Has only played 45 games. Looks better as 2nd or 3rd tall, behind Mitchell Lewis and Brandon Ryan when he played.
Started to show something late in the year. I am hoping we give him another year to see how his development continues as he pushes past 50 games
Geee.....you must live in la la land if you truly believe that a player would make a decision based on the outcome of one game. Any suggestion that a player in his position is so 50/50 on where they will play next year that one game would sway their thinking is pure fantasy at best and blatant...
This thread is seriously embarrassing.
People on both sides should be ashamed.
Cant believe I wasted 15 mins reading a c@ck measuring contest.
P;n d;cks all round
I was a little concerned with the state of our list at the start of the year, in particular our midfield depth once Mitchell went down.
However, this year we have seen the emergence of a couple of kids, still early in their development, but very encouraging signs.
The loss of Mitchell has...
She traded up...........
Why........you jealous.
Thats understandable.........
As far a wives go, she's a bit of all-right......and she still has all of her own teeth.
As I said, my wife is a Pies supporter, and probably knows more about football than the both of us.
She is generally a pretty good judge of trade values from the 5 years i have known her, and she is the one telling me 3rd rounder (ish)
The guy has played 17 games in 3 years........doesnt inspire...
If you read what I said, then perhaps you wouldnt have wasted everyone's time with your rant.
I said he is of more value to Collingwood staying put.
IF he was to leave this year, then I doubt very much you get much more than a late 2nd rounder, to early 3rd.
Pick 18-20......dreamin
Lynch a clear upgrade on Cox, or perhaps you can play Lynch and Cox in the same forward line.
Cox wont have 15 blokes hanging off him because they will all be attracted to Lynch.
Moore can play in the backline, so Lynch solves 2 problems for them.
Their midfield and flankers are...
FWIW......I think he lands at Richmond.
You don’t announce contract extensions to 3 of your 4 highest players in less than a month just because you can.
If not coming to Hawthorn, then I’d prefer he doesn’t go to Collingwood.
The one thing they lack is a KPF......they can wait a little longer...
Saints have lost the plot if they even contemplate giving up a top 5 pick in this draft.......that is crazy.
Given Hanners is reportedly on 800k (2 years left on current contract), I wouldnt be paying anything more than pick 30.....and asking the Swans to pay at least 150k p.a. of his salary for...
I wouldn’t wish for anyone to go to GC to be honest.
And I doubt RS will be going there either.
He will stay at Hawthorn next year, but if he did go then somewhere like the Dogs perhaps.....as a FA, or a pick in the 60-70 range if Dogs need to protect any FA compo
I have shared my analysis a few pages ago, so wont go through it again.
The end game is that Port want your first rounder......after that it is rather semantic.
If you value him even late teens, then according to the draft points table, you should expect nothing more than about pick 45 back...
Fair......I would suggest more mid teens, but late teens is not far off the mark
Definitely not worth 2 (late) first rounders...........as some have perhaps suggested.......that is just fanciful.
Similarly, worth more than a 2nd round pick.
I have no doubt your first is part of the...
Snake......
I havent read back through the whole thread to see what you might have previously suggested, but interested to hear what you think Polec is worth a the trade table, nothwithstanding DFA etc.
I think he would be a very good acquisition for North, and if you are going to pay a bloke...
No doubt Port will be looking to upgrade their picks to get hold of Rankine or Lukosous. Both clubs will be well placed to land one of the 2.....the question is which one does each club want more.
If it’s me, I take Rankine ahead of Lucosous.....both clubs have some decent talk forwards, so...
Don’t worry.....Crows supporters just don’t want Port getting another 1st round pick and upsetting their plans to land Lukosous and Rankine.
Their agendas are almost embarrassing.
They cant help themselves
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.