Search results for query: *

No, we cannot win a flag under Hinkley

Its really close imo. West Coast probably had the most complete midfield and they batted really deep. Their second string midfield was pretty good. But their peak was also fairly short lived compared to Geelong and Brisbanes. Geelongs was just a total powerhouse. Many outstanding...

You cant really base much off raw disposal numbers. The game changed dramatically from 01-04 to 07-11 in terms of disposal rates. But, Johnson and Chapman should be included as they were part of the mid rotation, particularly the back end of their dominant era

This 'dump kicking' has literally been our forward movement since 2018

Rozee will end up the best of the three.

I'm mainly interested to see how Thilthorpe and Fogarty go once Walker retires. Fogarty is just ok, Thilthorpe has underwhelmed. Can either/both become the 50-60 goal a year target once Walker retires?

Not sure their rebuild is botched, its just still going. This year seems more a coaching/gamestyle issue than a talent issue.

Port

Oh look, another thread where Victorians underrate Tredrea. Shock horror

People get seduced by Brown winning 3 flags.

Bowen Lockwood was always meant to be a gun 1-2 punch with Tredders in Ports forward line. Played 30 games in his first 2 years and looked good. Then ****ed his back up bad in training and not only did his career peter out, so did his quality of life.

Tristen Walker worse than Kinnear imo

He’s both. Hes one of the best pollers of this era for a reason. Its not like he came from the clouds like a Woewodin.

Theres been far more controversial winners than Neale. Ball magnet in a team that finished 2nd, traditionally one of the best voters of the current era. He was always a big chance due to how many games Brisbane won, compared to Daicos who missed a stack of games and Bont who played in a...

92-01ish was the best era from a spectators viewpoint i reckon.

He's having the best start to his career since Judd and i'm old enough to remember there being a Chris Judd forum on here when he broke out. Outside of injury, he'll end up being the V/AFL record holder for disposals, brownlow votes and brownlow medals by the time he hangs it up.

The only reason Bickley is in is because he captained those sides. If he wasnt captain, his name wouldnt have even been brought up. Good player, but he’d barely even make the best Crows team in their history imo

You're missing the fact that it's not the AFL Hall of Fame.

The last wuarter was farcical. One of the worst quarters of footy i can remember watching

Stuey Dew kicked 3 goals all from outside 50 off one step in the space of 45 seconds in the 2001 Ansett Cup GF. Even though the match meant nothing, that was ridiculous.

There was an Adelaide v North Melbourne game about 20 years ago where the score was 0.10 to 1.8 or something similar at half time. That was a hideous game, even though it was a close finish. Worst game i've been to, Port v Richmond 99 at Footy Park. The whole match was played in pouring rain...

Yep, he would be coach of the year. But weve been here before. Thats why Port fans are waiting what happens in the finals

Hes had a vfl/afl record amount of time. Its not like hes 3 years in.

Have they shown the infringement anywhere yet? There's plenty of situations every game where 2-3-4 players come off the ground at the same time. If they had 2 left and 3 players come off at once for example, how does the steward police that by waving a flag?

Thats a shame. I thought it looked great

The young family of 4 who think its a great idea to bring their two young boys to the football once a year. Can be seen arguing who gets to play with their Switch first. One ends up watching Peppa Pig on their mums phone with the volume somehow louder than the stadium speakers Kids kick the...

Seems more of a Freo issue than a Jackson issue. Statistically he's no different than he was last year. Freo as a whole have really regressed.

If someones going to leave, surely you'd prefer the situation that happened where he was contracted and you controlled what you got, as opposed to just getting pick 11ish this year for him?

Has anyone legitimately suggested they have?

And yet mid 2012, Geelong flew Scott, Wells, Selwood, Bartel and Enright over to SA to have a meeting with Travis Boak and his family to convince him to come back home to Geelong. Mid season. Quite openly. At the time they were praised for how ruthless their club and their list management was...