Search results for query: *

  • Users: The Gotham Penguin
  • Order by date

Remove this Banner Ad

  1. The Gotham Penguin

    Ultimate Glory 2023 Trade speculation and Shinbeggars discussion

    Chol + F2 to Collingwood Ginnivan to Suns It's being discussed.
  2. The Gotham Penguin

    Ultimate Glory 2023 Trade speculation and Shinbeggars discussion

    If Blanck can hold down the FB spot - Ginnivan,Chol and Gunston should see you blokes rise up the ladder pretty rapidly tbh. Would turn those 1 goal losses into nailed on wins. Sneaky outside finals hope?
  3. oh boy.gif

    oh boy.gif

  4. The Gotham Penguin

    Ultimate Glory 2023 Trade speculation and Shinbeggars discussion

    Add a F1 and the deal gets done for pick 1 WCE need a name to put bums on seats, a talent, an excitement machine, and as much as people like CJ here at Hawthorn - Scrimmers gets the nod all day long in the back 6 based on what I've seen. Plus WCE may feel they have a shot at the younger...
  5. The Gotham Penguin

    Play Nice AFL Womens - General Discussion

    Nathan Burke was very frank - and it was overdue tbh. Some players just don't seem to be observing the basics regarding diet / nutrition / training in both the pre-season and in-season. I know it's almost a taboo to criticise anything AFLW - but it's season 7, and surely by now, the players...
  6. The Gotham Penguin

    Ultimate Glory 2023 Trade speculation and Shinbeggars discussion

    My prevoius thought on Chol and why he could be a great get under Sam Mitchell FWIW
  7. The Gotham Penguin

    Ultimate Glory 2023 Trade speculation and Shinbeggars discussion

    The sometimes injured Lewis, rookie Ryan and VFL Greene will struggle to kick a winning score tbh. Kosi going and McKay not coming leaves a few spots for talls. I posted a week or so back why Chol would be perfect for you guys, and that hasn't changed. $450,000 PA is his contract. He's...
  8. The Gotham Penguin

    Ultimate Glory 2023 Trade speculation and Shinbeggars discussion

    He looked good on TV in round 23. Then the Crows delisted him,so I'm not sure what to think of this guy.
  9. The Gotham Penguin

    Ultimate Glory 2023 Trade speculation and Shinbeggars discussion

    The poor guys a wreck with all the stuff with his missus. Hope it all works out for both of them ,but you have to fear the worst. Port have been super supportive apparently, so I can't see him leaving - not sure if he will play again tbh. Been through it all myself - the long term effects of...
  10. The Gotham Penguin

    Ultimate Glory 2023 Trade speculation and Shinbeggars discussion

    What are you on about? I haven't mentioned pick 29?? Wrong poster fella! All good.
  11. The Gotham Penguin

    Ultimate Glory 2023 Trade speculation and Shinbeggars discussion

    You've tried this year - it's all now riding on next year - if Hardwick gets us into finals - King stays. Another crap year - all bets are off. I'd imagine that applies to more players than Ben King as well. We have some high quality players - but there comes a time when the realisation dawns...
  12. The Gotham Penguin

    Ultimate Glory 2023 Trade speculation and Shinbeggars discussion

    I said that and got pelters. In Hawthorns forward line. with the delivery from the improving mids he should beat last years tally of 44 goals easily. To the doubters - how many extra games will a 40 - 50 goal Fwd / ruck win you The answer has to ge a couple surely. It's all about wether SM...
  13. The Gotham Penguin

    2023/2024 Gold Coast Draft & Trade periods

    So did you. Hardwick changed everything - as well you know. Behave.
  14. The Gotham Penguin

    Ultimate Glory 2023 Trade speculation and Shinbeggars discussion

    Why? It wouldn't affect the kid you want being drafted at #3 - you pick him at #4. #3 goes to WCE - and they still probably get Curtin. Swapping 3 + 4 shouldn't change anything as far as Hawthorn are concerned. And you get a forward. No drama - it's the hypothetical thread for a reason!
  15. The Gotham Penguin

    2023/2024 Gold Coast Draft & Trade periods

    Fair call. I did wonder. There's couple we could ship off with Sharpe and Hollands to improve WCE best 22!
  16. The Gotham Penguin

    Ultimate Glory 2023 Trade speculation and Shinbeggars discussion

    I posted earlier about Chols deficiencies. If SM can work them out of Chols game - result. Hawks are going into 2024 with Lewis Ryan and DGB (maybe Kosi too). Greene gets cut surely. Hawks are 1 key forward injury away from struggling to score - so unless I missed it (apologies if so) - are...
  17. The Gotham Penguin

