[YOUTUBE]zbnJo88kuP8[/YOUTUBE]
IN: Butler
Out: Smith
I don't think Embers will be sub but I can't really decide who will replace him.
IN: Butler
Out: Smith
I don't think Embers will be sub but I can't really decide who will replace him.
Rnd 2 Changes vs Melbourne
- Thread starter DrTomSwift
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Aug 22, 2009
- 24,445
- 28,072
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Butler for Smith. Or McGinnity would be ok.
Embley into the 21, Hams or Masten as sub.
Embley into the 21, Hams or Masten as sub.
Bulter for Smith for mine too. I don't think he was as horrendous as people seem to suggest but he was below par, and also I just think Butler is better.
Would be good for McGinners to find a way in, but we seem full at the moment.
Hill and Hams both did well, they're definitely in next week.
Would be good for McGinners to find a way in, but we seem full at the moment.
Hill and Hams both did well, they're definitely in next week.
Ian Dargie
Premiership Player
- Jun 14, 2011
- 4,838
- 1,511
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Banned
- #6
Imagine there would be a case for Butler coming in for Smith.
McGinnity probably a chance as well, although our mids did enough to hold their spots. Kerr was quiet but he won't be dropped.
McGinnity probably a chance as well, although our mids did enough to hold their spots. Kerr was quiet but he won't be dropped.
kaiserchief13
Hall of Famer
- Jul 12, 2011
- 33,896
- 24,708
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Eagles, Lakers, Bayern, Trojans
Definitely Butler for Smith. Don't know other than. Masten definitely not the sub though.
- Oct 25, 2007
- 2,722
- 67
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Thunder
Agree. Someone has to make way for Butler, and Smith would be the obvious choice.
Forward Press
Hall of Famer
Huh? Hams was fairly quiet.
I think he should get the vest next week and like many here, just the one change with Smith out for Butler.
I think he should get the vest next week and like many here, just the one change with Smith out for Butler.
Public Enemy No1
Premiership Player
- Banned
- #11
The MC obviously picked Smith over Butler for a reason. He was ok.Got to give him a few games I think.
Embley wont be sub again
Embley wont be sub again
For me Butler in for Smith. Looked like Smith improved as the game went on but would rather Butler in defence. Not sure about the sub but safe to say it won't be Embley again.
I'm thinking Kerr out for Butler or McGinnity.
We probably wont need Kerr in our next 2 games and I'm not certain he's 100%.
We probably wont need Kerr in our next 2 games and I'm not certain he's 100%.
- Sep 8, 2011
- 10,990
- 10,957
- AFL Club
- West Coast
No Change
Hams had 2 goals and 12 touches, every bit as good as Hill. Leave them both in.
I don't think we should make any changes. Maybe start Embley and use Kerr as the sub. Smith was poor but he'll get better. If they drop Smith, it should be for Brennan or McGinnity.
Smith should stay for this round at home against the Dees.
I wanna see Mcginnity in there somewhere. Take over where Scooter left off so Scooter can grow and grow.
I wanna see Mcginnity in there somewhere. Take over where Scooter left off so Scooter can grow and grow.
- Apr 2, 2000
- 74,801
- 25,011
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Liverpool, Chicago Bulls.
Why Hams out? He kicked two goals which is about what you want from a small forward. Did enough to keep his place in the side.
As everyone else has said, Butler should come in for Smith. Smith wasnt great and Butler is simply a better footballer.
Embley shouldnt be the sub either. Not sure who should get the vest though.
As everyone else has said, Butler should come in for Smith. Smith wasnt great and Butler is simply a better footballer.
Embley shouldnt be the sub either. Not sure who should get the vest though.
Butler was ordinary for Perth in the WAFL, so doubt he will get a game, though you never know we could do a Ross Lyon.
And pick a horribly out of form Nick Suban, for a afl game.
I dont think John rewards poor WAFL form though.
Ash Smiths best games of footy have been against Melbourne, he usually plays on Brad Green and rips him a new one.
And pick a horribly out of form Nick Suban, for a afl game.
I dont think John rewards poor WAFL form though.
Ash Smiths best games of footy have been against Melbourne, he usually plays on Brad Green and rips him a new one.
In: Butler
Out: Smith
Butler Glass Schofield
Hurn Mckenzie Waters
Rosa Priddis Embley
Masten Lynch Darling
Hill Kennedy Hams
Ruck: Natanui S.Selwood Shuey
Int: Cox A.Selwood Gaff Sub: Kerr
It might not be a bad idea to start Kerr as a sub regularly during the year to help break the hard tags and to nurse his body through the season.
Out: Smith
Butler Glass Schofield
Hurn Mckenzie Waters
Rosa Priddis Embley
Masten Lynch Darling
Hill Kennedy Hams
Ruck: Natanui S.Selwood Shuey
Int: Cox A.Selwood Gaff Sub: Kerr
It might not be a bad idea to start Kerr as a sub regularly during the year to help break the hard tags and to nurse his body through the season.
Hams was very efficient today , doesn't play well at Subi for some reason . Hill / Hams combo could work well being different type players which compliment each other !
Stevenson best for Claremont , so maybe Stevenson for Smith however probably no changes .
Stevenson best for Claremont , so maybe Stevenson for Smith however probably no changes .
I do believe Butler was out this week due to matchups against the bulldogs. Bulldogs generally have a small quick forward line. Which is why they went for Smith.
For me
No changes.
For me
No changes.
