Search results for query: *

Remove this Banner Ad

  1. EB&W Pieman

    The best teams at NOT going back to back

    The 2011 Collingwood team was a beauty, but so was the 2011 Geelong team. The difference was that the Cats were all aligned, with every duck in its allotted place. Collingwood, on the other hand, were internally bereft with Malthouse and Buckley seriously butting heads and players taking...
  2. EB&W Pieman

    Sydney… the biggest club in the land??

    Attending regular sporting events isn’t part of the Sydney culture. They go to big spectacular happenings, rather than home and away football matches ( in any code). They fill the stadium for SOO but virtually never get more that 25K for even a high level regular season NRL game. But I was at...
  3. EB&W Pieman

    Training 2024 training updates.

    FWIW Hayden Young is a future All-Australian.
  4. EB&W Pieman

    Universal Love Ranking the Premierships

    I’m verrrrry old. We all know that every GF win is precious, and we all prefer the ones that occurred while we were in our prime. The joy of 2023 following another near miss in 2022, the indescribable relief of 1990 following 32 years of stuff-ups and near misses are great days in my football...
  5. EB&W Pieman

    Premiership players should not just be Grand Final participants

    Has it occurred to anyone that, with mid-season trading, we could have one or more players in a Grand Final who would collect a medal no matter who won?
  6. EB&W Pieman

    List Mgmt. 2023 Draft & Trade Hypotheticals

    Isn’t your greatest need a Joey Kennedy replacement? I constantly read about the Swans getting smashed in the clearances. Is there a Giant you could pinch? They seem to have a stack.
  7. EB&W Pieman

    Analysis 2023 All Australian Team Awards Night

    In American Football, Tom Brady has always been the best or second best player. But, if he’s not selected at quarterback, he misses out. They don’t put him in as nose tackle just because “Tom Brady is certainly Zbetter than ———“ I have made this case before, players MUST be selected in their...
  8. EB&W Pieman

    Can the AFL Actually Beat Concussion Class Actions with these Stupid MRO Decisions?

    Yep. Of course that “cold” killed more than two million people …….. and counting.
  9. EB&W Pieman

    Rules Interchange infringement wins Sydney the game

    Just saw it on TV. One player was coming off (75th) and another one cramped and scurried off (76). A second player on the bench scurried on - didn’t want to leave the side short. No AFL official was ever in position to rescue the Roos from their own incompetence.
  10. EB&W Pieman

    Swans in Sydney v Storm in Melbourne.

    What? They had premierships taken off them. The 1995 Blues didn’t.
  11. EB&W Pieman

    Who is the best team in the history of the game to not win a grand final??

    Hey back off everyone. You’ve all had a lot of fun at our xpense over the decades making fun of our record in Grand Finals. So how about you all rack off, and let us decide among ourselves which of our 28 losing Grand Finals was our most noble. Fair’s fair.
  12. EB&W Pieman

    Who is the best team in the history of the game to not win a grand final??

    Collingwood 1966_1970 specifically 1970. Best team in it by several goals. Had been building beautifully over the previous five or six seasons. Ready to go and dominated the blues in the first half, famously leading by 44 at the break. Injuries to Tuddenham and McKenna, made a difference...
  13. EB&W Pieman

    Fixture Who finishes last in 2023?

    Hmmm. You may well be right, but …. 1. Every list manager has his price. The things a club can do with the number 1 pick these days make it much more useful than ever before. 2. I reckon your recent reluctance to finish last was personal - Clarko didn’t want his record blemished. 3...
  14. EB&W Pieman

    Fixture Who finishes last in 2023?

    Hawks seem determined to have first pick from a hot list of kids.
  15. EB&W Pieman

    What's your favourite? I like 'em all

    The Beau special against Carlton. Worth watching again to note how Pendles manipulates the two Blues players to release Beau and give him sufficient time and space to kick that spectacular goal. We’ll miss that when he retires. More than we know.
  16. EB&W Pieman

    All Time Fav Cult Pies Player?

