Search results for query: *

One of the guys commentating sounds exactly the same as Cameron Ling.

I'm not sure a side like Sydney, who base their gameplan around a strong defense, would be wanting to give up a defender for a KPF.

I'm not too sure how much we could offer him, but if Wellingham and Dawes both go, that would free up around 450-500k. Dane Swan onto veterans list which adds another 100k we can use. Looks like we will delist Cameron Wood, who would be on around 200k. If all goes to plan, we could have around...

Dawes will be traded if Tippett says he wants to come to Collingwood. Melbourne showing interest apparently, I'm sure we could get their first rounder for him...

I don't think he is overrated, but most people probably rate him on potential more than anything. He has a big tank and if was played predominantly through the midfield, rather than forward, I think he would be rated a lot higher.

Hard to say. Showed a lot of potential in 2010 and is obviously very classy in big games, but he went backwards in 2011, IMO.

Re: Tarrant to Pies with Pick 44 for Pick 43 and 44 edit: thanks alfy

No, not for Collingwood. We don't need a midfielder at this stage. Would much rather draft a young ruckmen.

:rolleyes: Read my post before trying to respond. Pykie, his disposal was great in his first season, but as UpTheGuts said, his disposal this year wasn't great, perhaps due to being noticed more than he was in his first year. I'm not saying he won't be a good player, but I wouldn't use my...

I'm not saying he has peaked, that isn't what plateaued means. Just saying that unless he gets a better fitness base, he will only be an average midfielder.

Meh, still doesn't look worth a first rounder. Maybe if he got fitter. Maybe.

Wouldn't give up a first round pick for him. Seems to have plateaued.

Bailey has played him in different roles this season. I wouldn't take him, but Melbourne would be stupid to get rid of him.