Search results for query: *

Fair call and better data manipulation (but doesnt disprove what I asked of people in the first place, who decided that instead of offering up what you have, just criticise and whine and jump on the #metoo lifestyle). The intention of an "opinion" which is the tag used, is to get debate on the...

Obviously another nuffy. Accuracy % conversion is the important one which an obvious numpty would ignore. Shots at goal is to show just that, shots at goals based on points/goals. It doesnt include ~50 shots average per year that are OOB. But keep jumping on the #Ineedfriends bandwagon. Doesnt...

Its almost amusing to see the level of whine that comes from people who spend more time on here than is healthy. For starters this post is an opinion that is set to start a conversation. Not to hear peoples life stories IDGAF about or trolling without any opinion of their own. An opinion needs...

Read and Mzungu as development coaches arent in the conversation for top 20 in the AFL , so why arent we targeting best development coaching staff during our 26 year rebuild? And Hale played as the second or third forward in great teams. Why havent we gone after a Mitchell, or Stevie J or to...

On a few notes. Chapman is not anywhere near ready for a winger role and I would rather have him as a mobile HB for when wee wise up and sack some hanger ons and recruit smarter without Board influence. The chevron isnt terrible but the anchor definitely should be the derby guernsey. 1. Get...

Wilson coming off man, doesnt lay tackle. His man floats forward and ..lucky hits there post..but could have cost us plenty there.

Well Cripps is a free agent anyway, and hasnt signed contract, so its literally money that will drag him back to WA and dont need to trade for him and we have the salary cap. Cripps at HF/mid rotating with Fyfe for me at Freo is a win. I would want Cerra for the next 4 years outside centre...

I dont know. I am tentative because Freo play better with a crowd and there will be no "home team advantage". I had initially tipped Dockers +20, butI think it will be closer knowing that North had a sniff against a bad Cats performance last week and if we get the shoulders down mentality we...

A lot of people here have the Ross Lyon disease of looking at history and wishing they were what they were "way back when" and thinking that because a player was a great serviceman (not great as in respects to players like Mundy, Pavlich, Fyfe, Neale, McPharlin etc as he isnt in that category)...

But the big question is, Why? A guy that was a high pick that was good but not great, without the fan favourite aspect, doesnt have a spot in the best 22 in this team currently. All emotion aside, resign before mid year pick and let Fremantle take a pick. Wont happen because why lose 200k a...

They could stick a sack of potatoes with a tree branch sticking out of it the last 2 years, he'd still try and play for a free kick for high contact and get ignored because every umpire knows he plays for free kicks. He doesnt draw the taggers or defenders anymore, thats a fact. Who has lined up...

After the last 2 games Acres has had, I rate him up there on his best day. I also rated Langdon, but Bhill was never up there on my list. Was overrated here, and was left to his own devices because we had players like Mundy, Fyfe etc who had the decent mids on them freeing up Bhill and at the...

Hamling should be good by the 30th at this stage, but prob wont be given a run unless desperation calls for the derby. Watson might get a run in favour of hughes to prep him for the beagles game.

I would go unchanged, (unless like me, they want Walters dropped for a players who is hungry for the ball and not for the Selwood-Shuey medal) except Crowden as the starting in for Cerra (if rules dictate missing a week with sub rule) with Blakely or Banfield with the way he played at HF/high...

I would prefer a 50% Young than a 70% Hill. And Hill is travelling more at 25% at the moment.

Super happy to see Darcy get fired up and not back off the contest. In the top 5 players on the field today.

I dont know, Darcy has been playing like Forest Gimp as of late. 100% agree. Fyfe should only go HF on rotation or to drag a midfielder out of the contest for Serong/Brayshaw/Cerra to win a ball.

Ive been on the Tab train since day 1. Still on it, and I think hes a good choice. Just thinking the doubt comes from form and Jlo's horror start to selection in 21 he will run with 4 rucks come round 6.

Nope.

Agreed. Literally 2 Ruck, with Treacy as a DPP Ruck/Forward makes me curious about what JL is doing? He had all preseason to test all this stuff... playing these guys, with Lobb to come back in in 2 weeks...doesnt look good for Tabs.

If they wont push Young to the wing as the best kick in our team, no one will get pushed out to the wing.

But JL isnt rotating through the depth players/kids. :~( which is the frustrating point

No chance. Darcy, Meek, Taberner, Treacy... thats 4 kids who are basically stationary targets. No way you would play 2 tall forwards and 2 rucks. Where would Darcy/Meek rest? Bench because they couldnt go forward...and Lobb back in means theyd drop meek/darcy. I think playing both Darcy and...

Its got me stumped though. Why the Docckers would launch a challenge (at a cost of $15k) to make Treacy available to play at round 2, but not select him?? Thats 15 members who got their moneys worth right there! :D

Hes a workhorse with a decent leg on him. Like 70% Young 30% Acres but not as fast as a Colyer etc.

Agreed. Walters/Conca/Colyer/Mundy (even though he did do well enough to be left off the sht list),Acres all stood off the contest 90% of the game. You cant have that from that many senior players. Mundy cant act as captain, because hes too nice a guy. Walters disregards what he says and jsut...

Acres wont ever be dropped with this many infuries. Sturts already been noted as a definite WAFL. Treacy must have Blakely'd Justins daughter or wife.

No one is melting. We are jsut sick of the promises by coaches that come in.. "New gample style", "play the youth", "Building a team".. when it comes down to it.. its always the same selections, the same kids who never get a callup even when the team at AFL level is woeful, trade headaches where...

Dont think its true as he was in Subi on the weekend wearing a West Coast hat..... :D But to be honest, with the Dockers selection panel being what it is probably get a delist and get picked up and go on to be a top 10 player at another club after not getting a gtame here (Sam Menegola anyone?).

He never left. He is actually Valente in disguise.