Search results for query: *

Softest tackle attempts I’ve ever seen

SDK just not enough mongrel We’re playing very poor all over missing targets, marks out on the full kicks Missing easy chances running fwd Blind kicks Feel like dees have come to play and we’ve been drinking our bath water

Good mark, but lacks intensity, lacks burst speed and hasn’t got enough agility for a mid ( he tends to walk into a tackler, lift his arms with his height to release a handball - that’s not going to cut it). Would be shocked if he makes it

Conway maybe will prove a win (I’m very hopeful) but knevitt is zero, will not make it. Effectively Conway vs Clark. Clark is very good and a loss to us but hopefully Conway had yet getter career long term.

Definitely would pick smith over Perkins. Smith is a point of difference and much higher ceiling. Still young and has the ability to be a top 5 mid in the game if he’s focussed and is different to all our mids. ACL is a risk though. Perkins is more a standard B grader that most teams have. No...

Constable played a decent game for geelong too… knevitt has shown very little compared to others of his age on our list

What exactly does SDK do? Looks soft, mentally shot, can’t take any marks off opposition, can’t spoil. Just turned into a nothing player

Conway Dempsey mullin should play most games this year. An example of kids that have shown a glimpse (unlike sat, knevitt)

What mullin did just before is why we should persist with him in the 22. The kid is a special talent

Agree with oisin. But we can’t be giving games to knevitt who is just not an afl player

Because knevitt is so far off it and lacks intensity.. at least oisin has the talent, just needs confidence. Way more potential in oisin than knevitt. There is a reason knevitt is down the pecking order

SDK is hopeless. He’s run out if credits for me

Our defensive positioning is horrible

I think I love Dempsey

This keeps happening. Saints have a few blind kick and hopes and it works with us out of position. As frustrating as it is, it highlights our poor positioning behind the ball

Dempsey is going to be a great geelong player

Dempsey needs to settle the nerves and kick this

We have minimal defensive pressure. Especially in our forward half

JUH is unrealistic Bailey smith would completely change our midfield and should be our no 1 realistic target

Kids I’m excited about (in no particular order): Holmes O. Henry Clark SDK Conway Dempsey Bruhn COS Kids I believe in but not 100% convinced: Mullin Neale Kids I think are overrated on this board and would be surprised to see make it: Knevitt Clohesy Too early to tell you include last...

Dempsey had impressed me most. Going to be a gun. Clark looks like he will be a nice cog. Neale might be a player. I think Mannagh will be an important role player for us this yr and over the next few. I know knevitt didn’t play but he’s nowhere near the above in terms of best 22.

Knevitt hasn’t shown anything in his entire career compared to dempsey’s quarter. Frankly I’d be shocked if knevitt makes it

Dempsey extremely impressive. Best of our young players by far.

Clark’s kicking hasn’t improved from last week… hopefully it’s still just nerves

Assuming Guthrie is injured: Fb. Stewart. Dekoning. Kolo Hb. Zuthrie. J.Henry. Holmes C. Duncan. Blicavs. Miers Hf. Close. O.Henry. Cameron Ff. Dempsey. Hawkins. Stengle Foll. Stanley. Danger. Atkins Int. Neale. Touhy. Bruhn. O’Connor. S. Bowes Emg. Clark. Mannagh. Conway

Way to early to call but based on everything so far, Mckenzie looks a lot more impressive…

He can be quick at combine conditions but he plays slow and reactionary. He can’t breakaway from players and instead has a habit of walking into tackles, freeing the arms with his height to hb away. Not ideal for a midfielder. His combine results mean zero when he plays with cement feet

But he’s the same age as Conway. We do need more rucks but someone a little younger than Stanley to ease Conway into it. Having a ruck the same age as Conway makes little sense unless we think Conway won’t make it, potentially due to durability

Cannot play in the same team as Conway. Strange selection

Why would we select edwards when there is zero chance we could play both Conway and edwards in the same team in the future?? Can someone please explain.