Search results for query: *

source

unless Melbourne give up something to GC (or some form of communication between the clubs is discovered) then it's impossible to say there was cooperation in return for GC not bidding on Viney

It's hardly draft tampering. It's GWS deciding JV is not worth pick 1 and GC deciding that MD#1 is more valuable to the club than JV at pick 2.

What can Dawes do that James Sellar can't?

My source (who I won't reveal because i'm ethical and s**t, but don't worry he's entirely trust worthy and never gives me bad info) has told me that a certain player wants out of his club and that there are possibly 3 or 4 clubs interested in him. but that's all the information I can tell you...

What is the point of this thread

I just wish they all played for the same team

I would be surprised if GWS did not pick him up in that scenario

Re: Is a mid teens pick for Tom Scully fair compo ? why. They can't keep the kids. if they demand to much they won't get anything at all

Re: More clarity on GWS U17yr old trades - no mini-draft Blame the afl. They're the ones who created this cluster**** by not putting in place adequate compensation measures

Not sure What the lions faithful think but for me it's Redden > Rockliff > Rich

We picked Martin based off one game when he was filling in for a mate at old hailibury(?). he didn't even play footy at the time.

The right sort of players but I think age will be a factor as well. I doubt GWS will want to go for anyone older than 26 at the start of next season. not only do they need immediate success they need to be able too sustain that success until their kids have fully matured and are ready to go it...

Viney is going to the Dees under the Father Son rule http://www.melbournefc.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/7415/newsid/105532/default.aspx yay

he only has to play 1 game to win a premiership. he has to play 4 full seasons + finals to reach 100 games

Re: Jesse White goes to the Dees oh please let this be true

Pia Miller

holy crap I can't believe I have to post this picture again. I swear it was only 2 days ago I last posted it. BF is usually smarter than that

but then we loose Pia as well

you lose draft picks for breaching the salary cap

not including any of your forwards. Goddard, Montagna, Dal Santo, Hayes, Gram, Gwilt, Peake, Ray and Gardiner how many more attacking players does Ross Lyon need?

what you're saying is that because Swallow won a B&F he is better than Higgins what i'm saying is that club B&F's measure how important a player is to the club they belong to and isn't useful for comparing the abilities of players from different clubs, proven by the fact that even though Jones...

so consistency isn't more valuable than a single good season, is that what you're trying to say here

but he has better b&f results, isn't that what you were basing your argument on? Jones > Higgins and because consistency over a period of time is far more valuable than a single stand out season. Jones > Vince & Swallow > Higgins :thumbsu:

Jones has a 2nd and 5th in B&F's but I don't see you complaining that he isn't above Higgins

Judd averaging 15 possession, 3 tackles and a goal a game. that might not be considered huge, but it makes him a very important part of the team from day 1 Hodge had a lot of OP problems early on iirc so wouldn't say he had much of an impact It was described as(and has proven to be) a...

of course they're not going to be in AA contention or win a B&F in their first season. but that doesn't mean they're going to have horrid first years they can comfortably fit into an AFL side, put in a season of solid games and do what the team asks of them. there have been plenty of top draft...

never thought i'd see that word after I finished year 12

also I don't see what interchanges have to do with anything really Melbourne were one of the highest interchanging teams in the first half of the season and we still weren't winning

I'm sure you were picketing for Essendon to do the same at the end of 08 then