Search results for query: *

Fair question. Unclear in my mind and I prefer to let players complete their career before bestowing on them the honor of being in my all time team. fwiw: Simpson Lawry Bradman G.Chappell Miller/Border Harvey Gilchrist Lindwall/O'Reilly Warne Lillee McGrath

Yeh I actually think he's gonna be a good ruckman.

If he's going to retire like most people think he is, I cant really see the point in resting him at all. He might as well play if he's fit.

This is a big if, but IF Jack wanted to go on, and he remains uninjured this year, why not give him another season? We'd have been royally ****ed without him this year, with Lynch down. He's still a formidable target, he still brings the ball to ground if he doesn't mark (which is a huge part...

I dont know why this doesn't or cant happen more often in footy, but I'd love to see proper succession plan stuff happen, instead of just dumping a coach and moving on. Especially when we're in the position we're in, 3 flags in 6 years. Identify a future coach, let's say Shane Edwards. I...

Seems like such a dumb overreaction from Sheedy. Stupid classless thing for Barrott to write, but wanting to kill him for it just seems ridiculous.

Still dont pick guys in my ATXI until their careers finish. Morris Barnes Bradman G.Chappell Harvey Miller Gilchrist Warne OReilly Lillee McGrath Cummins and Smith definitely in line once their careers end.

Pretty hard to separate Dusty, Royce Hart, KB and Francis Bourke imo. Hart was the greatest CHF of all time (along with Carey), named at CHF in the team of the century. Bourke was on the wing in the all time team of the century but could play anywhere. Hard as *. KB was the biggest...

Guys i've seen B- Grimes : Rance : Kellaway HB- Cameron : Gaspar : Vlaustin C- Edwards : Cotchin : Deledio HF- Martin : Richardson : Brown F- Riewoldt : Lynch : Bolton R- Nankervis : Knights: Prestia Ottens : Campbell : Broderick : Houli

Tarrant was epic this year. When Gibcus deserves his spot he'll get it. And Balta cannot do the same lockdown as Tarrant does.

Looking forward to Renshaw and Pukovski forming a long term opening pairing

Jack still adds plenty of value to the team. Even if he isn't dominating, he's still demanding a good KPD and he does clever things and is a general out there. Should definitely go around in 2023 unless someone is demanding his spot,m which they aren't.

i do the exact same thing, remember that username from years ago with my old account

I’m disturbed while you’re deluded sounds right

1990 onwards (off the top of my head) Grimes - Rance - Bowden Kellaway - Gaspar - Houli Deledio - Prestia - Vlaustin Martin - Richardson - Lambert Riewoldt - Lynch - Edwards Ottens - Knights - Cotchin Broderick - Gale - Bolton - Newman I probably forgot someone obvious

Oh, I’m well settled.

Lol. What level of cricket do you play here?

Backs Michael Green Vic Thorp Kevin Sheedy Half Back Basil McCormack Mervyn. Keane Gordon Strang Centre Francis Bourke Bill Barrot Dick Clay Half Forward Roger Dean Royce Hart Matthew Richardson Forward Dale Weightman Jack Titus Bill Morris Followers Roy...

Dumb maybe, but could anyone see us getting another year or two out of JR as a key defender? He reads the play better than most and makes good decisions in traffic. Could see him being a Paul Roos type at CHB. He’d set things up well. He might be past it but it’s worth considering imo.

give it a rest, champ

See the post above This s**t is completely unnecessary

and you read that as me saying people who aren't AFL standard cant talk about footy how?

Yeh, he probably should have had a set shot. Yeh, we probably should have nailed one more goal from the 20 plus behinds we kicked. We'd have won either way. Meh.

I'd say darker times if we've reverted back to the old Richmond "pile s**t on the one bloke when things aren't going well" Can you tell me where I said if you're not AFL standard, dont talk about footy? Pretty sure I didnt and I actually said "stop shitcanning one bloke and revealing how little...

People are venting like unintelligent morons. Very very little of the responsibility for yesterday's loss falls on Aart's shoulders. You know nothing about footy if you think he's to blame for yesterday. And as such I am happy to call it out for the vitriolic bullshit that it is. Once again...

Mate, I'm as emotionally invested in it as anyone here. I'm pretty sure being healthily invested isn't shitcanning one decision one player made to the point it could be very detrimental to his mental health. When he was far from responsible for what happened yesterday. Hardly think that's what...

Well let's just say almost every AFL player is elite in the context of the whole scheme of things, to just get there is elite. Not the real point of my post anyway.

The vitriol in this thread is putrid. The guy made a bad decision under pressure. He wasn't the only bloke who screwed up and you can't expect to win wasting so many chances. 33 scoring shots to 22. We had more inside 50s. More possessions, more tackles, more free kicks, more one-percenters...

He's not a full time mid because he improves our team significantly when he is in the back line. We started playing good footy this year when him and Balta went back instead of being forward of the ball. With Prestia, Cotchin, Edwards, Graham, Short, Martin and Bolton all able to run thru the...

Got a bit of a feeling this will really galvanise our playing group in the run to the finals. Hope so.