Im ok with the Hird appointment if its true. We give second chances all the time in society, I don't know why sport should be any different.
I would like more detail on the role and how he is equipped to contribute though.
Well I would say a lot of those players have stints in the wing rather than are picked primarily in that role. Pez is largely on a wing but also has stints both forward and back too… ash has only recently moved there and XO plays a lot on the HFF too
I’m not sure it’s apples against apples is...
I totally agree the DE can be misleading and obviously LW is the better player
I just think your assessment of Kennedy is too harsh. He is still in his prime imo
injuries have been harsh to him but when fit he plays
The kennedy debate is an interesting one. We don't really have established players that play the wing role. Yes we have LW and Chook but they are regularly in other positions now days. There are younger bodies that have potential but haven't proved they are capable for prolonged periods of time...
I think you are a little harsh here on Mainly Daniels. Yes he is often listed as a small forward but he spends most of his time higher up the ground. I suppose you need to be near the goals to impact them
You can’t separate the two
The hypocrisy of insulting me and then complaining when you get a reaction as “playing the man” is clearly lost on you
I’m here to chat footy not put up with this rubbish. Pull your head in
I reckon the question here is why do you care if we “look silly”
Occasionally early players bust. But did Melbourne look silly cos or trengrove or Toupas?
They looked silly cos of the result. But the league accepts some players don’t turn out as expected. Do we look silly regarding ahern and...
It all comes down to what AC decides the priority is of course. If Callaghan is too good to pass up the whole point is done. But for the sake of bigfooty let’s say we are keen on a few options (Andrews/gibcus/rachele/) it’s likely we will still get one of them at 7 so that trade might work for...
I like most of this. I think that we need to pick performance over potential at this stage as there is no data to indicate players like stone are improving (although. we obviously expect them to). If thats the case I think id have XO in over Stone
I couldn't justify including Preuss using my...