In regards to the guy who was citing Chapman vs O'Meara as an argument vs what i said, clearly irrelevant given the age and profiles of the players i was comparing (Crameri vs Docherty).
I'm well aware, and understand what you are trying to say, but think we've kind of gone a bit off the...
Given you guys offered him a 4 year contract at 480 k a pop, i'd suggest the powers at be in your club rate him fairly highly, and the fact they're only willing to offer Grant 1, should tell you were he stands in the pecking order.
Docherty hasn't done anything at AFL level yet, "potential" is...
This is just stupid, you'd prefer a player who has done nothing at AFL level over a forward who will kick you 40 + goals a year?
On output all 17 other clubs in the league would take Crameri.
Do you know what the term "match" means?
I'll give you some help "One that is exactly like another; a counterpart. b. One that is like another in one or more specified qualities".
The only thing that St Kilda can change in terms of manipulating the payments to Goddard is to change the amount...
Goddard is a star of the competition, what is wrong with adding talent to our list?
We could have tried to pick up a list clogger like Knights, but we'll that for your rabble of a club.
To me Caddy may well become an elite player but based on output it is still a highly speculative pickup. To trade a number one ruck or someone of equal importance to our systems and structure in Dempsey. It kind of defeats the purpose of bringing in Caddy if we were to trade Dempsey in the deal...
Why on worth would we trade Dempsey? You only trade players that are surplus to your needs unless the player you are trading in is a proven jet ala Judd to Carlton when they traded Kennedy.
I agree with Sunny a third party would probably need to be involved to get a deal done between Essendon...
That is also applicable for Gumbleton and Essendon, do you really think after persisting with him for this long that we are just going to let him walk out the door the minute he starts to show a bit of promiss? Given the faith and support Essendon has shown in him, i doubt he'd want to leave...
Wasted 20 seconds of the shotclock which put pressure on offensively for the last 5 mins of that quarter. Watson has to finish off games because Lucas whilst a good shooter, cannot create.
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.