    Barry Rist
  17. EB&W Pieman

    Opinion Sydney Swans Academy and Rebuild

    I would imagine that every Victorian club has a player in their top team who was originally recruited by a Northern AFL team. You can’t have this discussion without including the problems that non traditional AFL teams have in retaining recruits. That’s why the Northern Academies were set up...
  18. EB&W Pieman

    Opinion Geelong v Sydney GF. Neutral supporter prediction/analysis

    Footy fans tend to have Dory-type memories, but I’m surprised at how many responses assume that the season began on Friday night. Both the grand finalists prevailed in incredibly tight finals against Collingwood, and had relatively easy wins in their other game. If anything, the Cats could...
  19. EB&W Pieman

    What’s your greatest personal football highlight.

    I captained Kimbarra to the House Football premiership at (then) Mitcham High School. The kid who captained Kimbarra before me played in the 1967 & 1969 VFL Premiership teams. I rose to no such heights. But I did kick the winning goal for Ferntree Gully against Lilydale one day.
  20. EB&W Pieman

    If you could take 1 player from another team

    The Gold Coast King. Fills a desperate need and exactly the right age profile.
  21. EB&W Pieman

    Player Watch Finlay Macrae

    Yep. Some of the commentary here (and elsewhere) demonstrates the preference of hope over experience. None of our recruits got a Risng Star nomination last year. They need to improve for the Pies to contend in the near to medium future.
  22. EB&W Pieman

    Best small forwards of the AFL era

    As soon as a small forward kicks more than 95 goals in a season they go straight past Peter Daicos. Until then ....
  23. EB&W Pieman

    Your clubs drafted best 22?

    Pies. Noble. Mihocek Madgen Quaynor. Moore. Maynard Phillips. Pendles. J. Daicos Sidebottom. Ceglar. Stephenson Elliot? Cox. Henry Grundy. Degoey. N.Daicos. 1. Not sure about Elliott. He was on some GWS list, but I don’t think he was ever employed by them. Pick any...
  24. EB&W Pieman

    Training Apples' & Jen's Training Thread 2021 (Latest report #3590)

    I got something on my Facebook feed to the effect that members could access the game on a closed loop.
  25. EB&W Pieman

    Opinion The National Draft... is not really a National Draft?

    The go-home factor/retention is where the current system is loaded against the Northern states. I know that all clubs have lost players who miss their mum, but it clearly is much more prevalent in a state where the clubs might go five years without drafting a player from that state. I can’t be...
  26. EB&W Pieman

    Picking an all-time CFC lineup

    1. Peter More could probably play as a modern tall winger. Super athletic, fast and tall. Big Lenny was a pure ruckman - albeit he started at CHF in thE 1970 Granny 2. Peter McKenna was a bit stiff. As a full forward he was opposed to Gordon Coventry - key member of the 4 Premierships in...
  27. EB&W Pieman

    Rank your team

    Interesting exercise Our top eleven - down to Crisp - are terrific; the next eight - down to Noble - are fine AFL standard players, but after that it does drop off. Grundy Moore De Goey Pendlebury Howe Adams Meynard Sidebottom Treloar Crisp Elliott Daicos Cox Stephenson Quaynor Roughead...
  28. EB&W Pieman

    News Best22Under22

    You forgot to mention that one plays as third forward (On the third tall defender) while the other plays as the KEY forward on the first tall defender (as well as the intercept defender). PS. Oscar Allen looks the goods.
  29. EB&W Pieman

    Expansion Alternate AFL World 1987

    In 1898, the interstate games would have been a real problem.
  30. EB&W Pieman

    Shane Morwood v Harry O’Brien & Crosisca v Ben Johnson

    Morwood comfortably then Harry comfortably then Crosisca then Johnson. Heater is the only one close to Morwood.
Back
Top