Search results for query: *

Was not happy when he got chopped…

What caused him to collapse?

How good is this trade period to not have Dodo derailing other clubs trades. We might actually see a year where all clubs find equitable trades that are win/win for both sides.

If I remember correctly - the one knock on Sammy Walsh in his draft year was his kicking. His highlights showed a lot of balls falling short of the target. But at afl level I would say his kicking is quite good and his other attributes that he showed at juniors are what makes him so good. I...

Agree with most of what you say. But in regards to GWS and Suns… Suns are more of a basket case than GWS. Membership numbers over past few years consistently back that up. This year GWS 32k and suns only 21k. North had about 35k only a few years back if I recall correctly. GWS will build and...

I actually mostly agree with you. I just think that ruckman develop a bit later generally and his body type is very athletic but he still lacks the genuine size to compete. Darcy developed into a monster earlier than most, similar to Grundy. Point was that his upside potential could be bigger...

Regardless of differing opinions - you do win the medal for most obnoxious BF Carlton poster I reckon. TDK is a year younger than Darcy. His best has been sensational and more exciting than anything Darcy has done but he is so far inconsistent. Darcy has bloomed a year or so earlier than most...

They all have age on their side. He doesn’t. Calf injury is an ‘old man’s’ injury and at that age once they get chronic, they rarely come good.

So your nickname is wheelbarrow at work?

Agree with a lot you post on here mate but not this. 33 by next year and having constant calf issues this year is a concern at that age. He’s had great training leadership and sets a good example for young blokes but we have Cripps and Walsh and others who show enough of that. See if he wants...

Have to agree with the sentiments around Stocker. Stunned. Thought he was the player who played most like Vossy and he would have liked him. He had some flaws but too many positives to delist now. If he gets picked up by someone I will be dirty at the club but clubs generall y have conversations...

I’m neutral but if that goal review operator didn’t have his house in lions winning then he is obviously just a Brisbane supporter. What a cheat. Nobody could say that was a goal or not but it was definitely umpires call. Sad that games are decided in that way. Good game of footy other than that

I’m neutral but if that goal review operator didn’t have money on you blokes then he is obviously just a moron. Worst cheating I have ever seen. Don’t deserve to be there.

Both 193cm. May is 100kg and Kemp at start of the year was listed at 88kg but would be more than that now and will get more size. I was 85kg at 19 at 185cm and 3 years later 92kg with same fitness level. Maybe Kemp won’t get to be like May but I was comparing where he is likely to get to...

Don’t know where that is but give me decent notice coming from QLD these days and I will happily meet to prove the obvious 😉

The decision against Sidebottom was wrong but not laughable because there was definitely a sling/dangerous tackle element to it (although I think was minor and not a free kick) But there were many laughable free kicks that were not paid to us throughout the game that would have changed the...

I agree but also has similar attributes to Steven May at Melb as an intercepting plus one on one KPD. Whether he has that mongrel I’m not sure but I see him as that with some confidence and aggression..

Out of all the threads on here - this thread title is the most accurate. Everyone agrees except for a few delusional Bombers supporters. I bet one of them is Dodoro with an alias… is it Yoda? 😛

I respect you have an opinion. Watched it closely you say - maybe? Not had experience with getting hit in the back of the knee and the reality they buckle like Harry’s did - definitely. Happy to meet you at a game one day and do a role play to show you how the knee buckles like that. 👍

Although I haven’t seen Young play CHF, he seems to read the ball well enough to be tried in this role so this is a more than fair opinion. Durdin definitely not far behind and with a few games under the belt could easily equal or surpass Young.

Can’t agree with that one but S.Durdin is going to be solid injury depth. Lewis young has done some great things this year and got better consistently through the year. Has a few brain fade moments but I think that is a confidence thing and they will become fewer as they did with L.Jones over...

McKay dropped his knees?? How about you go outside and get a mate to stand behind you while you legs are straight and they thrust their knee into the back of yours and see if your legs stay straight. Then they fall on top of you. Let’s see if you shout ‘play on’. Watch the footage closely...

Just like almost every game of his career. All talent and no ticker.

A work colleague of mine (also a Carlton supporter) knows Graham Wright very well from playing footy with him in Tassie. Earlier in the year Wright told my mate that Voss interviewed well for Pies job last year but was seen as a great assistant coach but not head coach material. Well liked...

I agree mate. Time to watch basketball or soccer… oh s**t, wil just be same same… Might watch Rugby from now on - it’s still a contact sport.

To be honest, going by our history over the past 20 years we can realistically say it’s likely we get slammed by the Lions next week. Teams that are front runners like our squad don’t win big games.

The reality is - and most supporters won’t agree - but Carlton has the second most talent in the league behind Melbourne… But we have too many pretenders. Too many players who are soft and who are weak. Best thing may h committee could have done this week was drop H. He drops easy marks week in...

And again I will blow in for a quick laugh and response. Let’s be clear though - nobody hates Dodo. We love him. He is footy’s greatest fraud (as the thread title clearly states) and his antics and ego damage the club he works for and helps hold back a club that most non Essendon supporters...

We love a good laugh us Blues supporters… a good place to find comedy is reading the bombers supporters defence of dodo. We blow in from time to time, have a laugh and then get back to enjoying our lives in other areas.

Picking up free agents that are mids is easier than proven keys/spine players. Our rebuild was smart in the fact we built the spine first (which takes time to come on) and then added mids later through draft (who come in pretty quick) and free agency/trade to tidy up loose ends. Dodo has no...