.23.167 - VFL - 1979.
154 - Tas - New Norfolk 24.10.154 wdb Glenorchy 26.11.167 - TANFL - 1983.
153 - Vic - South Melbourne 23.15.153 wdb Geelong 25.7.157 - VFL - 1976.
153 - SA - 23.15.153 West Adelaide wdb Woodville 25.13.163 - SANFL - 1984.
152 - SA - 23.14.152 West Torrens wdb Central District 27.17.179 - SANFL - 1976.

Vic :
163 - Vic - Geelong 25.13.163 wdb Hawthorn 26.15.171 - VFL - 1989.
159 - Vic - Kangaroos 25.9.159 wdb Essendon 27.9.171 - VFL - 2001.
157 - Vic - Fitzroy 23.19.157 wdb Melbourne 24.23.167 VFL - 1978.
155 - Vic - South Melbourne 24.11.155 wdb Geelong 26.11.167 - VFL - 1978.
154 - Vic - South Melbourne 24.10.154 wdb Melbourne 24.23.167 - VFL - 1979.
153 - Vic - South Melbourne 23.15.153 wdb Geelong 25.7.157 - VFL - 1976.
152 - Vic - North Melbourne 23.14.152 wdb Fitzroy 25.16.166 - VFL - 1984.
150 - Vic - Richmond 22.18.150 wdb carlton 28.9.177 - VFL - 1972.

Tas :
154 - Tas - New Norfolk 24.10.154 wdb Glenorchy 26.11.167 - TANFL - 1983.
149 - Tas - Mount Pleasant 23.11.149 wdb Woodsdale 22.19.151 - Oatlands DFL - 1973.
140 - Tas - New Norfolk 21.14.140 wdb North Hobart 24.19.163 - TFL Statewide FL - 1989.
139 - Tas - North Launceston 21.13.139 wdb Hobart 22.9.141 - TFL Statewide FL - 1989.
136 - Tas - Cooee 21.10.136 wdb Smithton 20.17.137 - NWFU - 1983.
131 - Tas - Longford 20.11.131 wdb North Launceston 24.24.168 - NTFA - 1977.

SA :
156 - SA - 24.12.156 North Adelaide wdb Norwood 26.22.178 - SANFL - 1975.
153 - SA - 23.15.153 West Adelaide wdb Woodville 25.13.163 - SANFL - 1984.
152 - SA - 23.14.152 West Torrens wdb Central District 27.17.179 - SANFL - 1976.
151 - SA - 23.13.151 Central District wdb South Adelaide 26.11.167 - SANFL - 1976.
151 - SA - 23.13.151 West Torrens wdb Woodville 29.11.185 - SANFL - 1982.
150 - SA - 22.18.150 West Adelaide wdb Woodville 25.25.175 - SANFL - 1985.
149 - SA - 23.11.149 Glenelg wdb West Adelaide 29.13.187 - SANFL - 1983.
148 - SA - 23.10.148 Woodville wdb West Adelaide 29.16.190 - SANFL - 1984.
147 - SA - 22.15.147 West Torrens wdb Woodville 23.13.151 - SANFL - 1983.
146 - SA - 23.8.146 Woodville wdb South Adelaide 24.21.165 - SANFL - 1973.

Was more content added to yuku after the final table update? - Yes

Original discussion : Footypedia Messageboard on Yuku Boards (lapsed)


- This documentation is replicated from old messageboards associated with the footypedia website. The website's back up, but I won't be supporting the messageboard system.
- This list may already be duplicated on Bigfooty, on this very forum. I'm just tranferring data. If there is a duplicate, add a link here and we can work on a process of integration.

 

[Todman]

180 - Coolaroo Rovers 27.18.180 (v Kooyong Park 31.6.192) Panton Hill FL – 1987 2nd Semi Final

 

[Mr Mister]

The highest reserve losing score was achieved by Collingwood kicking a ridiculous 29.8(182) against Hawthorn's 30.17(197) back in 1982. There was literally a goal kicked every two minutes on average.

 

[Connor7395]

Some from the eighties

157 - Vic - Mitcham 23.19.157 wdb Vermont 24.19.163 - Eastern Districts FL Div. 1 - 1981
155 - Vic - Doncaster 23.17.155 wdb Bennettswood 26.15.171 - Eastern Districts FL Div. 2 - 1982
152 - Vic - Montrose 23.14.152 wdb Forest Hill 24.20.164 - Eastern Districts FL Div. 3 - 1980

No idea when this happened, but australianfootball.com added every YVMDFL result going back to the 1988 season. Only one +150 result makes the list.

