Search results for query: *

Remove this Banner Ad

  1. GarnerSmash

    Traded North Melbourne trade #8 to Melbourne for #26, #50 & 2020 1st Round Pick

    North are about 2 - 3 good drafts away from having the composition of a list capable of challenging. By that stage Goldstein, Higgins, Cunnington, Ziebell, Tarrant, Macmillan, Atley, all mainstays will be gone. We need quality depth in the middle, a refresh off half back and replacements in key...
  2. GarnerSmash

    Traded Jesse Hogan [traded with #65 to Fremantle for #6 and #23]

    They have the option to match, yes, but that does not mean North must then engage in a trade for Gaff. North can, and will, walk away if WCE match.
  3. GarnerSmash

    Recommitted Andrew Gaff [re-signed]

    North won't be trading for Gaff under any circumstances. That the club are willing to throw big coin at him does not mean that we are going after him at any cost. We are going after him with salary cap space and want him as an FA only. North have a plan and will stick to that plan over the next...
  4. GarnerSmash

    Recommitted Josh Kelly [re-signed]

    It is known.
  5. GarnerSmash

    Recommitted Josh Kelly [re-signed]

    It's GWS or North. Simples.
  6. GarnerSmash

    Recommitted Josh Kelly [re-signed]

    This is where knowledge of club becomes important. There was no way known that Scott was going to drop any senior players last year, unless they were injured. Since last year 5 mainstays of the 22 were moved on and as such more young players are getting games. Also, a numnber of young players...
  7. GarnerSmash

    Recommitted Josh Kelly [re-signed]

    Check my post and read again. First and second round draft picks 2012 - 2016. St. Kilda = 13 North = 14 Re first round picks. Since 2012 St. Kilda have had 6 with an average position of 11, North have had 5 with 14 being the average draft position. Re second round picks. Since 2012 St. Kilda...
  8. GarnerSmash

    Recommitted Josh Kelly [re-signed]

    Of those at North who are 23 or under and who have debuted the average games played is 16. This is due to pushing for a flag, so playing older players, and injury to guys like Garner, Wood and Anderson which has restricted their exposure. To be making any definitive calls on quality when there...
  9. GarnerSmash

    Recommitted Josh Kelly [re-signed]

    Players 18-21: Carlton: 15 North: 20 St. Kilda: 18 Players 22-26: Carlton: 18 North: 15 St. Kilda: 18 Players 27+: Carlton: 13 North: 9 St. Kilda: 9 As of the start of this year North had more untried first and second round draftees than any other club. If you go purely by age of list North...
  10. GarnerSmash

    Giant Clearance Sale - 2017

    Ok. If North take the spoo next year then your opinion means something. Right now you are a fanboi on an internet forum who thinks he knows better than a professional recruitment and list management team. Basket case. Wooden spoon. Your words.
  11. GarnerSmash

    Giant Clearance Sale - 2017

    Let me provide you with a little information which will assist you in not sounding like a high school drop out at a Trump rally. You are of the opinion that North are ‘a basket case’ because they are just starting a rebuild which will take a minimum of 3-5 years to get back to being a...
  12. GarnerSmash

    Recommitted Paul Ahern [re-signed]

    He has a linsfranc fracture. Wells had a linsfranc dislocation which took frikken ages to heal and is still managed. A club that picks him up would be tempted to give him half of next year to get back to full training.
  13. GarnerSmash

    Free Agency Daniel Wells [signed with Collingwood as UFA]

    Still managing the achilles week in, week out. Struggles to play when sore which shows how good he is considering he ain't been perfect this year.
  14. GarnerSmash

    Traded Jaeger O'Meara [traded to Hawthorn for pick 10 and GWS's 2017 2nd rd pick]

    I defiantly read this thread. Much against my better judgement
  15. GarnerSmash

    Recommitted Mason Wood [re-signed]

    Off the table. 4 year deal inked
  16. GarnerSmash

    Traded Jed Anderson [traded w/ picks 38 and 40 to NM for picks 15 and 54]

    Greg Denham says Anderson to North. Well, that's us out of the race.
  17. GarnerSmash

    Traded Jake Carlisle [traded w/ #23 and #44 for #5, #24 and Craig Bird]

    Pick 14-15 actually seems about right for an uncontracted player.
  18. GarnerSmash

    Traded Jake Carlisle [traded w/ #23 and #44 for #5, #24 and Craig Bird]

    Saints finishing top 6 next year?
  19. GarnerSmash

    Recommitted Brendon Goddard [re-signed until 2018]

    What are you wearing?
  20. GarnerSmash

    Traded Jed Anderson [traded w/ picks 38 and 40 to NM for picks 15 and 54]

    And I can understand that is a factor too.
  21. GarnerSmash

    Traded Jed Anderson [traded w/ picks 38 and 40 to NM for picks 15 and 54]

    He's done that once in his professional career, this year against Werribee. At this stage he is potentially an very good player at AFL level, but thats it. He got talent, but so do a s**t load of other young blokes. They don't all come on.
  22. GarnerSmash

    Traded Jed Anderson [traded w/ picks 38 and 40 to NM for picks 15 and 54]

    Nice player with strong potential but there is a bit of over rating going here. The way he is being spoken about you would swear that he should have been destroying it at VFL level this year. 2 x BoG from 15 games, averaging 19.2 disposals, 1.67 goals, 3.1 marks and 4.8 tackles and across his...
  23. GarnerSmash

    Traded Aaron Black [traded to Geelong for pick 92]

    Why cant he try do that at his current club? Hey, if he leaves good luck to him, but id rather he be a great player at North than anywhere else and if he does leave that we get value for investment. We wont get that this trade period so id rather he stay, play much better and if he still wants...
  24. GarnerSmash

    Traded Aaron Black [traded to Geelong for pick 92]

    How dare the club bring in a player they think can perform well at AFL level, and use another who showed excellent promise and gave Goldy a chop out. So unprofessional of them.
  25. GarnerSmash

    Traded Aaron Black [traded to Geelong for pick 92]

    Sure. Including lack of other key forward targets. Including playing in a poor team. Regardless he managed 24 goals in 16 games. As a primary target. Then when he was given AFL opportunities he stunk it up. I wanted him to succeed, but he didn't. You say he worked hard, fine. He got * all...
  26. GarnerSmash

    Traded Aaron Black [traded to Geelong for pick 92]

    I stated that he either didnt work hard enough or he wasnt good enough. You say he worked his arse off. So he's not good enough then.
  27. GarnerSmash

    Traded Aaron Black [traded to Geelong for pick 92]

    As in a new player to whom Blacks contract $$$ would go to. We are better off hanging on to Black in the hope that his value increases next year because his value now is as low as it has ever been. This draft is fairly shallow so a fourth rounder this year would be next to useless.
  28. GarnerSmash

    Traded Aaron Black [traded to Geelong for pick 92]

    Reality is that is probably all he is worth right now, but nah. Unless we have a better option ready to come in and play forward.
Back
Top