The thing is that if he kicks 4.2 instead of 3.3, we win.
Same against Hawthorn.
Maybe against WCE.
No-one is asking him to convert 100% of his setshots, but he seems to be going at 50-50 at the moment, with the ones he's missing the technically easier shots. If he can get it to 65-35, it...
Couldn’t agree more. Wines is playing his best footy since 2021.
Re Butters and JHF, this is why we need more options coming through the midfield. Even a kid like Moraes when he gets up to speed could provide a point of difference there.
Two big positives from the last three weeks are:
1) the way we are defending. Against Geelong we defended the whole ground very well. Against the Crows we defended the back 50 well.
2) Efficiency of getting scores for inside 50 entries. Goal conversion would bolster this further.
Tackling to...
Just need to turn the close losses into wins before the end of the season. Make sure that close losses don't become too associated with this playing/coaching group.
I'm with you.
The suggestion that he is a good kick is off the mark. He's got what looks like a straight, neatish left-foot kick, but it lacks penetration and we haven't seen any evidence that he kick reliably beyond 45 m.
He has been better the past two weeks, but his direct opponent today...
Those two goals will do his confidence the world of good. The snap on his left was a thing of real beauty. Happy he stood up when it mattered. He needs to be careful though playing on from marks in the goal-square. More than one very good player has got caught doing that in big games before.
3 goals is another good effort.
I'd just let him stay up forward the rest of the year. Let's see if he can kick 20-25 goals from his next 10 games. If he can, then maybe there's something there to persist with as a forward. We have next to no depth in tall forwards.
If we take the longterm view of finishing lower to optimise our draft hand while building a strong game plan and resilient culture, then it’s probably ok. I just don’t think Showdowns where the cards fall our way should be the games we accept losing, by whatever margin.
Statistically we had a lot of guys below their best:
JHF 20 disposals
Farrell 12
Richards 10
Burgoyne 14
MacKinlay 5
If Farrell, Burgoyne and Richards are not finding the footy then we’re not linking up well enough to take it inside 50.
This is how I see it. We went into this game with momentum and playing the stronger footy. We looked classier until Soligo and Murray had their minute of glory to set up and kick 2 late in the third.
I doubt we get Adelaide again where Thilthorpe and Curtin are ineffective, Dawson missing...
It's early days, but Josh has now overseen a 1 pt loss, 2 pt loss and 3 pt loss this year. We've not been up to it in close games under him. It may become a habit losing close ones.
The one thing he's doing best at the moment is his intercept marking. The rest of his game is not quite in order yet at AFL level. He's not bad, but he's not showing the other traits that he has based on SANFL exposure.
19 tackles from a midfielder, in a game when Butters and JHF got caught every time they took possession, was pretty influential from Berry. My top 3 would have been:
1. Milera
2. Aliir
3. Berry
Not a trend, just a fact.
Butters, Rozee and JHF can't respond to intense congestion. They don't fight their way through it. We do need a plan B.
It wasn't coincidental that late in the game the only midfielders who were getting anywhere near the clearance for us were Wines and Drew. Wines...
He's become our lest reliable kick for goal. Absolute myth that he's a good kick.
Not sure what frustrates more: the misses from straight out in front, or the stupid unrealistic flies in the pack that he goes for to concede unnecessary free kicks.
His good is good. If his opponent was Milera tonight, then he probably cost us the game though. The fact that he trailed Milera to that last bouncing ball that came out of defensive 50 and couldn't effectively pin the tackle is evidence of that. Cost us the game as much as any play.
What hurts is that we got Adelaide at a very good time. It wasn't Thilthorpe who killed us, it wasn't Worrell. It was Berry, Soligo, Cook, Milera, Rachelle, Keays and Rankine. Our similar players should have been able to get the better of that group. We didn't.
I don't think it's that, but his record in recent Showdowns is not of a big game player. It's the same in finals. He can't fight his way through the congestion. Almost becomes unrecognisable in the way he goes about it, and when he does get a hint of space, he rarely kicks efficiently.
Has been for a fair while. I'm surprised that no-one at the club has called him out on it. He's become a Crows sycophant. Really commentates against us. Don't think he does so against other teams.
I felt we lost it in quarters 2 and 3. We started getting out hunted around the ground. They were ostensibly more ferocious than us both in tackling and getting their arms free in tackles, and they got their spread back, often getting multiple numbers around the perimeter to receive the handball...
He's been a solid performed for them this year. He and Soligo just tough it out against us more often than not. THey are JHF and Butters' kryptonite. Neither of our guys stay in the fight long enough against them. Wines and Drew did their best.
Our rucks couldn't get our midfielders into it. But I swear I've never seen Butters outworked so obviously. Just didn't will himself into the game after HT at all.