Search results for query: *

I think the rivalry between them is still there albeit fairly dormant. A finals match up between them would remind everyone this is probably the biggest interstate rivalry alongside the rivalry between Sydney and West Coast.

Crows started rebuilding in 2020. Carlton started rebuilding in 2015. Yet it feels like the Crows have gone past Carlton in their rebuild. Do you think the Crows have gone past Carlton in their rebuild?

I know the grand final losses were only recently but it's clear GWS haven't recovered from the 2019 grand final loss to Richmond and Sydney haven't recovered from the 2022 grand final loss to Geelong. In my opinion it's fair to say Geelong and Richmond destroyed the NSW clubs. Would you agree or...

After 4 rounds St Kilda 2009 - 4-0 at 200.4% 453 points for and 226 points against St Kilda 2023 - 4-0 at 160.4% 364 points for and 227 points against When it comes the playing lists I think the 2023 list is far more even and balanced. 2009 list had far better top end talent but the gap...

As the number 1 club in SA? Crows haven't finished higher than Port on the ladder since 2017, and it looks like Port have gone past the Crows in their rebuild too. JHF, Rozee, Butters is going to be a seriously good centre square trio, and might even rival the Judd, Cousins, Kerr trio in 5...

Port never recovered from the 119 point belting they received from Geelong in the 2007 grand final and Adelaide haven't recovered from the 2017 grand final loss to Richmond. In my opinion it's fair to say Geelong and Richmond destroyed the SA clubs. Would you agree or disagree?

Collingwood added Mitchell to their midfield while Richmond added Taranto and Hopper. Both were finals sides who were thereabouts in 2022 and having both strengthened their midfields it'll be interesting to see who finishes higher in 2023.

Now the 2023 fixture is out, it'll mean after they play each other in 2023 the last 10 home and away matches between the two sides will be as follows. 8 matches in WA. 2 matches in NT. 0 matches in VIC. The last time they played each other in VIC was when Demetriou was still running the AFL...

They've played some big games in recent years with some absolute classics. So why isn't there a rivalry? AFL always seem to schedule these games in SA and next year will be the second year in a row these sides will play twice in a home and away season. So maybe the AFL can sense there's a...

Which grand final is the best grand final of the modern era and why? I've included grand finals from 1999 onwards as that's how many grand finals the forum allows me to include in the poll.

Something I can't help but notice on here is the constant bickering between Geelong and Richmond supporters across these boards. Am I missing something here? Because there doesn't seem to be a rivalry in real life between them, and I have a lot of friends and acquaintances who barrack for either...

This will be the third time in four years where Brisbane and Richmond have crossed paths in the finals. There's been noticeable heat between these teams in recent times eg. Robertson vs Martin and lets be honest, who doesn't love an interstate rivalry? There have been some classic interstate...

Two outsider coaches who lets face it were treated poorly by the club. Even though their coaching records were average and nothing to write home about, the absolute circus on both occasions was completely unwarranted. If it turns out we've sacked Rutten to appoint Hird like we sacked Knights to...

I've seen discussions on here regarding who has more supporters out of Collingwood and Richmond but in my opinion, a topic worth a thread of its own discussion is the question regarding who has the most feral supporter base out of the two clubs? Collingwood and Richmond are two of the biggest...

This is how it's done. Richmond fans take note.

Journalists keep banging these drums ad nauseum and these discussions keep popping up on several different threads around here, so I've decided to make a thread intended to discuss this very topic seeing as though there isn't already one that exists. What do you think will happen to North...

Hearing Leigh Matthews hailing Geelong as the most successful club of the 21st century despite Hawthorn having won more flags in that time has got me thinking about who's been more successful out of the two SA clubs. Port have a better win percentage and lead the Crows in the H2H count but the...

Which grand final is the best grand final of the modern era and why? I've included grand finals from 1998 onwards as that's how many grand finals the forum allows me to include in the poll.