Search results for query: *

Remove this Banner Ad

  1. eaglespremiers

    News AFL Tribunal appeals board upholds Houston's 5 Week Suspension

    Houston absolutely hits him high at the first instance. 6 weeks is the right outcome IMO.
  2. eaglespremiers

    MRP / Trib. MRP and Tribunal - 2024 - Grand Final

    The game was cooked when Reid received two weeks for a tackle that didn't cause an injury to the player he was tackling. At least Cameron actually caused a head injury with his tackle.
  3. eaglespremiers

    MRP / Trib. Parker cleaning a bloke up in the magoos

    Based on the arguments, pretty clear 6 week suspension for mind and I say that being a fan of Luke Parker.
  4. eaglespremiers

    Maynard cleared by tribunal for Brayshaw collision

    Strike that's a twisted take on reality.
  5. eaglespremiers

    Maynard cleared by tribunal for Brayshaw collision

    Well then you have nothing to worry about and it's all semantics. However, I look forward to you returning to this thread to rage out if that doesn't occur in due course.
  6. eaglespremiers

    Umpiring The Purpose Of Boundary Lines - Pies v Cats Game Discussion

    Well it does multiply the incompetence, doesn't it.
  7. eaglespremiers

    Umpiring The Purpose Of Boundary Lines - Pies v Cats Game Discussion

    I know he cops a lot of stick around here but even Whateley called it as a Geelong fan:
  8. eaglespremiers

    It's Miller Time on Dayne's Nuts

    As long as you don't read it in Dwayne's voice. Stuff like "Oh baby!" "That's get cream dripping off it!", "Zorko needs a safe word here!", "drown them in your honey", "from little things big things grow", "chaos balls", "where angels fear to tread!" the inappropriate list of Dwaynisms for this...
  9. eaglespremiers

    MRP / Trib. De Goey hit on Elijah Hewett

    360 had Lewis on there (instead of Robbo). Lewis said 3-4, probably 3. They didn't blame Hewett for the hit, at least.
  10. eaglespremiers

    MRP / Trib. De Goey hit on Elijah Hewett

    Impact would have to be considered severe, wouldn't it? I don't think it can be considered less in the circumstances.
  11. eaglespremiers

    MRP / Trib. De Goey hit on Elijah Hewett

    It would likely be classed as severe, which does mean the starting point is 3 weeks. Then whatever the tribunal wants to apply from there.
  12. eaglespremiers

    What rule would you Add/Remove/Change to improve the game?

    Anything to dissuade players from rushing a behind. For instance penalising players waiting for opposition players to come into the goal square area only to then rush the ball. That and penalising forwards and ruckmen for excessive scragging on the goal line. Anything that would go in a marking...
  13. eaglespremiers

    Umpiring The Umpiring Dissent Rule - Discuss Here

    Ah, the ol' Matthew Kreuzer ploy.
  14. eaglespremiers

    Umpiring The Umpiring Dissent Rule - Discuss Here

    I remember one game in local U17s game when I received a 50m penalty against me for simply glaring at the umpire. That was about 17 years ago, so was simply absurd at the time, but maybe not so much anymore.
  15. eaglespremiers

    MRP / Trib. Kossie Pickett hit on Bailey Smith

    And Tim English was in standstill through it all.
  16. eaglespremiers

    MRP / Trib. Tom Stewart - Result 4 week match suspension

    Top bloke is Milburn: "I would have done the same thing every other time" Cat tries to put past behind him
  17. eaglespremiers

    McGovern reported

    I think you have made the assumption that because I am a West Coast supporter I would invariably want for McGovern to get off any charges. I have no issues with the AFL handing down a one week suspension for McGovern's action. However, I believe that the reason for the suspension should be on...
  18. eaglespremiers

    McGovern reported

    https://www.afl.com.au/news/2019-06-20/watch-star-eagle-on-report-big-bomber-in-trouble
  19. eaglespremiers

    McGovern reported

    There is absolutely no evidence of a "second action". If you don't want to hear that, then fine, we'll let reality be subjective.
  20. eaglespremiers

    McGovern reported

    I'm not sure how you believe that what you are posting is accurate. There is less than a second between Guelfi disposing of the ball and the impact from McGovern. Further, McGovern reaches Guelfi while he is either inside or on the boundary line and is committed to disrupting the Essendon play...
  21. eaglespremiers

    McGovern reported

    The push happened a split second after Guelfi disposed of the ball. By all previous determinations ("cough" Ablett "cough") this should be deemed in play. Further your freeze frame seems to emphatically indicate that the push occurred almost exactly on the boundary line. I'm not sure how your...
  22. eaglespremiers

    Umpires with no cajones

    You honestly see those sort of "blocks" about 15 times a quarter. Wasn't paid once yesterday and Rioli's certainly wasn't the worst. Pretty open and shut.
  23. eaglespremiers

    Is Nat Fyfe in trouble for this incident?

  24. eaglespremiers

    Is Nat Fyfe in trouble for this incident?

    Did you miss the Naitanui tribunal proceedings?
  25. eaglespremiers

    Nic Nats Report: Tribunal - Still pathetic/soft/inconsistent

    I like that you are genuinely concerned about Naitanui's health.
  26. eaglespremiers

    Nic Nats Report: Tribunal - Still pathetic/soft/inconsistent

    Sounds like Nic needs to work on being a bad tackler. Perhaps he should consider corralling next time.
  27. eaglespremiers

    Petition - Remove the score review system

    Sure, but Heeney kicked that goal.
  28. eaglespremiers

    Saints vs GWS, free kick to Carlisle?

    Is this a deflection for Carlisle's weak attempt to mark?
  29. eaglespremiers

    Trent Cotchin bump on Dylan Shiel

    There is a fine line between incidental and careless.
  30. eaglespremiers

    Trent Cotchin bump on Dylan Shiel

    I don't think anyone is proposing it was malicious.

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top