My doubt about this proposal is that, to me, Sholl's biggest weakness is his extremely conservative disposal. It's rarely creative & damaging, just racks it up and moves it 40M forward down the wing to a contest.
Backline distributors need that courage to take the tough kicks slicing through...
No worries at all, but I picked Rankine first, Walker 2nd, so I put (Rankine, Walker). Seems to me you've go that backwards, but maybe you expect the names in "earliest vote to the right hand side" order?
Disagree Hulu. They took a good step tonight obviously, but it could be even better with Rach mixing it up also...
Laird/Crouch are not irreplaceable, they can and should be dropped entirely instead of just reduced, making more room.
Room, not just for Rash, but Pedlar, and maybe a young bloke...
I've only read this a few times in various threads, but it shits me when people say "Rachele/Rankine/Pedlar can't be/don't deserve midfield time, because otherwise they'd be in there and their stats don't look like midfielders right now"
That's the worst argument I've ever heard, if they were...
Nah mate, he's athletic and tries but his skills are super poor. Can hide that by being the Joe the Goose forward for us for a bit.
Needs to go eventually but believe it or not we've somehow got a bunch of blokes even shitter
I totally agree. I don't personally hold hope that Curtin is a full-time mid, but just might be a new Tom Lynch connector. Wouldn't that just be 1,000,000 times better than Murphy.
And we got him KPD in the SANFL... sigh.
Can't drop the young and potentially good players. It's not really their fault. A proper coach would have them all looking way better.
But the oldies should get no passes.
Unfortunately Murphy is injured so it won't look like a dropping 😕
A new (GOOD) coach would do what good coaches do when...
This is such a bad take mate.
Just because someone (Nicks) is better than Joe Rando doesn't mean they get to stay in a pointy end job, when their flaws are so evident and appear insurmountable.
BTW, we nearly made the 8 despite Nicks.
This has gone up from 7 just a couple of days ago, 4 a couple of weeks ago, and 2 when I first voted it xD
Love to see it!
Unfortunately it'll take the club longer to see it than many of us.
At least we have enough talent that we can still win a few games each year, despite all this.
I've got us 9th or 10th, don't think I was fooled but maybe :p Nah, we'll look a million bucks in some games, especially at home.
Don't worry, it's never as bad as it feels (or as good!). We'll bounce back.
Could even play a final, if Nicks stops picking teams poorly.
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.