Search results for query: *

Convince me why you think you will keep Gibbs....the only reason I will keep him is because he may get more midfield time with Murphy out....but watching him yesterday he was running around like a headless chook

He is getting the bullet from me too. I don't have Dangerfield so am going Gibbs > Danger to get the DPP. Doing that I will miss out on Zorko but still get the DPP in the mids. Any ideas?

Thanks for your reply. Yeah Gibbs was a risk. I wanted a point of difference in my team at the start of the season, and this one has not paid off. Prob should have played it safe but it's all good in hindsight. I will see what I can do to hold him until the bye. In the meantime my backs need...

Horsely

^^ I have Horsely too

I have a dilemma. I don't know what to do with Gibbs and Rocky is up and down ATM. My midfield is Boyd, Pendlebury, Rockliff, Gibbs, Coniglio, Magner and Clay Smith. Got 110 in the bank. Thinking of going Ellis to Spurr freeing up enough cash to Possibly go Gibbs to Swan or Stanton. I know...

I am very tempted. You got rid of him before his price drop so that looks like a good move now. I am torn on what to do really. if i trade him out I bet he will hit a rich vein of form.

What do people think of Lewis as a swap for Goodes? Averaging 90 and super consistent. Robbo/beams/Sidey/Chappy or popular choices, but just thought I would put this one out there. Doesn't have as big ceiling as the others but may be a good point of difference if you need someone different in...

Feeling the same way with Gibbs mate. He will keep leaking cash so I Am thinking about getting rid of him too. He isn't playing a midfield role and isn't having the breakout season I thought he would. Horsley is a must and he will average the same as Gibbs for the next few week IMO. Never like...

What's the point of playing one game then operating the week after? All or none I would have thought. If he needs surgery, get him in now so we can get him back ASAP

Can't believe some of you so called supporters are bagging Pav?? He is out of form but he is our captain and he will come good. The way the game is played these days 36 players are in the forward 50 which makes it all the more harder. We some better plans and disposal he will kick bags off 5 or...

Johnson? Harsh

If he goes in for an operation he will be back for September

There will be a spot for Neale also. Pav and Sandi have another 3 years in them I reckon

It's a good dilemma to have

Look it's round 2. None of the changes will happen besides forced ones if required to Mellington and Duff. In comes Mundy and Silvagni maybe. Pav won't get suspended and none of the others will get dropped

You can expect to cop it maybe so, but to have it deleted immediately?? Don't think so. everyone is entitled to an opinion

True good point that...i think Jones is a real possibility though

Could there be a chance of someone like Goddard following Lyon to Freo? he won't win a premiership at the Saints and he will top off our list. the only thing is who we could give up for him.... I think we could be in with a chance to get Clint Jones for Crowley/Pearce...or a player like...

Hit the nail on the head

That is my point exactly. Any opinion you have that does not align with their thoughts are dismissed and your post is deleted.

After reading both forums over the past few days, I would just like to say that the quality of the posts on Big Footy far outweigh the rubbish that is posted at Dockerland. keep it up guys

I am excited too. if you pop over to dockerland.com they are very negative about the whole thing. I feel for mark harvey but it is in the clubs best interest to get the best available coach and we finally have! looking forward to next year. can't wait!

Go Lower > Suckling. That would give you a pretty settled backline, then start to upgrade your forwards. Knights would be a good M7. Moves up the ground a bit and tries to get some cheap possies. Coming off 116

Keep Swallow, good back up when other players have byes during the season. Option 2 and 3 is a bit of a coin toss. Both your forwards and backs are similar strength. Tapscott has better JS than Lower so maybe that might influence your decision. I would go Enright if you go option 2, you only...

Hard to know without seeing your full team. Depends what bench is weaker...if you are going to go option 1, I would choose Mundy. Carlton have a finals bye.

Better to trade out Libba in my opinion. Swallow has better JS and their byes have finished so keep him.

Heaps of people seem to be going Suckling, but I am going to stay clear of that. I like the Lower to Fisher trade. I am thinking about going the same. Like you said, can move Goddard into the mids when they have their bye. he is a proven dreamteamer and Suckling, although is cheap and has a low...

this guy burnt me bad last season, he is off my radar

This was a good read and good thread until you turned up!