Search results for query: *

Sorry to stick my nose in.........but Rioli's 3rd quarter 3 on 1 effort on the wing and subsequent free kick, was to me the play of the year. As that unfolded I went from thinking you guys were in trouble, to thinking he may force a ball up which would be a great win...to scratching my head when...

Well done Hawks....right team won and was stoked to see it. :thumbsu:

Actually just glad to see he does talk rubbish about other teams as well after reading his waffle about the Eagles and his Judd obsessions. Sorry Hawks! Parrot is a peanut, usually spends his time on the Polls Board, and treats it like his own little personal Bay 13, somehow getting away with...

Can actually understand Hawks (or any interstate) supporters not being fond of the Eagles if they lived in Perth. I lived in Melbourne for 4 years and actually enjoyed supporting the Eagles more there than I do here. Even as a supporter I get sick of the lame, biased articles and almost...

That is a seriously nice looking jumper! :thumbsu:

Would certainly be karma if Kennedy did live up to potential and become the next big thing. I feel for him, and hope Eagles fans really take him into their hearts. I don't take offence that he originally wanted to stay, shows he's a genuine bloke whose first preference was to be loyal. I...

Not so sure that is the case. I'm not saying he deliberately screwed us over out of spite at all, but he had to know the consequences of choosing only one club. Yet he went ahead and did it anyway, and then backed it up with a threat from Connors that if we didn't deal with Carlton, he would go...

Great post :thumbsu: And yes, your last sentence is the perplexing bit in the whole scenario. Was created for delisted players to get a second chance, not give a crap team the ability to screw a good club out of a quality player with the PSD threat.

Re: Boyle - Collingwood offer pick 14! Given Collingwood are holding out some hope of being able to trump Carlton for Judd, I doubt they would commit to giving away their highest pick too. Of course that didn't stop me posting the rumour in the Judd board, just to see who gets wound up about...

Re: Boyle - Collingwood offer pick 14! Given that the other Boyle thread has some saying 1st round, and others saying first hafl of the 2nd round is more realistic, for those that say 14 is too low....is that blind hatred of Collingwood or an accurate assessment of Boyle's worth? I'm actually...

I'm actually stunned he's on the market, would have thought Melbourne were about the last club that could give away tall defenders.

Which placed him around 37th in the league for goals kicked for the year. I like Boyle, he played a good role behind Buddy and Roughead. But just because he's tall, let's not confuse him for a spearhead KPP that is worth a 1st round pick. How would Boyle go, if defenders weren't double and...

Not a chance I wouldn't think. Melbourne are one of the teams in least position to be able to lose a key defender.

Removed after post above was taken down.

You know what, I'd take that. Long term I actually think Morton will be the better player, but fair is fair, Boyle has some runs on the board where Morton doesn't. One thing though........a couple of people have mentioned that Boyle played 3rd tall and often without a defender as they were...

:D God would strike me down if I responded with the obvious comment at this point.......

Opened this thread expecting to see Essendon and Kangaroos at the top of most lists. Now my feelings are hurt. :( Bah...I still like you Hawks!

Saw the thread title and thought christ, don't tell me we'd do a trade involving Guerra? Judd would certainly have to do some changing to fit in with the likes of Croad and Crawf.

Was actually my first thought too. Crawford's coat hangar was definately the best of the 3. Seriously not a good day for the Hawks at the MRP.

Re: hawthorn team 2008 If you guys are going to play Franklin on a HFF, just trade him to us will you???

That's terrible on so many levels i don't know where to start. Mitchell does strike me as a future captain, and the type of player who is a 'lifer'. Why would we give away Hunter as part of all this? Effectively the trade you're suggesting, suggests Judd = Mitchell Hunter = Williams...

Settle mate...I was joking that Vanders had retired now all as some part of a master plan to offer Judd the captaincy and recruit him. Got the utmost respect for Vanders.

Kind of sad really....that last bit is soooooo true. Can see us Eagles fans justifying it now. "well we used to think Judd was better, but it was..... 1. Only because he had Kerr and Cousins to take the best tagger 2. Only because he had Cox feeding him 3. Don't you guys realise Hodge...

If you guys get Judd.......remember Judd > Hodge, therefore Vandenburg replaced by Judd. In fact the timing of Vanders leaving now stinks. Opening up the job for Judd????? Bloody untrustworthy Hawks!!!!

You guys will just have to argue with St Kilda fans that Judd AND Hodge >>>> Ball. If you guys had a sense of humour you'd do a deal to get Ball to the club as well if Judd ends up there. Actually knowing some West Coast fans, they'll keep the Judd v Hodge debate alive, it'll just go...

Sure you'd be devastated. ;) But yes, if Judd wants to go, and the Eagles try and be too smart / greedy, they could end up with nothing but a sad face on PSD day.

Spot on....... I know you guys rate Thorp highly, and Franklin, but it'll be this kind of thing that leads to trades being dragged out. I don't want the Eagles to outsmart themselves by being greedy, but post such as the one below the one quoted here sum up the predicament. Don't trade...

I hope (honestly) that West Coast simply trade fairly, try and get acceptable return for losing a club champion and captain. My interest will be watching a couple of your supporters.....those of you that recognise me as a poster know I like the Hawks...but would love to dig up a few of the...

Top thread. You guys support a great club and have a bright few years coming up.....so sad that many fans missed last week's great win and then saw last night, based on which ground each game was played at. Hawks fans that want to sook about TD, should come live in bloody W.A. Good ol'...

C'mon you guys don't want him.......:o How could we argue over and over about who's better between him and Hodge if they play in the same bloody side?