Search results for query: *

Remove this Banner Ad

  1. marcmurphy3

    List Mgmt. 2024 List Management 📃

    Fair point. I'm just surprised he would want to move to a really poor team when he has had to play for a bad team his whole career that is finally coming good. And it's not like he had to spend the whole year out of the side. He played maybe 5 games in the VFL. He's still got 2 years left with...
  2. marcmurphy3

    List Mgmt. 2024 List Management 📃

    I hope we get something decent for Fisher if he leaves. He might not be best 22 now but isn't far off and could easily be in round 1 with a good preseason. I mean Fog and Cunners took his half forward role in the back half of the year, but 2022 Fisher is still an upgrade on both. It's not like...
  3. marcmurphy3

    Toast Sam Walsh - 2023 Gary Ayres Award winner

    Heaps of major sports around the world have a finals MVP award. I think its weirder that it took the AFL so long to have one.
  4. marcmurphy3

    Speculation Elijah Hollands [OOC 2024]

    They won't get a first from us or anyone else (even a late first) but they're the seller. A future 2nd is fair though ours will (hopefully) be on the later side so think we come out slightly ahead if that's the trade. Hard to know what they'll actually accept without knowing the inner workings...
  5. marcmurphy3

    List Mgmt. 2024 List Management 📃

    If Smith is to leave a large part would be because he's been played out of position at half forward for most of this year and he wants a full time mid. I doubt he comes to us unless thats where we play him.
  6. marcmurphy3

    Official Club Stuff Carlton Academy - Next Gen & Father/Son Discussion

    Ben actually didn't play half back at all. Spent the first half almost exclusively on-ball and the 2nd half almost exclusively on the wing. Lucas played mainly wing and high half forward.
  7. marcmurphy3

    List Mgmt. 2024 List Management 📃

    That suggests it might be an interstate player. Smith wouldn't need to be put up in a house for a week to see the surf coast. He'd just drive from Melbourne for the day.
  8. marcmurphy3

    List Mgmt. 2024 List Management 📃

    Whatever happens I suspect both the Roos future picks will be traded this year probably for unders to avoid any chance of them being taken back by the afl next year. They have gotten so many freebies they won't care about getting full value for them. They will just want to end up with the...
  9. marcmurphy3

    List Mgmt. 2024 List Management 📃

    Not sure how we could possibly get Smith done. Our first plus future first wouldn't be enough then there is his salary.
  10. marcmurphy3

    Official Club Stuff Carlton Academy - Next Gen & Father/Son Discussion

    I wonder how involved we get in their development through their draft year? As in would the club be telling the twins how we see their strengths, opportnutties, what positions we would like to see them develop in over the coming year?
  11. marcmurphy3

    Bluemour 'Silly Season' Begins XXXV

    That's true. I think multiple clubs being in the picture helps Dow in terms of his contract value not us. He will choose a club and we will negotiate with that club whilst the other moves on. Hopefully he picks Sydney as SOS will give us stuff all.
  12. marcmurphy3

    Speculation Mabior Chol [OOC 2025] - strong possibility of a move

    I actually think he would be an upgrade on Hipwood though I suspect they play both with Hippy being the 3rd tall. Might do better without a key defender on him.
  13. marcmurphy3

    List Mgmt. 2024 List Management 📃

    It's not a bad strategy. Every year there are a group of 8-12 players clear of the rest. If you cant get up into group you are better off getting multiple bites of the apple in the top 35 then a single late first.
  14. marcmurphy3

    List Mgmt. 2024 List Management 📃

    Watson over Dursma every day of the week. Find it easier to see how he translates at afl level and exactly what we need. Hopes aren't very high but could see him falling to around 10 which gives us a chance depending on how many eggs we want to place in that basket (tradewise)
  15. marcmurphy3

    Speculation Paddy Dow

    Where did the word come from that he was touring facilities?
  16. marcmurphy3

    List Mgmt. 2024 List Management 📃

    I don't think anyone thinks Cunners is one paced. Athletically he is exactly what we need. Issue is he often doesn't get to use his pace because he struggles to get involved in the play. He looked much better early in our winning streak so hopefully he just tired out by the end of the season...
  17. marcmurphy3

    List Mgmt. 2024 List Management 📃

    I think it does but only for the right price which will probably be the issue with Gresham..
  18. marcmurphy3

    Speculation Elijah Hollands [OOC 2024]

    I don't think an F2 will be a problem for Hollands. We don't even know where the campo twins will land yet.
  19. marcmurphy3

    Restricted Free Agent Tom Doedee

    Would be a good get for Brisbane. Fits there needs perfectly.
  20. marcmurphy3

    List Mgmt. 2024 List Management 📃

    I wonder if we have reconsidered our position on Gresham with the way we finished the year? Our half forwards were a big problem during our losing streak when we were reportedly keen. Then Fog amd Cunners came in and did a great job and we apparently cooled on him. But towards the end of the...