Search results

Remove this Banner Ad

  1. N

    Autopsy post mortem v hawks

    Brown has kicked the most goals of anyone over the past 3 years. He had an absolute shocker and still wasn’t that far behind Xerri. On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
  2. N

    Autopsy post mortem v hawks

    Regardless of the result I would have the same opinion. I have been critical of bringing in Xerri each week, with a lot of people wanting him in. It just doesn’t work structurally in my view to play a ruckman as a permanent forward. I would have stuck with wood or given Hosie a shot. Hosie has...
  3. N

    Autopsy post mortem v hawks

    I did watch the footage and all I saw was a ruckman being played out of position. You were as critical as anyone over our pre-season. Yes he took some contested marks, but structurally we looked horrible. Again he is a RUCKMAN not a forward. A McEvoy/Xerri comparison is completely irrelevant...
  4. N

    Autopsy post mortem v hawks

    He is a ruckman playing as a forward. Pure insanity. On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
  5. N

    Autopsy post mortem v hawks

    Don’t play Xerri or Campbell forward ffs, they’re RUCKMAN. Nothing against Xerri, he did the best he could and I am sure his time will come to play in his preferred role. But playing him as a permanent forward is insane. We have tried playing two rucks in the past, other sides have tried it and...
  6. N

    Autopsy post mortem v hawks

    Round 1 - Ziebell goes off with second half comeback. Round 4 - Ziebell goes off with last quarter comeback. Sorry, but he is cooked. I would be shocked if he plays beyond 2021. Don’t play 2 ruckmen,it is just f**king dumb. On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
  7. N

    Preview Round 4: Changes and prematch discussion vs Hawthorn

    Stop smoking billies billy On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
  8. N

    Preview Round 4: Changes and prematch discussion vs Hawthorn

    You’re bringing in 3 players for 3 players out, but Cunnington was already out. On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
  9. N

    Player Watch #16: Aiden Bonar

    Yep. The only thing worse than Bonar’s game was that comment. On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
  10. N

    Preview Round 3 North vs Swans Saturday 1:45 pm: Changes & pre match discussion @Marvel

    They made two grand finals just after he arrived. I guess you can argue it wasn’t a success, but they definitely didn’t go backwards. On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
  11. N

    Preview Round 3 North vs Swans Saturday 1:45 pm: Changes & pre match discussion @Marvel

    Where has all this noise come from that Ahern has come back out of shape? He looks the same as he always has, he just has that type of body. I just can’t imagine Shaw playing someone second week back after coming back out of shape, it just wouldn’t happen. Anyway happy with his inclusion and if...
  12. N

    Uncontracted Jye Caldwell [OOC 2020]

    No chance he goes for a second rounder. Clubs will be lining up for him. GWS have let some players go cheap due to their salary or injuries, but Caldwell is on stuff all, fit and playing seniors. He will possibly be in and out of the side a bit, but so are a lot of players in their second year...
  13. N

    Autopsy vs GWS

    We don’t need a forward ruck though, as Goldy is rucking the whole game or 90% at the least. He would be playing basically as a permanent forward and I just don’t see him performing in that role, or it working structurally. I would also say he is a ruck first, who can play forward, not the...
  14. N

    Autopsy vs GWS

    I don’t think Xerri is a pure forward and playing him would turn out like it has in the past playing two ruckmen. We tried it with Campbell last year and other clubs have tried it with mostly poor results eg. Preuss at Melbourne. Wood didn’t play well by any means, but structurally we looked...
  15. N

    List Mgmt. 2020 Trade Thread.....

    Do you think DGB would be ready to roll in his first couple of years? I have also heard good raps on Cox (not the freo one). Would he be a good alternative if DGB was out of reach? On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
  16. N

    List Mgmt. 2020 Trade Thread.....

    Why would we go after Crouch? He is probably the last type we need on our list, with the salary he would demand. On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
  17. N

    Autopsy vs GWS

    You were lamenting our prospects after our first pre season game. On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
  18. N

    List Mgmt. 2020: Death Riding Melbourne [NMFC owns MFC's 1st & 4th 2020 picks] - Keep Your Eye on the Red and the Blue

    Their midfield is vanilla and one paced. They also don’t have a key forward capable of kicking goals on a regular basis. Most good sides have two. On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
  19. N

    Prediction Pick trades

    I wouldn’t be surprised if we do both. We need a quality defender now and with question marks over Durdin and McKay, we also need to look to the future. On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
  20. N

    Preview AFL Returns - Round 2: North Melbourne vs GWS @ Giants Stadium - changes/prematch discussion

    If it ends up being wet, playing Xerri would be suicide. We all just bagged out B.Scott for 10 years for making the same sort of mistakes at the selection table. On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

Top Bottom