    Ultimate Glory 2023 Trade speculation and Shinbeggars discussion

    HFC trade Pick #3 to GCS GCS trade pick #4 + Mabior Chol to HFC GCS trade pick 3 + Sharpe + Hollands + Graham to WCE WCE trade Pick #1 + #54 to GCS Hawks get KPF whilst dropping only 1 spot. WCE get 3 x best 22 players and still a high draft pick GCS get Harley Reid
  18. The Gotham Penguin

    2023/2024 Gold Coast Draft & Trade periods

    HFC trade Pick #3 to GCS GCS trade pick #4 + Mabior Chol to HFC GCS trade pick 3 + Sharpe + Hollands + Graham to WCE WCE trade Pick #1 + #54 to GCS Hawks get KPF whilst dropping only 1 spot. WCE get 3 x best 22 players and still a high draft pick GCS get Harley Reid (and the publicity...
  19. The Gotham Penguin

    No Oppo Supporters General AFL discussion and other club news

    Sicily was very harshly treated. As he was when McCreery put him down off the ball for a minute with a strike to the stomach. No free, no report.
  20. The Gotham Penguin

    No Oppo Supporters General AFL discussion and other club news

    I can't stand Collingwood, but even I cannot see any way that Maynard gets a suspension. he was in the air going to block. He can't defy gravity - he was landing in one spot. Unfortunately that was on Angus. Where does this turning the shoulder nonsense come from? Accident - play on. JVR...
  21. The Gotham Penguin

    NO TROLLS Homophobia in the AFL - 4 Corners

    Of course not. Any newspaper doing an article about Darcy, would no doubt be told by Darcy the correct way to refer to Darcy in the article. But you knew that, just as you knew that I already said that people who know or deal with Darcy should and do doubt do,address Darcy appropriately. I'm...
  22. The Gotham Penguin

    NO TROLLS Homophobia in the AFL - 4 Corners

    My son is gay - his words not mine upon watching a couple of minutes of AFLW - "is it a requirement to watch this crap to be actively gay, waving a rainbow flag and hugging your same sex partner?" "I've seen less queers in Sircuit than this" There is a real risk that AFLW football itself is...
  23. The Gotham Penguin

    Ultimate Glory 2023 Trade speculation and Shinbeggars discussion

    You gotta feel a little bit for Chol. Left Richmond after not being supported in 'grope-gate' and really, Dimma wasn't a fan. Goes north to be closer to family (and probably GC the best suitor even on about $450K per year) - and then finds out that his new coach is.......Dimma. All the talent...
  24. The Gotham Penguin

    Ultimate Glory 2023 Trade speculation and Shinbeggars discussion

    Being on the recieving end of one of BH pieces of drunken stupidity I can tell you that he 100% had off-field issues. You can start with him being a complete pisshead.
  25. The Gotham Penguin

    Ultimate Glory 2023 Trade speculation and Shinbeggars discussion

    Why pick up Henry when Weddle and even CJ could be much more damaging on a wing? With the news from your boards most reliable ITK that Ben M is coming, surely it means Weddle gets to go up the field? Henry just doesn't seem like a player that will add much to Hawthorn with their current list.
  26. The Gotham Penguin

    Ultimate Glory 2023 Trade speculation and Shinbeggars discussion

    At the end of 2024 how is Hardwick going to stop him? You reckon the shite served up today in Hobart is going to get BK rushing to sign an extension or ringing his agent to get the f*ck out of GC? And Flanders? The guy who already has had 3 meetings with Vic clubs - he's going to stay for 4...
  27. Capture.JPG

    Capture.JPG

  28. The Gotham Penguin

    Autopsy Round 24, 2023 : Hawks slow to a crawl

    I honestly got the impression Sam Mitchell didn't care about the win but was keen to try out a few moves and test some players in an AFL environment rather than VFL. Could Kosi lead the forward line? Could Finn play another role other than tagger Sicily and Scrimmers forward to test Serong...
  29. The Gotham Penguin

    Autopsy Round 24 vs North Melbourne Kangaroos @ Hobart - 26/08/23 - 1:45pm

    Oh - and did you guys see the TV footage of Chol and 2 coaches pissing around at half-time with lollies? Here's an idea - try to figure out how to beat the bottom club who haven't won for 20 games. It's like a kindergarten - no discipline, no heart, no soul.
Back
Top