Search results for query: *

Youd hope given his age his brain recovers fully. Certainly he was at the point where nearly anything would concuss him so there wasnt a safe continue option.

When we beat Swans and Port in finals and made the Prelim ? 2004 is the one we are said to have tanked.

Brave or reckless ? So many of his concussions were easily avoidable. His choices may well have halved his career.

He would be brilliant in our team if you reckon he's overrated.

Chief routinely says backmen are nothing but failed forwards.

Anyone replacing Jeans waa going to fall short. Despite how much success Joyce had.

Motlop was the expert at this. Even got another club to believe him.

Im sure he hasnt seen a Carlton flag. Certainly not one won without brown paper bags.

Im sure noone has ever said that without any context. Also we may be tanking but could still have our first pick being pick 6 or 7.

Matthews doesnt even make the bench? Hawks chose Mew over Knights for their TotC and Im inclined to go with that as well.

"Most" though? Who rates him in the top 10 midfielders in the comp? Noting that when he is in the middle we massively win the centre clearances.

He is average to good. 1.5 goals and 15 possessions a game is pretty good for a small forward. Who hyped him other than maybe the Crows marketing team? I'd say his output at the Crows is about as good or maybe a bit better than at GCS.

Legend status is for a particular thing not an overall thing? I know there were reasons why people have been excluded and it was to do with needing to be a legend at your best thing, not the sum of all parts. Matthews would get it for both given he coached 4 flags with a 3-peat and is the GOAT...

Those 40m chips forward the stat padders do I guess.... As for him going forward, he may get 12 touches given how bad the Roos are. Surely he goes where needed.

Its not 4 times as fast as when we had one umpire or 2 times as fast as when we had 2. When we had 3 they had clear zones they were responsible for but now we have 4 and Im sure half the time they dont know whether to blow their whistle or not.

They did the Premiership video at the cinema instead of Fox ?!?!

His first year was incredible given how regularly they got flogged. O'Meara's first 2 years for similar reasons.

Newcombe laid 14 tackles in his very first game. Not sure how many he broke through given I dont think that is a stat.

Wallace, Tuck, Matthews

Money is more important than anything else now. They literally dont care what happens with the game so long as the short term money comes in. Would the game be worse if more focus was put on quality and not revenue? To start, ban all gambling money, gambling ads, and anything else to do with...

Next time probably dont call the umpire a campaigner.

WCE have 100,000 members and their stadium holds 50,000 members each game. Maybe the best way to see football is to get a membership for a different team. Also, I live in Sydney and no matter the game I go to (Swans or Giants) there is always at least one guy wearing a Collingwood jumper. Some...

August for Carlton ?

The drafting rule with top picks is always take the best available player no matter the position. But when you have a dozen picks in 2 years surely you use some on KPP.

7 years for the wrong McKay - who is only good on average or worse forwards.

The way you lot carry on, and the way the media fawned over Daicos - easily.

Yeah, imagine that. A team near the top of the ladder getting more votes than a team at the bottom of the ladder. I wonder if it was the first time that ever happened. And a player in that team being the focus of the media every-single-week, vs a player getting almost zero focus because...

HBF is a pretty easy school. Particularly in a team seeing 60 or 80 I50 every match. But he is well ahead of Daicos at the same stage.

Lockett didnt win much either. Nor did GAS. Both got suspended a lot as well. I do like this method of rating an individual.

So are we tanking? With 4 other teams being basically terrible it will be hars to finish dead last and bid on the guy going to Brisbane anyway.