Search results for query: *

Remove this Banner Ad

  1. S

    Have Richmond passed North and west coast

    The FA gaff deal in 2018? That would’ve netted us pick 19? Everyone in afl land said that was a good idea did they?
  2. S

    Have Richmond passed North and west coast

    Eagles have gained as many second rounders from slight trade downs than they’ve given in that period.
  3. S

    Have Richmond passed North and west coast

    Is this just Sherekhans expert opinion? Eagles have shown to be flexible in moving up and down the order dependent on the specific players they wanted. Getting extra second rounders in 2021 and 2024 by moving slightly down the order. In hindsight the 2021 slide down the draft has turned out...
  4. S

    List Mgmt. Welcome Elijah Hewett (Pick 14, 2022 National Draft)

    Is it not being reported that what WC have offered as opposed to him asking for it? Sounds like we’re trying to buy low before he signs a 2 year deal dominates and gets a better deal.
  5. S

    List Mgmt. Welcome Elijah Hewett (Pick 14, 2022 National Draft)

    This is from people that work at the club.
  6. S

    Have Richmond passed North and west coast

    I mean, I wouldn’t have any of them necessarily ahead of the other in terms of kicking right now. All are capable of ridiculous kicks and Lalor pulls it off probably more than the other two, but also has the worst retention/most turnovers of the three. Duursma probably has the highest peak...
  7. S

    Autopsy Round 8, 2026: Positives and Negatives vs Richmond

    This “Harley is a high teens high impact”, “might average 25 one day” is pretty hilarious considering he’s averaging 23.2 including 17D with one of the better taggers in the game running around with him.
  8. S

    Autopsy Round 8, 2026: Positives and Negatives vs Richmond

    I find that far less fun than Reid more than doubling Martin’s coaches votes by round 8. You can admit you had a shocker mate. Everything points to Reid in year 3 being the better player than Martin in year 3.
  9. S

    Autopsy Round 8, 2026: Positives and Negatives vs Richmond

    In year 3 he averaged less disposals a game than Harley is currently and polled 9 coaches votes which was good for 13th in his side and tied 178th in the league, he finished the year with 5 Brownlow votes. Harley is currently on 21 coaches votes, sitting around 20th in the league and by far the...
  10. S

    Autopsy Round 8, 2026: Positives and Negatives vs Richmond

    What a braindead take. Harley averages more disposals and clearances than Martin did at the same age yet isn’t as consistent. He’s currently sitting just outside the top 20 in coaches votes playing in an awful side. “Ok” apparently is being considered the second best player on the ground by...
  11. S

    Autopsy Round 8, 2026: Positives and Negatives vs Richmond

    ****ing lol at Harley being a net Nil. Some of you campaigners should genuinely give up watching the game.
  12. S

    Have Richmond passed North and west coast

    I’ve already said it was a good game from Richmond’s younger players. Doesn’t really change the past does it? Richmond’s wins last year were due to their senior players, the fact this year they’ve started getting win due to their young players is a huge positive.
  13. S

    Have Richmond passed North and west coast

    Yeah what a ridiculous comparison 🙄 This in spite of Bailey having nowhere near the injury history and coming into the season with 27 games under his belt as opposed to Hewett coming into off a full year out and only having 14 games in his first year under the belt. Hewett may not reach the...
  14. S

    Have Richmond passed North and west coast

    Again SF stocks have been addressed recently, T.Williams, Champion, Newton, Murdock, and even Gross all drafted in the last two years. It will take time for these kids to come good if they do end up good but the need has been addressed for the time being. There’s very few teams with “elite...
  15. S

    Have Richmond passed North and west coast

    I don’t even know why this comparison is a thing, I laughed at the notion that Mcaullife has shown more in his last three games than Hewett in his career. Something which your dearly loved player ratings disagrees with. We have a pick 65 outperforming your pick 7 from the same draft, things...
  16. S

    List Mgmt. Welcome Elijah Hewett (Pick 14, 2022 National Draft)

    Why would he need 25 in the WAFL? When bat now has he been “gifted” games since you seem to think it’s a trend? He started slow last year as well before almost dragging us over the line vs Essendon. If we had made him toil in the WAFL until he had 25D we would have missed out on a huge...
  17. S

    Have Richmond passed North and west coast

    Lol, was merely stating that Key defenders impact should not be judged by disposals. If you watched the game and didn’t have Ginbey top 3 on the field for the eagles, you don’t watch footy to closely.
  18. S

    List Mgmt. Welcome Elijah Hewett (Pick 14, 2022 National Draft)

    Not a lot, he’s clearly been brought back underdone and is lacking touch after a stint of no footy. That doesn’t mean he isn’t a hard worker/highly competitive. The discourse is honestly pretty bullshit and unfair and seems to me that it stems from Hewett loving a big celebration after a...
  19. S

    Have Richmond passed North and west coast

    Lol, did you watch the game? Imagine using statistics to determine a key defenders impact. Dylan Grimes “only” averaged 11 disposals his entire career.
  20. S

    List Mgmt. Welcome Elijah Hewett (Pick 14, 2022 National Draft)

    Clearly not, because I know for a fact he’s one of the harder trainers at the club. Would you know how hard he works? Or are you making baseless assumptions from what you can see on the television.
  21. S

    Have Richmond passed North and west coast

    Who are the currently “very good” players Richmond were missing, if we aren’t counting solid role players like Robertson and Graham and others due to not playing enough games, surely only Nankervis, Taranto and Lalor can be considered as opposed to Starcevich and Edwards for the Eagles. Our...
  22. S

    Have Richmond passed North and west coast

    Ginbey was our second best player.
  23. S

    Have Richmond passed North and west coast

    He meant Harley.
  24. S

    Have Richmond passed North and west coast

    Was definitely a good game from the Tiger youngsters, I wouldn’t say as a group they were vastly superior though. I think the performance of the youngsters (particularly Faull, Burton and Gray) who hadn’t shown as much prior to the game should be as/more exciting than the win. Was...
  25. S

    List Mgmt. Welcome Elijah Hewett (Pick 14, 2022 National Draft)

    This is bullshit, Elijah is a very hard trainer. Commenting from your couch is easy though.
  26. S

    Have Richmond passed North and west coast

    28 touches @ 71% and a goal - 11.9 rating, likely coaches votes 21 touches @ 81% and a goal - 13.9 rating 23 touches @ 70% - 7.4 rating Bombers - R6 last year - 22 touches @ 50% and 2 goals - 14.3 rating, 5 coaches votes, 1Bl vote Dees- R8 - 15 touches at 80% and 3 goals - 21.1 rating Dees -...
  27. S

    Have Richmond passed North and west coast

    How so. Do opponents matter or not? Because many Richmond fans thought so when Faull was taking the #1 KPD. Now you’re changing the goalposts and claiming it doesn’t.
  28. S

    Have Richmond passed North and west coast

    Mcaullife has not shown the ceiling of Hewett vs Essendon and Melbourne last year. He also hasn’t shown more in 3 games than Hewetts entire career, it is absolutely a lol worthy statement. Career averages aren’t good due to subs, differences in age when their percentages of games played were...
  29. S

    Have Richmond passed North and west coast

    Richmond fans: “Faulls early season form can’t be held against him as he had the #1 KPD”. Also Richmond fans: “opponent doesn’t matter, can’t take that into account, stop changing goalposts”. How do you blokes afford to live honestly? Not one degree between you all.
  30. S

    Have Richmond passed North and west coast

    Opponent very clearly matters, which is the entire reason Faulls recent performances can be excused. If anything it’s Richmond fans that are changing the goalposts. You have a room temp IQ.

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom