Undersized would be okay if he was quick or had elite endurance, but he does seem to be a classic Essendon pick. So often it seems to be players with massive deficiencies that are relevant to their position; they're right up against it to succeed from the very beginning. Key forwards whose hands...
I don't hate the idea of O'Sullivan because he looks like such a good prospect and does have that versatility. If he's much better than the next best prospect, it's worth pulling the trigger. But if it's a marginal difference and they still go for the KPD because they're just slightly 'best...
eDPS Is George Stevens with the first pick realistic at all? Limited athletically but genuinely physical, a leader, and kicking looks more than serviceable. The query seems to be if he can spread and get to enough contests, or is a purely inside mid like Brodie or Constable, which doesn't seem...
For Martin, do you mean his stats don't do him justice or that they flatter him? Surely the former; he's got to be close to the best kick in the league this year.
Move Weideman (or anyone else apart from Stringer) back, or include someone else in the side who can play/swing back - try literally anything else. Langford has been insanely effective forward; it's way easier to cover his absence in the backline than his absence in the forwardline. Completely...
Every year the top prospects will get compared to top players, but the amount of hype varies. There's not a Reid type that fans talk about tanking for every year.
He was never that hyped or the consensus number one pick, likewise Jamarra wasn't considered head and shoulders above McDonald. Even guys like Walsh and Rowell, despite being clear cut consensus #1 players, weren't hyped to the same extent since they were more highly productive and professional...
His kicking looks like a real strength. Even when he's bolting and most players just boot it, he can put serious finesse on the pass. Skill, composure, good size and shape, good running ability; I think he's highly likely to turn out well.
Best case scenario is Wardlaw but it looks like North will get him. Aside from him, I'd love Phillipou. Would be okay with Humphrey, Mackenzie or Clark.
If pick 4 gets traded back or 22 gets traded up into the teens, my pick would be Isaac Keeler, looks really impressive to me: big unit, super...
Tsatas. I don't like the sound of a midfielder who accumulates by getting on the move early and anticipating where the ball will be. That's exactly what Essendon has too much of with Parish, Merrett and Shiel. The midfield needs someone who can absorb physical pressure. Tsatas being 186cm is...
Part of what's appealing is that he could/should come cheap since he's surplus to Brisbane's needs. He's also not looked at as a prospective star but someone who has particular attributes that the list lacks.
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.