151 - Vic - Monbulk 23.13.151 wdb Olinda-Ferny Creek 30.15.195 - YVMDFL Div. 1 - 1992

New additions down here whenever I find them:

167 - NSW - North Shore 25.17.167 wdb Western Suburbs 26.22.178 - Sydney FL - 1983
157 - Vic - Sandhurst 23.19.157 wdb Eaglehawk 24.15.159 - Bendigo FL - 1980
156 - Vic - Cheltenham Assumption 23.18.156 wdb Moorabbin West 25.20.170 - Southern FL Div. 4 - 1994
154 - Vic - Clayton 23.16.154 wdb Donvale 26.15.171 - Eastern FL Div. 1 - 1996
153 - Vic - Broadford 24.9.153 wdb Woodend-Hesket 23.19.157 - Riddell DFL - 1982
152 - Vic - Croydon 24.8.152 wdb Lilydale 23.17.155 - Eastern FL Div. 2 - 1992


Unrelated, but interesting so I put it here.

Thomastown 34.20.224 def Balaclava 20.13.133 in 1982. The quarter by quarter scores were 4.10-2.3, 8.5-3.5, 11.3-7.2, 11.2-8.3. That means in the second half, Thomastown kicked 22.5.137 to Balaclava's 15.5.95 for an aggregate score of 37.10.232 in a single half of football. That's got to be some kind of record for a game that remained competitive to some degree...


Since I can't find a lowest winning score thread, I'll post some finds here too.

12 - Old Essendon 1.6.12 def Old Geelong 1.5.11 - VAFA E Section - 1988

 

[Connor7395]

175 - Vic - Mount Waverley 29.10.184 def South Melbourne District 27.13.175 - South East Suburban FL Division 1 - 1991

One to challenge Coolaroo Rovers.

 

[Connor7395]

162 - Vic - Omeo/Benambra 24.18.162 wdb Bruthen 25.16.166 - Omeo DFL - 2011

 

[Connor7395]

169 - Edithvale/Aspendale 26.13.169 wdb Hastings 27.10.172 - MPNFL Premier Division - 1999
157 - Albert Park 23.19.157 wdb Eley Park 25.10.160 - VAFA F Section - 1999
151 - Bundoora 25.12.162 def Diamond Creek 22.19.151 - Diamond Valley FL Div. 1 - 1983

 

[Connor7395]

159 - Vic - Saint Andrew's Presbyterian 24.15.159 wdb Trinity Presbyterian 31.15.201 - Eastern Suburban Churches FA C Grade - 1978

 

[Connor7395]

From the SAAFL between 1988 and 1999

160 - SA - Lockleys 25.10.160 wdb Unley 27.11.173 - SAAFL Div. A5 - 1992
151 - SA - Woodville South 24.7.151 wdb Port District 24.20.164 - SAAFL Div. A2 - 1991
148 - SA - State Transport Authority 23.10.148 wdb West Lakes 26.15.171 - SAAFL Div. A5 - 1993
148 - SA - Ovingham 23.10.148 wdb West Lakes 27.22.184 - SAAFL Div. A5 - 1992
148 - SA - Ovingham 23.10.148 wdb Ingle Farm 24.15.159 - SAAFL Div. A5 - 1992
144 - SA - Lockleys 22.12.144 wdb Adelaide University 24.14.158 - SAAFL Div. A5 - 1992
144 - SA - SMOSH 22.12.144 wdb Rosewater 24.19.163 - SAAFL Div. A3 - 1988
142 - SA - Seaton Ramblers 22.10.142 wdb Brighton Districts and Old Scholars 28.16.184 - SAAFL Div. A2 - 1992
141 - SA - Glandore 21.15.141 wdb Scotch Old Collegians 26.8.164 - SAAFL Div. 2 - 1999
141 - SA - Fitzroy 23.3.141 wdb Rosewater 23.14.152 - SAAFL Div. A3 - 1990
140 - SA - Modbury 21.14.140 wdb Fitzroy 24.10.154 - SAAFL Div. A3 - 1992

 

[Connor7395]

One from April 1994 that needs a check.

156 or 166 - Vic - Lake Boga 26.0.156 or 26.10.166 wdb Swan Hill 24.26.170 - Mid Murray FL - 1994

The Age has 26.0 but that surely isn't possible. It could be 26.10 or 26.9.

 

[Connor7395]

148 - SA - Langhorne Creek 23.16.154 d Victor Harbour 23.10.148 - Great Southern FL - 1983
147 - SA - Wallaroo 28.17.185 d Maitland 22.15.147 - Yorke Valley FL - 1983
146 - SA - Mount Compass 23.11.149 d Milang 22.14.146 - Great Southern FL - 1984
146 - SA - Encounter Bay 26.21.177 d Goolwa 22.14.146 - Great Southern FL - 1985
145 - SA - Yankalilla 24.7.151 d Encounter Bay 22.13.145 - Great Southern FL - 1992
144 - SA - Langhorne Creek 26.13.169 d Victor Harbor 21.18.144 - Great Southern FL - 1985
142 - SA - Encounter Bay 28.20.188 d Strathalbyn 21.16.142 - Great Southern FL - 1985
140 - SA - Port Elliot 28.22.190 d Encounter Bay 21.14.140 - Great Southern FL - 1985