Search results for query: *

Remove this Banner Ad

  1. Keys

    Autopsy So so so close (Please read OP)

    Commiserations guys. Shame that there had to be a loser after such a gripping contest Hopefully we both make it back for round 2 next year
  2. Keys

    Game Day AFL Grand Final - Matchday Discussion Collingwood v West Coast (MCG – 2:30PM)

    Good luck tomorrow guys. Hoping it’s a good hard fought game as neither team deserves to be on the wrong end of a blowout. Both have overcome their fair share of setbacks to make it this far and have well and truly earned their spot Obviously I’m hoping for an eagles win but if we had to lose...
  3. Keys

    News Q-Stick in black and white

    Looks can be deceiving. The Q-stick was always a big unit but he was never particularly aggressive given his size. He was always fit though and very durable. Was a good pickup for you guys and I hope he does well as he was a favourite of mine at the Eagles
  4. Keys

    Wellingham to WCE in exchange for pick 17

    Wellingham BOG:)
  5. Keys

    Wellingham to WCE in exchange for pick 17

    Good to see this wrapped up nice and early allowing both clubs to pursue other deals through the trade period I may have been a bit cranky this time yesterday with some of the reports indicating a potential stand-off so feel a little silly now after a going off half cocked yesterday. The...
  6. Keys

    Wellingham to WCE in exchange for pick 17

    So if Collingwood demand pick 17 and masten and refuse to budge, west coast will eventually accept that because walking away isn't an option? There will be a maximum that west coast are prepared to offer, just as Collingwood will have a minimum they will accept. None of us know where those...
  7. Keys

    Wellingham to WCE in exchange for pick 17

    Well he can go into the draft or psd whether Collingwood like it or not. He does relinquish control over which club he goes to though
  8. Keys

    Wellingham to WCE in exchange for pick 17

    I doubt it As with all negotiations the eagles will try to get wellingham as cheaply as possible and there'll be a point at which if they consider the asking price to be too high they'll walkaway. That point will be determined by wellinghams perceived worth and won't have anything to do with lynch
  9. Keys

    Wellingham to WCE in exchange for pick 17

    Depends largely on how much wellingham wants to go to west coast Assume that wellingham is genuine in his desire to play at west coast and doesn't want to go to Melbourne regardless of what they are offering. Now under your scenario Collingwood tell him that they won't deal with west coast and...
  10. Keys

    Wellingham to WCE in exchange for pick 17

    I'm not that clever I've always been of the opinion that our first rounder will be required to get the trade over the line but I'm realistic enough to understand that the eagles are unlikely to put that on the table straight up
  11. Keys

    Wellingham to WCE in exchange for pick 17

    I think the eagles want to try and keep our first rounder which means it might take a while for any deal to be done as obviously our second rounder is well short of what's required so our recruitment staff will need to come up with something creative
  12. Keys

    Wellingham to WCE in exchange for pick 17

    I'm not certain of the relevance of other clubs offers for wellingham unless those clubs can convince him to accept their offer Players can change their mind of course but I get the impression that the only club other than collingwood that wellingham wants to play for is the eagles. If a...
  13. Keys

    Wellingham to WCE in exchange for pick 17

    Absolutely correct IMO Pick 17/18 would get it done but if the eagles want to keep that pick then they're going to have to come up with something pretty creative to keep collingwood happy. I don't know what that could be though
  14. Keys

    Wellingham to WCE in exchange for pick 17

    Ash smith just signed a new two year deal this week so it would be unlikely for him to be traded now
  15. Keys

    Wellingham to WCE in exchange for pick 17

    Firstly, I think that if a trade can't get done Wellingham will most likely stay at Collingwood rather than take his chances in the draft. Secondly, I would have my doubts that we could fit an $800,000 salary under our cap Finally, if Melbourne don't pick him up, Freo will whether it be the...
  16. Keys

    Wellingham to WCE in exchange for pick 17

    If Wellingham is forced to go into the draft we won't get him
  17. Keys

    Wellingham to WCE in exchange for pick 17

    Mitch Brown is of far greater value to us than he is to Collingwood I would have thought so I very much doubt that he'll be a part of any trade
  18. Keys

    Wellingham to WCE in exchange for pick 17

    I've read posts that we could get a pick in the 20's for Stevens and then trade that to Collingwood for Wellingham which is delusional. There are some equally delusional trade scenarios from Pies supporters. Most posters from both sides seem to think pick 17/18 is fair with Pies supporters...
  19. Keys

    Wellingham to WCE in exchange for pick 17

    How's the fishing in Darlinghurst?
  20. Keys

    Wellingham to WCE in exchange for pick 17

    Kitchen sinks can be pretty cheap these days:p
  21. Keys

    Wellingham to WCE in exchange for pick 17

    Couple of things 1) Wellingham would be in the best 22 at West Coast without a doubt 2) Yes he has nominated West Coast as his preferred club which does make it a little bit harder for Collingwood to broker the best possible trade but nominating a preferred club is not unusual and Collingwood...
  22. Keys

    Wellingham to WCE in exchange for pick 17

    This thread comes up on my alerts so I jump to it from there rather than clicking on the Collingwood forum link. Have to remind myself where I am so it's a plausible rookie mistake Anyway, enough of that, I'm just glad that trade negotiations are conducted by professionals at the clubs and not...
  23. Keys

    Wellingham to WCE in exchange for pick 17

    To be fair there's a thread on this on both the Eagles board and here with posters from both clubs having there two cents in each of them so it is easy to momentarily forget which board you're on if you're posting in both threads
  24. Keys

    Wellingham to WCE in exchange for pick 17

    I think you may have forgotten this thread is on the Collingwood board
  25. Keys

    Wellingham to WCE in exchange for pick 17

    Priddis and Kerr primarily
  26. Keys

    Wellingham to WCE in exchange for pick 17

    They have to use it this year. Can't back fa picks in the way you could gws and GC compo picks
  27. Keys

    Wellingham to WCE in exchange for pick 17

    I don't think we're offering that sort of money. Sharrods manager is reported as saying the contracts offered were similar amounts He's still worth pick 17 though without question
  28. Keys

    Wellingham to WCE in exchange for pick 17

    You're on another teams board and their rules apply. Consider yourself as a visitor to another persons house and give them due respect If you want to slag them off go to bay13
  29. Keys

    Wellingham to WCE in exchange for pick 17

    I take it you guys are likely to use your second rounder on a father son selection
  30. Keys

    Wellingham to WCE in exchange for pick 17

    Dick had some pretty solid form playing for East Fremantle in the WAFL in the second half of the season and many of us thought he might have been a chance late in the season for a game in the seniors. It seems though the the club wanted him to build his fitness and strength in the WAFL this year...

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top