Search results for query: *

Remove this Banner Ad

  1. dinnaz

    Analysis KPP Pick Quality

    It's highly likely a couple do. But consider you have to turn out better than the absolute cream there's a long way to go. I've given you definitive benchmarks on what level players were at during a similar snapshot in time. Many such examples correlating with future AFL performances. My...
  2. dinnaz

    Analysis KPP Pick Quality

    Right idea. If we amalgamated the last 10 drafts (at the same point pre draft) no one from 2024 would be top 30. But then you may have 15 guys 30-60. The talls however have less strength in totality. Richmond have the right idea that with a bunch of darts thrown some will stick, but there are...
  3. dinnaz

    Analysis KPP Pick Quality

    Walsh had almost the best 17s year you'll ever see and just as good as everyone's 18th. Everyone else is merely good for that underage year. I do tend to analyse in a vacuum. How much value do you put on rumors, go home factor and such. I'd expect every player to maximise their effort and...
  4. dinnaz

    Analysis KPP Pick Quality

    An idea that needs exploring for sure. The champs usually show this higher tier play where you can see the dip from regular state level. The Vic Metro v Vic Country game this year is the best underage game i've seen because the level was so high around the ground.
  5. dinnaz

    Analysis KPP Pick Quality

    There was definitely good depth which is 95% of why it was hard to move back in. I wouldn't go so far as to say 40 usual top 20 picks but 30 for sure. Also a few other things to note are that: North wanted to be done with the draft now and will probably look to trade in players for the next few...
  6. dinnaz

    Analysis KPP Pick Quality

    Not really. This is what a standout player will be doing. Plenty of years someone has to be picked first but aren't that that level above. Think Raynor for example. Yep! Walsh did it for 2 years in a row which is remarkable to be that good as a 17 yr old which shows his quality. He also...
  7. dinnaz

    Analysis KPP Pick Quality

    I meant in terms of range not for Richmond specifically as that was your last list spot I think? Likely would have been there as a rookie/undrafted and is a real project player.
  8. dinnaz

    Analysis KPP Pick Quality

    I am n̶o̶t̶ a crackpot😬
  9. dinnaz

    Analysis KPP Pick Quality

    Without talking about the work rate or athletic profiles the stats say: Walsh 30d + 0.7g + Rowell 32d+ 0.4g + 9 tackles Daicos 36 disposals and 2 goals a game. Ashcroft 35d + 0.4g Anderson 28d + 2g Petracca 25d + 2.5 g Tom Boyd was at over 3 goals a game Weitering was at 2.9 contested marks...
  10. dinnaz

    Analysis KPP Pick Quality

    No one projects to be that good. And we talk about something along the lines of kicking 80 goals as a Jr in 15 games as what those guys were doing. Listening to the Carlton recruiters, at the time they actually had Kennedy at #1 but had to work around other teams, and knowing he would still be...
  11. dinnaz

    Analysis KPP Pick Quality

    While it's true that we don't know exactly how a players career will turn out we have a pretty good idea what range they will fall into. And when drafts are spoken about its in direct comparison to others at the exact point. For playing style- Think about Jack Watts, he never was going to pack...
  12. dinnaz

    Analysis KPP Pick Quality

    I think you're looking at it a little wrong. You need to look at the draft as a hundred moving pieces and not a whole thing to be dissected. The best players get picked earlier- that's a fait accompli, but why? After all a draft pick is just a number and means nothing after that night. It's...

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top