Search results for query: *

Remove this Banner Ad

  1. eaglespremiers

    Moore v Hipwood v Curnow

    In fairness if you compare Lynch's best year (2006) to Curnow's last season it's pretty close (arguably Lynch's is better): Goals - Lynch (65) v Curnow (64) Disposals - Lynch (364) v Curnow (264) Marks - Lynch (143) v Curnow (126) Obviously, Curnow's taken his game to another level this year...
  2. eaglespremiers

    Moved Thread Voss vs Selwood

    Of recent history I'd certainly entertain arguments to have him around the Simon Black/Scott Pendlebury/Jonathan Brown/Lenny Hayes/Luke Hodge level of player. The order is up for debate.
  3. eaglespremiers

    Moved Thread Voss vs Selwood

    I would have Voss in the top 25-30 players to have ever played. I don't think I'd have Selwood near the top 50.
  4. eaglespremiers

    Moved Thread Buddy or Ablett Snr?

    Not sure about the correctness of this. For instance, why does Kennedy get markedly less of an adjustment than Hawkins or Riewoldt?
  5. eaglespremiers

    Moved Thread Who was/is the better player. Gary Ablett jnr or Dustin Martin?

    Well then, end thread:
  6. eaglespremiers

    Nathan Fyfe v Elliot Yeo

    I see no similarities.
  7. eaglespremiers

    Nathan Fyfe v Elliot Yeo

    Perhaps the more interesting question is if they were in an even one-on-one marking contest who would win? Easily the two best marking midfielders in the competition.
  8. eaglespremiers

    What's the best season by a midfielder since the 2000s

    In fairness stat padding was invented in approximately 2007.
  9. eaglespremiers

    Moved Thread The Riewoldt cousins

    It's rather unfortunate that people use premierships as a comparison between players. Team success has limited bearing on a players ultimate standing as a player. Of course, I'm sure Martin Pike disagrees with my assessment.
  10. eaglespremiers

    2018 Ruckman rankings

    "Champion Data also notes that in direct ruck contests that he’s been involved in so far this season, Naitanui’s opponents are yet to produce a single hitout-to-advantage."
  11. eaglespremiers

    sam mitchell v simon black

  12. eaglespremiers

    Moore v Hipwood v Curnow

    Yes, which obviously you were talking about 2007, so my point in this regard is moot.
  13. eaglespremiers

    Moore v Hipwood v Curnow

    Buddy's 2007 may be considered the best year by a key forward for the last 20 years.
  14. eaglespremiers

    Moore v Hipwood v Curnow

    Buddy is not a fair comparison of normal key position development.
  15. eaglespremiers

    Does Caddy need to get better?

    Yep, OP backing away from his statement fast.
  16. eaglespremiers

    Alex Rance vs. Michael Hurley

    Ha ha, watching every goal conceded by West Coast that year, just to prove a point about CD's ranking of Mackenzie. Those were the days.
  17. eaglespremiers

    A 100 goal season & Joe Daniher: is he overwhelmingly the most capable player of achieving it again?

    I guess I expected more of you Jade. Daniher has all the hall marks of being an exceptional player and will no doubt be veying for the Coleman sooner rather than later. But your assertion is as baseless as you'll see on here. Usually a player has to prove himself at an elite level for multiple...
  18. eaglespremiers

    A 100 goal season & Joe Daniher: is he overwhelmingly the most capable player of achieving it again?

    So Kennedy's won the Coleman for the last couple of seasons and it's disputed that he is the best key forward yet Daniher just needs to do it for a handful or so games and we get drivel like this posted on the main board.
  19. eaglespremiers

    Martin v Shuey v Hartlett v Ziebell (version 2.0)

    Hartlett IMO is the odd one out in this poll.
  20. eaglespremiers

    Elliot Yeo vs Sam Docherty

    I voted Yeo. I'll readily admit I was mistaken.
  21. eaglespremiers

    Martin v Shuey v Hartlett v Ziebell (version 2.0)

    For what purpose? How does his opinion have any bearing on the specific comparison of the four players mentioned in the OP?
  22. eaglespremiers

    Martin v Shuey v Hartlett v Ziebell (version 2.0)

    You may(?) not be trolling but you're certainly not adding anything helpful.
  23. eaglespremiers

    Josh Kelly vs Zach Merrett

    It's because flippin' Hurley should be CHB. Struggled big time as a key forward.
  24. eaglespremiers

    Josh Kelly vs Zach Merrett

    Ditto.
  25. eaglespremiers

    Martin v Shuey v Hartlett v Ziebell (version 2.0)

    Did he single out Selwood as well? Because there's really no comparison, Selwood's a lot worse.
  26. eaglespremiers

    Martin v Shuey v Hartlett v Ziebell (version 2.0)

    Another amazing game from Martin. Has really pushed to the top echelon of midfielders this season.
  27. eaglespremiers

    Martin v Shuey v Hartlett v Ziebell (version 2.0)

    Shuey was a pretty clear BOG in the West Coast game IMO. Didn't see the Richmond game last night but Martin put up big numbers.
  28. eaglespremiers

    Dangerfield Vs Cotchin Vs Fyfe

    I actually had the same thought. Strange that Dangerfield is considered a good disposer of the ball.
  29. eaglespremiers

    Martin v Shuey v Hartlett v Ziebell (version 2.0)

    Guthrie clearly needs to be added to this thread.
  30. eaglespremiers

    Marcus Bontempelli v Elliot Yeo

    Only one turned up today and though Yeo contributed two goals there is a vast difference in maturity between the two. Yeo has all the attributes except the brain to put it all together.

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top