Search results for query: *

  • Users: mrb1
  • Order by date

Remove this Banner Ad

  1. mrb1

    Opinion Your 2026 R1 team

    Fogarty kicked 11 goals last year in 20 games. That was his best return. He has kicked 36 goals in his 90 game career. He can't kick over a jam tin. He's not very good. What's saving him is that he's a pet of Vossy's. The trouble is you win games by kicking goals, not by laying tackles even...
  2. mrb1

    Opinion Your 2026 R1 team

    Newman hasn't participated in match sim yet. So let's see what happens. I'd rather he had a bit more time.
  3. mrb1

    Opinion Your 2026 R1 team

    I'm going to assume that Newman and Acres won't be ready for the first game. B: Cowan, Weitering, Wilson HB: Carroll, Dean, Saad C: Walsh, Cripps, O Hollands HF: Hayward, McKay, Ainsworth F: Williams, O'Keeffe, Evans Foll: Pittonet, Lord, Smith Int: Kemp, Hewitt, Cerra, Florent, Byrne Emerg: L...
  4. mrb1

    Opinion Your 2026 R1 team

    1. Where's Frank the Tank? 2. Who takes Haynes spot for the first game? It's either L Young, McGovern or Wilson.
  5. mrb1

    Opinion Your 2026 R1 team

    Haynes is out.
  6. mrb1

    Analysis 2025 Draft watch

    How long do you want to wait until success? 32 years, 34 years, 36 years or longer? We can not wait. We need talent now. Don't trade current picks into future drafts. It's an endless putting off until tomorrow what you can do today.
  7. mrb1

    Draft Review 2025 AFL Draft General Discussion

    I understand. I'm sure not it's going to happen that way. If Dean is still available at 11 then they're likely to trade for lower picks once and be done with that. Then see how low the picks go before a Dean bid comes in. The key is not to lose total points value when you trade down.
  8. mrb1

    Draft Review 2025 AFL Draft General Discussion

    I don't think Essendon will agree to this. Picks 9, 11 and 43 total 2744. Picks 6, 21, 27 and 30 total 3367. That is a gain of 623 points for nothing. Essendon need to match bids as well for their academy players. If you take off Pick 30 then the difference is 169. Essendon might be prepared...
  9. mrb1

    Draft Review 2025 AFL Draft General Discussion

    I can only see three players getting bid on before Pick 9, that being Uwland, Patterson and Annable. That would take Pick 9 out to Pick 12. Who are the other two players that you think will be bid on before Pick 9? I don't see any logic that says Pick 16 next year is better than Pick 12 this...
  10. mrb1

    Draft Review 2025 AFL Draft General Discussion

    Why would you need to move Pick 11 back bit by bit? If Dean doesn't get bid on before 9 then you have a free hit on best available which may be Grlj or Schubert. Then you match Dean at 10 or select him at 11. Picks 43 and 54 which will come in due to Gold Coast and Brisbane academy selections...
  11. mrb1

    Draft Review 2025 AFL Draft General Discussion

    So would you trade Pick 9 for a future first with Geelong, Brisbane, Gold Coast or Hawthorn? That would be crazy.
  12. mrb1

    Draft Review 2025 AFL Draft General Discussion

    Carlton should not trade for a future first. They already have two. How do you know what guarantees Walker? The AFL have not confirmed the rules yet. They have already hinted that you may only be allowed to use two picks and you won't know how valuable Carlton's and Sydney's R1 picks are until...
  13. mrb1

    List Mgmt. 2025 List Management II 📃

    That's why Frankie looks so good.
  14. mrb1

    List Mgmt. 2025 List Management II 📃

    Not only that. Kennedy and Masten (Pick 3) won a premiership at West Coast. Judd didn't win one at Carlton. So we lost.
  15. mrb1

    List Mgmt. 2025 List Management II 📃

    Gov and EH are not worth a pick of any value (i.e. nothing under Pick 55).
  16. mrb1

    List Mgmt. 2025 List Management II 📃

    It doesn't. Gold Coast will never give up Pick 6 unless they get more points on return. They need the points for their academy players.
  17. mrb1

    List Mgmt. 2025 List Management II 📃

    So we failed in our list management. We thought the older/senior players were going to carry us through, but they didn't or couldn't. We cut too deep.
  18. mrb1

    List Mgmt. 2025 List Management II 📃

    Were we better in 2023 or 2025?
  19. mrb1

    List Mgmt. 2025 List Management II 📃

    You forgot Dow and Fisher both traded out in 2023. Plowman retired. O'Brien, Honey and Philp delisted.
  20. mrb1

    List Mgmt. 2025 List Management II 📃

    Josh Kennedy was in our best 22 when that trade went down. We lost that trade. Kennedy won a flag with the Eagles and Judd didn't win one with us.
  21. mrb1

    List Mgmt. 2025 List Management II 📃

    The draft is not poor. It just has a F/S and NGA players that are high up in the rankings. So that will push many teams' picks lower. Every draft has good players. Name me a draft that doesn't. We really need good young elite talent now. Why delay the mini-rebuild one more year when you can do...
  22. mrb1

    List Mgmt. 2025 List Management II 📃

    That's why we have picks so that we can match the bids. Don't stress on it. We can't control where the bids come out. We just need the picks ready. Why do you think Gold Coast have Picks 6, 12 and 15? That's so they can cover bids on their academy picks. If Uwland is bid on at Pick 1 then they...
  23. mrb1

    List Mgmt. 2025 List Management II 📃

    It's not critical. It would be better if Dean was not bid on until Pick 50, but we can't control that. So don't stress on it. St Kilda could bid on Dean. Essendon could bid on Dean. If they do then we need to have TDK's compo pick ready. We still have the JSOS compo pick to use on another top...
  24. mrb1

    List Mgmt. 2025 List Management II 📃

    We're going to get two top 20 picks due to FA compo (barring FS/NGA adjustments). One pick goes to Dean and the other one goes to Grlj, Greeves, Ludowyke or Dovaston. Our Pick 34 goes to Ison and Pick 44 goes to next best available. Get four quality kids in each year and we will soon be back. We...
  25. mrb1

    List Mgmt. 2025 List Management II 📃

    Curnow to Sydney Warner and Pick 9 (Syd) to WC Pick 1 (WC) and Pick 11 (WC) to Port Butters to Carlton All picks are those currently held. Compo picks haven't been allocated yet.
  26. mrb1

    List Mgmt. 2025 List Management II 📃

    If you trade away both compo picks how are you getting Dean, remembering we need next year's picks for Cody?
  27. mrb1

    Analysis 2025 Draft watch

    Why would we do that? It would be great to have a pick before Dean to pick up the likes of Sam Grlj. But if the bid for Dean comes in and you trade out the compo pick what are you going to use to match the bid for Dean? A ham sandwich? We need that pick to match Dean. If his bid comes after our...
  28. mrb1

    Hot Topic Michael Voss - Okay, he's gone ... but when?

    Charlie should be put into the midfield. It might rev him up.
  29. mrb1

    Leagues 2025 SuperCoach Leagues - FULL HOUSE

    I'd like to join a league if possible. Team Name: Mal Formed 2024 Position: 64,586
  30. mrb1

    Leagues 2024 SuperCoach - Need a League Filled - Post Code Here

    Thanks. I'm in. Mal T.

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom