Search results for query: *

... Huh?

Settle down mate, all i am saying is i dont think Wellingham is worth a first round pick, he is a good player, my main point is that i dont believe the Pies would really want a pick anyway, wouldnt a player be a better option? As i said i dont know anything about Stevens but he sounds well rated.

This seems really strange to me, no offense to Sharrod (and yes i realise he doesnt determine his value) but he isn't worth a 1st round pick, in any event would Collingwood want a first rounder for him? Given they are right in the thick of the hunt for a flag wouldn't they prefer a player (read...

I'll bite on this, given the Saints position at the moment the only blokes i wouldn't want to go would be Lenny and Milney and that is purely sentimental, if they wanted to leave for a chance at a flag i would be really pissed off at the club if they made it difficult. The deal would have to be...

This is true, I just hope for your sake the soft tissues dont reoccur (as they can have a habit of doing)

I think it will. Whilst i don't want to lose BJ, this is a good result for the player and the club to me. I dont know Brendon or what his mindset would be, but, he probably wont get another shot at a flag with us, he also probably wont get a contract that reflects his worth with us, if he can go...

Prefer me to say your wrong? FWIW i dont think you are wrong, being that it's your opinion and all, i do think you would be in the minority if you think Sam Reid is overrated based on what he has shown and his potential, to each their own.

Settle down champ, my opinion differs to yours, thats all.

Sam Reid? If youre talking Sam Reid and you think he is massively overrated but think Watts could fit in there thats a very interesting take...

Primus the new Billy Beane?

Don't think depth is a problem, it's quality, once you lose Patfull and Merrett the other guys aren't that good, Dawson doesn't really fix tht problem I would have to disagree, Dawson isn't bad, but his strength was in playing in an insanely structured defence, 95% of the time in a one on one...

Who are you talking about? If its Dawson GC just got Warnock so they wouldnt want another mature tall defender, Melbourne has Frawley and just got rid of Warnock so they clearly have the depth not to need him either, Richmond could be a possibility esp with the retirement of Thursfield.

I completely agree he should but he doesn't owe the club any more service.

I hope the deal gets done and as has been said couldn't see him moving after such a stellar carrer with the lions, but anyone suggested he owes the club etc etc is being an idiot, helping you win three flags and everything else he has given to the club is enough?

A legitimate question from someone who knows very very little about Gunston, he is a key forward yes? Why on earth would he want to go to Hawthorn, and why would they want him? If he was at Adelaide behind Walker and Tippett i understand wanting to leave but why Hawthorn where he would be behind...

O'Meara and 31 would be an unbelievable deal for us, as would a top 10 pick plus a solid player. They are similar value deals (O'Meara would be number 1 this year anyway) we wont get either, but he's not going anywhere anyway.

This wins the interwebs... It would be only slightly more hilarious if Brock and his mates get up and sing our most favourite time honored theme song, walking with.... in the land of.... wait what the hell is their song?

Wasn't fantastic for the ants today, but he does show something, very surprised if he went, would surely get a gig next year...

Would love to have him, but i think he is worth more to you than others would see in him, If it were up to me, late 1st rounder early second rounder, clubs wouldn't give that, and hawthorn (rightly) wouldn't accept anything short of that.

They also both have that crazy hunched over kicking on the run style

^^ this, coupled with the fact that Roo shared his time between CHF and CHB in his first few years (probably missed some games for photo shoots too) i did it before someone else did...

What he actually said was we aren't going to be entering discussions with any of the grand final team members right now, which he said last week, before the replay. Obviously reading between the lines he meant we will wait till the GF is done and dusted, then go after them.

Similar to the Joel Bowden rushed behind? Not against the rules but clearly against the spirit of said rule.

You might be forgetting that Ball nominated Collingwood in trade week and for whatever reason a deal couldn't be done (probably both teams faults we will never know for sure). If you want your statement to be correct we would have lost Ball & 16 for Lovett & 30 which, when considering our...

cause the tiges wants tuck gone, do him a favour by guaranteeing him a club?

I heard Adam Hartlett to Port, makes sense his brother is there and he is the same type of player as Brock McLean, not sure if Port have to give anything away to get him as he hasn't been used much at Carlton.

Between Cousins and Rance i think richmond have the biceps award well and truly covered!!!

Played at fullback in the carnival a bit, so i think were looking to develop him as a back, not sure st.nick will ever be a genuine full forward so i dont think we need another lead up player, lynch definately wont play full forward so other than kozi (who cant play structured football and needs...

Would agree, think he is a great player, how come he hasn't been getting any game time? Came back from that infection/pendicitis thing, got suspended then couldn't get back depsite you finishing 13th 0r 12th??