Search results for query: *

I think he is a really good player But over the last 24 years there has probably never been a time where he would be considered in the top 20-25 players in the game at that time. Therefore I don't think you could argue for him being in the top 100 players of the last 42 years And tbf there...

The aspect that he wouldn't be in the top 250 players of the last 42 years let alone top 100

he got pretty ******* close with that call

#5 Petracca

Using 1997 as the cut off we may not have a lot of depth in the 23 and under age group but we do have some elite talent Weideman - is a solid AFL player who could break out but would want to do it soon Oliver - Absolute elite player of the comp Petty - serviceable depth KPD who is getting a run...

if only they awareded wins for under 23 teams on paper, hey?

so what is the point of this thread?

Other than the location, what makes it bad? Sent from my SM-G930F using Tapatalk

Buddy is just a different type of big man to what the game has seen. A big man who has the agility of a flanker. Imagine if he was a great mark like some of the other KPF. He would be unstoppable Sent from my SM-G925I using Tapatalk

I think Jon Brown was, just injuries killed him at times. Remember the year i think 2006 where he was leading the brownlow after 10 or 11 games and was unstoppable? Then in typical fashion got injured and missed the rest of the season Sent from my SM-P555 using Tapatalk

Reiwolt the best player. Hodge delivered the most for his club Sent from my SM-G925I using Tapatalk

Toumpas and Aish Sent from my SM-G925I using Tapatalk

1 Sydney 2 GWS 3 Bulldogs Sent from my SM-G925I using Tapatalk

Adelaide: Eddie Betts Brisbane: Dayne Beams Carlton: Murphy Collingwood: Daniel Wells Essendon: Watson Fremantle: Fyfe Geelong: Hawkins Gold Coast: Ablett GWS: Mumford Hawthorn: Hodge Melbourne: Big Mxy Gawn North Melbourne: Swallow Port Adelaide: Gray Richmond: Human Meatball St Kilda: Steven...

Really? If so,.that was almost have to be the oldest thread Sent from my SM-G925I using Tapatalk

And I think you will find that his consecutive games streak came to a halt for a love tap to Yze's stomach. Might have caught him otherwise Also I just realised you posted this in 2009, a chance for the longest quote, perhaps?

Selwood Viney Mumford Ziebull M Robinson Ward Parker Hodge Sent from my SM-G925I using Tapatalk

Gawn 99 or gtfo

If you are questioning Maxwell's leadership skills, you have no clue

No Hogan?

pretty meh list to be honost

1. Ablett 2. Fyfe 3. Rockliff 4. Kennedy 5. Pendelbury 6. Selwood 7. Ward 8.Jones 9. Martin 10. Beams

You dont think Ablett would be in the top 3 players in the league?

So basically Carlton players across every line?

Kelly Parker Schulz Garland Howlett Patful Lewis MacKenzie Ward Yarran

So at any stage are we going to see a list of the top 50?

Didn't say they weren't any good, more they are hyped up to be much better than they are presently

Ziebull Cooney Cotchin Rioli L Jetta Hurley Montagna Kruezer Rance Scully

Not to mention the fact he has actually been good when on the park

Some of the s**t people talk on here never stops amazing me. He has been an even better player since he went to GC and many thought that would be impossible