Search results for query: *

Remove this Banner Ad

  1. HalloweenJack

    Opinion North Melbourne Priority Picks Part 2 - 2023/2024

    We don't want them.
  2. HalloweenJack

    Scott Pendlebury - Standing in the game?

    Pendlebury is a great player but not in the discussion for GOAT. That doesn't matter and neither does it lower his standing in the game. He could have easily won a second Norm Smith medal because his last quarter won Collingwood the GF. He was magnificent. For me he is in the top echelon of...
  3. HalloweenJack

    Roast The Brownlow has no credibility left

    Verdun Howell won the Brownlow, tying with Bob Skilton, in 1959 and he was the Saint Kilda fullback.
  4. HalloweenJack

    Roast The Brownlow has no credibility left

    In round 10 of 1993, Greg Williams (Carlton v Melbourne) had 44 disposals and did not receive any votes. Wanganeen won the medal with 18 votes and Williams was joint second with 17 votes. Williams should be a 3 time winner.
  5. HalloweenJack

    Best individual finals performance in AFL/VFL history

    You are correct and IMO Kouta was BOG in the 1995 GF.
  6. HalloweenJack

    Best Back 6 All Time

    I would replace Swan McKay with our first Brownlow medallist Bert Deacon.
  7. HalloweenJack

    Who is the best team in the history of the game to not win a grand final??

    It has to be Collingwood in 1970. Finished on top 2 games clear of Carlton. Beat Carlton 3 times during the year including the 2nd Semi Final, and in Round 19 (I think) by nearly 80 points, prior to the Grand Final and were leading that game by 44 points at half time.
  8. HalloweenJack

    Fremantle Under Longmuir

    They won't sack him. Nearly every year a team will come from the clouds and jump into the 8 and sometimes the top 4. Freo are primed to do just that as long as they don't get decimated with injuries.
  9. HalloweenJack

    Why do teams play teams twice before playing other teams?

    Just another Gil legacy, which I hope goes the way of the Dodo, but I doubt it because the AFL and its executives seem to only care about the bottom line.
  10. HalloweenJack

    Who feels sorry for St Kilda - the only drought remaining!

    You can add Essendon to that list because the 21st century began on 1 January 2001.
  11. HalloweenJack

    Play Nice Goal Umpire costs Adelaide a shot at finals, how do you stop it from happening again?

    I noticed that and now after viewing the additional footage the best explanation is that the Swans players knew it was a goal. Footy is a hard game.
  12. HalloweenJack

    Top 10 Key Position Forwards

    Ted Tyson played from 1930 to 1945. Playing in the VFL at that time was not a big deal. Haydyn Bunton left the VFL after winning 3 Brownlow's to play in WA where he won 3 Sandover's (the equivalent fairest and best award). So the VFL was not the be all and end all competition. Learn your history.
  13. HalloweenJack

    Welcome to East Germany Carlton and Collingwood - who finishes higher in 2023? Collingwood Ofcourse

    I totally agree because that is what footy is all about. It's disappointing to make finals and fall at the final hurdle but the journey can be exhilarating and memorable.
  14. HalloweenJack

    Best Individual season you've seen from a player

    Yep Kouta in 2000. It's a disgrace that he didn't win the Brownlow. I thought he was easily B.O.G in 10 games.
  15. HalloweenJack

    Player Watch JHF - Jason Horne-Francis

    I find the constant booing of this young man untenable. It really demonstrates what an unsavory lot of so called footy fans now attend matches. I hated the Goodes booing and I hate this.
  16. HalloweenJack

    Power and Privilege: Intersectionality in Australian Rules Football

    Thanks for this. I thought when I read the thread that it was codswallop and now I know for sure.
  17. HalloweenJack

    The Luke Jackson trade.

    Early days to make this call. Freo probably paid overs but it was Jackson going into the centre square that turned the 2021 Grand Final. He should be the number 1 ruck.
  18. HalloweenJack

    Top 10 Key Position Forwards

    Ted Tyson playing for West Perth kicked 1197 goals in 228 games at an average of 5.25 per game. He is never mentioned in these discussions.
  19. HalloweenJack

    Live Event Footy Club Survivor: Dunno about "Outwit", but can your club outlast? (Adelaide WINS)

    Adelaide -1 Blues +1 Adelaide 80 Brisbane 75 Carlton 66 Fremantle 34 Geelong 77 GCS 46
  20. HalloweenJack

    Live Event Footy Club Survivor: Dunno about "Outwit", but can your club outlast? (Adelaide WINS)

    Carlton +1 Crows -1 Adelaide 75 Brissy 63 Carlton 95 Freo 34 Cats 72 GC 43
  21. HalloweenJack

    Live Event Footy Club Survivor: Dunno about "Outwit", but can your club outlast? (Adelaide WINS)

    Hawthorn -1 Carlton +1 Adelaide 67 Brisbane 34 Carlton 95 Fremantle 34 Geelong 36 Gold Coast 32 Hawthorn 74
  22. HalloweenJack

    Live Event Footy Club Survivor: Dunno about "Outwit", but can your club outlast? (Adelaide WINS)

    Carlton +1 Hawks -1 Adelaide 74 Brisbane 34 Carlton 78 Fremantle 32 Geelong 35 GCS 34 GWS 7 Hawthorn 80
  23. HalloweenJack

    Selecting Fischer McAsey before Sam De Koning in the 2019 draft

    Spot on Bunk. Maybe the drafting age needs to be raised to 20.
  24. HalloweenJack

    Welcome to East Germany Carlton and Collingwood - who finishes higher in 2023? Collingwood Ofcourse

    I agree with almost everything that you wrote other than it being special if the Blues make the finals. It won't be special if we don't win the flag.
  25. HalloweenJack

    Welcome to East Germany Carlton and Collingwood - who finishes higher in 2023? Collingwood Ofcourse

    No one really knows except for Collingwood and JDG and his management. However, if you listen to the scuttlebutt, the behavioural clauses were just general in nature with no guidance as to what would constitute when and how these could be exercised. So a minor indiscretion may result in a...
  26. HalloweenJack

    Essendon gifted 3 Friday Night's in a row

    Agreed. Not that long ago my team were awful and looked like they weren't trying. At least the Bombers look like they care. Maybe they will try a different game plan now that Harry Jones is back. He looked awesome in the first half last week.
  27. HalloweenJack

    Who's the best Indigenous player ever?

    It is one of the greatest goals, no doubt. The indigenous players all seem to have that x factor and when they turn it on it's magical. A few posters have mentioned T.I. (Stephen Michael) and how great he was. It is a pity he never had the desire to play VFL because he would have shown the...
Back
Top