Search results for query: *

Remove this Banner Ad

  1. G

    The most important metric when judging a player's career ?

    I think games played really, majority of players don't even get to 100 games let alone 150, 200 ect..... So many greats of the game never won a premiership, or a Brownlow or a Norm Smith, Coleman ect..... but their legacy is not less because of missing out to anyone with the exception of the...
  2. G

    Who is the best team in the history of the game to not win a grand final??

    Early 80s Collingwood, 91 Eagles, 04 Lions, 08 Geelong, 09/10 Saints, 13 Dockers, 18 Tigers
  3. G

    Who's closer to their next premiership: Carlton or Freo?

    The Ross Lyon Bridesmaid factor must be considered as significant .... so Freo is closer .
  4. G

    Opinion Are we on the verge of another period of dominance from teams not based in Melbourne?

    We did..... its called the "AFL" .... your lot joined it too.
  5. G

    Prediction Season 23 - The big cojones calls

    Jack Ginivan breaks his own neck after throwing his head back in disgust after not being paid a high tackle free kick that he ducked into . Jack Darling gets hospitalised from Covid and refuses treatment Stuart Dew named coach of the year after Gold Coast win 12 and finish 9th West Coast...
  6. G

    Top 5 finals performances

    Ask a Richmond supporter, they will have plenty to say, they'd be wrong , but they will still have plenty to say.
  7. G

    Prediction Best 22 for Round 1, 2023

    Dep list clogger or at best depth player.... SPS was just rated too highly by Carlton when drafted and has never come close to living up to the level that was expected of him.
  8. G

    Top 5 finals performances

    Gary Ablett Snr - 89 hands down the best finals series ever, it is criminal to have anyone above Ablett Snr for what he did in the 89 finals ..... 27 goals in four games including 9 in a losing GF .... was just an absolute monster and his best .....
  9. G

    Prediction Best 22 for Round 1, 2023

    I like Yeo back at HB I'd swap Duggan and Hunt as we need Hunts run and ball carry from half back to speed up our play. This centre line needs pace with skills or a ball magnet bull with quick and accurate hands. Gaff, if he is a receiver is ok, but if is coal facing it he might as well be in...
  10. G

    Analysis If Dustin Martin wins a 4th Norm Smith medal and premiership will he be regarded as the greatest player of all time?

    Mathews is wrong..... Dusty as a mid forward better kick another 600 goals in 60 odd games to get to that level and Lethal never averaged more than 27 touches a game in his entire career as a mid / forward ... There is a reason Lethal was named player of the century, hell even the AFLPA MVP is...
  11. G

    If you could draft any player from history?

    I think Ablett would dominate in any era .... he kicked around 600 goals from the wing before he moved to a full time forward role.... 600 goas from the wing and the guy still only played 248 games. If anything Lethal and Ablett would have been suspended for half their careers by todays...
  12. G

    Analysis If Dustin Martin wins a 4th Norm Smith medal and premiership will he be regarded as the greatest player of all time?

    Sporadic brilliance still gets votes over the length of his career....... I just think his constancy in the regular season is not as good as the others, ill concede on Fyfe though, his finals consistency is well above the others hence one Brownlow and 3 Norms . GAJ - 262 Votes Ranked 1st - 2...
  13. G

    If you could draft any player from history?

    1: Ablett Snr 2: Lethal Mathews 3: Plugger 4: Buddy 5: Dunstall 6: Ablett Jnr 7: Judd 8: Fyfe 9: Dusty 10: Cousins
  14. G

    Analysis If Dustin Martin wins a 4th Norm Smith medal and premiership will he be regarded as the greatest player of all time?

    No......With the exception of his Brownlow year his regular season form has been sporadic , he is no doubt a September specialist and is in the argument for finals GOAT , Ablett and Judd and to a lesser extent Fyfe and Danger still sit above him in this Gen of players.
  15. G

    Fixture Who finishes last in 2023?

    Seeing as we're in a "rebuild" I am hoping West Coast..... no point finishing 9th to 12th , might as well take advantage of the fact we're a bit shite
  16. G

    How do fans decide which team they support?

    Number 1 Reason - forced by parents + geographical location. Number 2 Reason - Whatever Bandwagon is doing well.
  17. G

    List Mgmt. Contract, Trade & Draftee Discussion - 2022 Off Season Edition

    I wasn't ......... need a mongrel on the list
  18. G

    List Mgmt. Contract, Trade & Draftee Discussion - 2022 Off Season Edition

    I agree Gaff needs to be in the magoos, just does not fit on the coalface and does not gut run anymore. Needs to win his spot along with Sheed.
  19. G

    Who will be better in 2023 Richmond or Brisbane?

    The addition of Dunkley and Gunton cannot be understated. that is at least 50 goals right there and a ready made rookie who will only get better. I think their list additions will add more that Richmond's.... but like so many times in the past ......I'm probably wrong :-)
  20. G

    Player Watch JHF - Jason Horne-Francis

    True that, North are better off without the distraction. In saying that, I was astounded north drafted him in he first place. There was a reason Adelaide put that massive offer on the table before get got taken by North, EVERYONE except maybe North knew he would not stay in Melbourne .
  21. G

    List Mgmt. Welcome Elijah Hewett (Pick 14, 2022 National Draft)

    AAAAAAND todays winner of the internet is........^^^^this guy^^^^^
  22. G

    What is Perth's shittest suburb?

    Which area exactly?.... got an address?.....asking for a friend.
  23. G

    Opinion AFL Team of Your Lifetime

    Cousins at his best was a sight to behold. He set the precedent for the modern hard running midfielder with skill. While others around him cramped up and needed the bench , he just puked his ring out and kept running.
  24. G

    Expansion Joondalup Falcons in the AFL?

    True, however that is marginally offset by the fact there is a national draft. Registered players would grow if there is a hometown team to play for. Start with Tassie first though, and see how that pans out.
  25. G

    Expansion Joondalup Falcons in the AFL?

    Bunbury would make sense , there are direct interstate flights to and from Busselton airport now (1hr drive from Bunbury) and outside of Perth, the region is the most populated area in WA .... Melbourne is the hub of AFL , WA has two sides, NSW has two sides and Qld has two sides. They all...
  26. G

    What is Perth's shittest suburb?

    https://www.perthnow.com.au/news/offbeat/armadale-named-perths-shittest-suburb-of-2021-by-s**t-towns-of-australia-ng-b881893100z
  27. G

    What is Perth's shittest suburb?

    I get Gosnell's but I Gotta ask , why Atwell?
  28. G

    Player Watch JHF - Jason Horne-Francis

    didn't ask if he was good or not.......still cried on the field.
Back
Top