Search results for query: *

That is a tough poll. I went with Junior as most of my live memories of Senior were of him getting beaten by Silvagni.

Good comparison. I'd say Aker was the better of the two, especially in finals. I think the original poster may have thought Swan was/is way better? Why else put the joke selection at the bottom?

I voted yes, and the same goes for you Essendon supporters, Essendon have well and trully over taken us. Oh this is going to be sweet...

Two? The following are unavaliable, our number one ruckman, our best midfielder, our only genuine tagger and third best midfielder, our best "quarter back" backman and another starting backman, and our full forward. Thats a genuine 6 not including injured 2nd tier players. Injuries are not...

Everybody will pick their own, as it looks like they have. I don't know how they did it but in about 1994 (when bugger all people had a mobile phone) the age did a poll on who had the best uniform. At the end it was declared Carlton did with over 25% of the vote, the next best was 9%. Fashions...

I agree with this to date. There are chump years when only one or two teams are flying or years when a long shot accidently makes the GF, (1999, 2000 & 2006 come to mind). I think oppositely to the OP and judging by the response so do most people. This year's premiership looks like it will...

Where is Hawthorn of the eighties? No team had more annoyed talk back on the radio in history. Strong defence can win flags so I suppose thats just a byproduct of some great teams.

On ballers for mine... 1 Pendleby 2 Ablett 3 Murphy 4 Selwood (cheats for frees but is a gun) 5 Judd 6 Watson 7 Goodes 8 Swan 9 Bartel 10 Mitchel 11 Thompson 12 Godard 13 Kerr

Robinson is so far ahead of Grigg its silly to compare.

Hayes, miles ahead.

Dangerfield has done more damage against us than Sidebottom. He is a very good player in an average side. Sidebottom is just a good player in a very good side.

better player management. Judd is a better player than Bartel.

Hird Voss Buckley Ratten Worsfold McKenna

I think some of the younger supporters might be mixing up Phillip Matera with Peter Matera. My order Matera McLoud Wanganeen (diver)

Easily? You obviously haven't seen Simmo lately. BTW Carlton didn't bother tagging Stanton in the Elimination final last year. We basically played our own game and let you guys tag us. You're right, he doesn't always get tagged.

I'll gladly throw one in for Walks here, he is a VERY accurate kick for goal.

Its running at 60/40 Westcoast made a move for Garlett before last season when he only had one year behind him. He knocked back the extra money and stuck by the team that gave him an opportunity as a rookie. It will be interesting to see what Varcoe does if he is offered the same. For...

Turns out you have to vote in order to see the results even if you are the op.

I'm Carlton so I won't vote.

Ross Glendening vs Hodge would be a tough one. Only 40+year olds could have a say on that one. I would just take Hodge, he is super smart.

What I should have done is asked which one of these players won more games off their own back? I think Kernahan would win if that was the case, I reckon he single handedly won about 20% of our games. Carey would smash them both, more like 50%. No Carey no North. Getting back to the poll it...

When I set up this poll a few days ago the idea was to compare leaders or "captains". The two players are very highly regarded and considered all time greats by their clubs but i was interested in what the other fans thought of the two. I wouldn't compare their abilities, they play two...

I would put my football knowledge against yours anyday. I have been to over 500 games and I don't barrack for either of those teams so I'm not biased like you. Franklin is the best of that lot, the guy is a freak who can turn a game in a couple of minutes. Pendlebry is probably the best...

A poll for the oldies. Two legendary leaders and brilliant players, if you could have a young one of your choice who would it be?

1 Franklin 2 Pendlebry 3 Thomas 4 Roughead I would go with the pies duo, more value. Roughead is another Wowoden.

Craig Bradley was the biggest reciever in history, would you prefer Cotchin over him?

No NAB cup games on tv, what the? A friend of mine who is mates with someone high up at foxtel reckons foxtel want to take over all of the footy as early as the next tv rights deal. This worries me, what about the battlers? The ones who keep this game alive. Makes me wonder how many dinkum...

I didn't get to vote but I would have thrown another one on for Gibbs.... by the length of the Flemington straight. Gibbs was a boy who grew into a man during the 2011 season. Towards the end of this year Gibbs officially became an AFL gun. Averaging 30+ high quality possessions per game and...

I am also a Carlton fan but i agree more with you. Collingwood do have the best skilled team across the ground. Your backline is slightly better than ours and your forward line currently operates more efficiantly. But claiming your midfield is better is pushing it. With minimal injuries we will...

I am biased towards my own team but I honestly think Carlton is the pick of those three. We haven't managed to put our best 22 on the park for many years, but the day we do we should go pretty well. We have failed in recent times because of our weaker players being forced into the big games...