Search results for query: *

Tapping should pack his bags. I won't go to another game whilst he's still in charge. This is not the Collingwood I grew to love.

So you're saying we could get off to either a good start or a bad start. Thanks for the clarification. Will be watching the first quarter with these thoughts in mind.

Yes but you also wanted him omitted after round 1. Your three outs were: Sidebottom, Swan and Cloke. Your three ins were: three players who performed in the VFL. I notice there is no clear like-for-like replacement listed in your ins. Anyway, after a couple of rough weeks, I'm doing well.

I'm aware of that but if he plays well again then he will continue to put his hand up and will eventually be selected.

He was dropped last year, Dave. Went back to the VFL got 30 touches and was recalled to the seniors. Hopefully Broomhead plays well tomorrow and can be a suitable replacement for Blair the following week.

You wanted Cloke dropped after round 1. Who was the suitable replacement then? This is what you wrote after round 1 in the "Is it time to drop Clokey?" thread. At least try and maintain a bit of consistency.

I would prefer Cloke in the side but haven't you been one of his biggest critics on here, wanting him dropped?

Demonstrates the depth of our list when Cloke is playing VFL.

Just having a think about the side and what you've posted, it looks like Frost is coverage for Reid and Cox coverage for Cloke. I'd rather Goldsack in instead of Frost if a third tall is needed. However, I now understand what you were suggesting earlier. Could very well be several more changes...

Just going off the official release, mate.

White is the only out. No Goodyear or Goldsack named despite scoop's earlier post.

Bit confusing....If we win do we get four points or does Ed's theory make the points null and void? Edit: forgot to add more...........

I couldn't care less about players taking drugs but if you are going to insinuate who the player is then you would want to be certain that the individual did in fact test positive, otherwise it could be considered defamatory. I'm not sure you can be certain, given you don't have access to the...

You've all but named him. Quality post.

Do you ever stop thinking about dicks?

Fair enough. I hope he does well.

So after two matches it's confirmation that trading Kennedy was a mistake?

Trav often goes the fend off but usually gets the opposition player in the throat and gives away a free. He kicked a great goal against Hawthorn last year using a fend off. Also, Swan kicked a goal two years ago on Anzac Day bursting through a pack and palming off Baguley (I think?). Marley and...

Pretty much all teams play a zone. Just depends to what extent and how successful it is.

Okay, bit hypocritical of you though when you seem to agree with the post I was specially referring to. Start of the season had been poor, obviously. Buckley needs to improve this year or he will be sacked. Last night was a slight improvement from the week before.

What sort of stuff is out of line?

But mocking the coach for the way he puffs his chest out and wears clothing too tight is reasonable? Doesn't seem like a legitimate thread for constructive analysis.

Further evidence Paul Roos is a fraud. Some on here want him to replace Buckley.

Good on him. Just don't play him in the ruck then because he was useless in the ruck contests. Four hit outs to half time against Hampson was embarrassing.

Beat me to it. Robbo hasn't taken it well.

Da hole side be dropped.

According to you, he should have been dropped.

Drop da hole side including Langdon.

utensils pls start sucking. Get em over and done with and maybe go again next week.

You're a campaigner. Can you not comprehend?