Search results for query: *

Remove this Banner Ad

  1. cherub

    Player Watch #15 Sam Wicks

    I think Sam gets judged harshly, and certainly doesn’t get kudos he deserves. Paps goal of the week last year against (?) GWS where there was a 1-2 back and forth with Wicks along the wing was as much Wicks goal as Paps. Wicks took an amazing mark in the goal square one time, almost jack-knifed...
  2. cherub

    Player Watch #21 Errol Gulden - born to play

    There needs to be a chapter where they all earned more in their post-football careers because they were premiership players.
  3. cherub

    List Mgmt. 2024 Draft & Trade Hypotheticals

    Clearly you don’t live in Perth. Accuracy is optional in Perth media. (And a lot of other media).
  4. cherub

    Player Watch #15 Sam Wicks

    I think it must suck to be a fringe player. Why is Sam named and not the other player.? He is effectively being punished, publicly.
  5. cherub

    VFL 2024 Swans Reserves

    Horse probably knows it. But he will be developing useful connections for whatever sports-related career he takes up. As well as all of the benefits of playing high level sport.
  6. cherub

    Media Swans Talk in the Media 2024

    Insult to the 4*2. It least it’s potentially attractive and useful.
  7. cherub

    POTY Round 1 vs Melbourne

    5Heeney4Grundy 3.Blakey 2McInerney 1Papley YPOTY :Campbell
  8. cherub

    Mega Thread The Former Player Thread: Part 2

    Kieran’s wife is from Perth. Her family are here. I wondered if the Don Pyke connection would come in handy. Although I do see it as slightly treasonous!
  9. cherub

    Training Pre Season - Who's deadset training the house down 2024 style.

    I think the responses are coloured by the residence of the authors. My 10 year old daughter was sworn at by WCE fans on entering Subiaco Oval for 2005 prelim. final. Perth is quite small in its way, and it was not uncommon to see Eagles players, or know someone at the same event with reports of...
  10. cherub

    Coaching Staff Simon Dalrymple

    I agree. Dalrymple was at the Swans 6 years. It’s a reasonable tenure in a high performance industry and when Sydney is such an expensive place to live. Isn’t Dalrymple originally from Victoria, so friends and family are there. All the reporting I have read describes Kinnear as well-respected...
  11. cherub

    Mega Thread The Former Player Thread: Part 2

    Charlotte’s family are in Perth. Might be more support than they get in Sydney. Kieren achieved a Masters in something financial and was working for one of the Big (Evil) 4 accounting firms. Even if he’s not working for them,as an ex AFL player in Perth, he is eminently employable. Don Pyke...
  12. cherub

    Player Watch #6 Logan McDonald

    He’s only competing with Errol for Norm Smith and Skilton. They can both have the others simultaneously Or alternate years.
  13. cherub

    News Swans Talk in the Media 2023

    What’s a big blast of reality is how few draftees really go on to have an AFL career. And how inappropriate the over the top media attention on draftees is. And late picks often do ok.
  14. cherub

    List Mgmt. 2023 Draft & Trade Hypotheticals

    I think we agree to disagree. Some of the reporting on Freo has been very inaccurate. And their obsession with NicNat was nauseating. They’ve improved since they changed AFL journalists. I would have thought most of their Swannies reports were from syndicated sources.
  15. cherub

    List Mgmt. 2023 Draft & Trade Hypotheticals

    No.Stokes. Still pretty right-wing and I would never call it reliable in football matters.
  16. cherub

    List Mgmt. 2023 Draft & Trade Hypotheticals

    I agree. He does a lot of hard, team oriented stuff which is not flashy. Papley gets the goal, but Wicks running inside of him clears the way, and gives him the one-two pass option. He does a lot of stuff like that, but I could see that he might like to be more secure. He seems to have reigned...
  17. cherub

    List Mgmt. 2023 Draft & Trade Hypotheticals

    You mean $500000 a year, and incidentally there’s a house going, with a harbour view, near Coogee Beach for $500000. And I hear the local fashion store has some well-paid work.
  18. cherub

    Player Watch #6 Logan McDonald

    Errol, with his genius level footy IQ, has already strategised how to keep the other necessary pieces of the footy puzzle to achieve a footy dynasty. He’s got a long term view.
  19. cherub

    List Mgmt. 2023 Draft & Trade Hypotheticals

    Why do you say WCE won’t take him? He would be perfect for running the wings at the Perth Stadium.He looked fabulous the Covid year we played there. Still remember the great goal he kicked against GWS.
  20. cherub

    List Mgmt. 2023 Draft & Trade Hypotheticals

    It was a post-operative ankle infection. Difficult to clear, and took around a year, but once it’s clear then it’s gone. It meant he didn’t play for over a year, but equally his muscles/tendons weren’t being subject to strain. He’s proved his recovery in the WAFL, and been behind a good back...
  21. cherub

    List Mgmt. 2023 Draft & Trade Hypotheticals

    Hmm. I reckon doing a home-made tattoo on your foot, when you’re a footballer, is an idiot act in a class of its own.
  22. cherub

    Opinion 2024 and Beyond

    Haha. DQ probably lives near the SAS base in Perth.
  23. cherub

    Opinion 2024 and Beyond

    Was Trengove and Jack Grimes as co-captains.
  24. cherub

    Player Watch #14 Callum Mills (c)

    I also wonder if there wasn’t some pre-existent weakness/tear that made an innocuous act damaging. Konstanty is hardly a big guy. They do wrestling sometimes as a training routine.
  25. cherub

    List Mgmt. 2023 Draft & Trade Hypotheticals

    And he looks great with his shirt ripped off! I mean he’s not afraid to stand up for himself and the team.
  26. cherub

    List Mgmt. 2023 Draft & Trade Hypotheticals

    Oh no! He’ll become a merchant banker. I thought better of him.
  27. cherub

    List Mgmt. 2023 Draft & Trade Hypotheticals

    Pretty sure Dawson didn’t announce his intention to leave till after the B&F.
  28. cherub

    Opinion Posts That Don't Deserve a Thread (Random Opinion or Questions)

    So, 10c per member.
  29. cherub

    Game Day 2023 Non-Swans Game Day

    I’ve seen a lot of attempted smothers. I’ve never seen one before that caused so much contact. I’ve seen legs fallen across, but never such a degree of front on body force. What was different about Maynard’s technique.
Back
Top