TradeDraft
Premium Platinum
In: Jolly D Thomas Didak
Out: Wood Buckley Ugle
Out: Wood Buckley Ugle
Preview AFL Rd 7 - Collingwood v Brisbane - Changes and Prematch Discussion
- Thread starter TradeDraft
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Yidaki
AFL Behavioural Awareness Officer
- Jul 24, 2010
- 27,886
- 29,119
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Re: Changes vs Lions RD 7
Out: Sinclair, Wood, Obrien
Same ins as you dave.
Out: Sinclair, Wood, Obrien
Same ins as you dave.
Re: Changes vs Lions RD 7
OUT: Wood, Ugle, Johnson (inj), Fasolo (inj)
IN: Jolly, Thomas, Didak, Blair
edit: forgot about Blair
OUT: Wood, Ugle, Johnson (inj), Fasolo (inj)
IN: Jolly, Thomas, Didak, Blair
edit: forgot about Blair
Heir_Apparent
Team Captain
Re: Changes vs Lions RD 7
I can tell you now TradeDraft that you are already wrong.
Buckley will not be getting dropped lol, 7 clangers is a lot but 30 touches and 7 inside 50's more than makes up for it, he played a freaking great game apart from a couple of mistakes. Also, Johnson is not on your Outs.
if I was coach I would do this:
IN: Thomas, Didak (if fit)
OUT: Johnson, Ugle
Wood can play again, Jolly doesn't need to travel the week before the Cats.
If Thomas isn't fit then Young will come in, Didak will most likely be sub, if not then Sinclair, they will swap in the 3rd quarter.
I can tell you now TradeDraft that you are already wrong.
Buckley will not be getting dropped lol, 7 clangers is a lot but 30 touches and 7 inside 50's more than makes up for it, he played a freaking great game apart from a couple of mistakes. Also, Johnson is not on your Outs.
if I was coach I would do this:
IN: Thomas, Didak (if fit)
OUT: Johnson, Ugle
Wood can play again, Jolly doesn't need to travel the week before the Cats.
If Thomas isn't fit then Young will come in, Didak will most likely be sub, if not then Sinclair, they will swap in the 3rd quarter.
Yidaki
AFL Behavioural Awareness Officer
- Jul 24, 2010
- 27,886
- 29,119
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Re: Changes vs Lions RD 7
To be honest, I think this is a danger game for us. I know the Lions haven't been in good form, but neither have we. Additionally, playing at the GABBA only makes it more tough for us and they tend to play well against us up there. For some reason, all teams rise up against us.
To be honest, I think this is a danger game for us. I know the Lions haven't been in good form, but neither have we. Additionally, playing at the GABBA only makes it more tough for us and they tend to play well against us up there. For some reason, all teams rise up against us.
TradeDraft
Premium Platinum
- Thread starter
- #6
Yidaki
AFL Behavioural Awareness Officer
- Jul 24, 2010
- 27,886
- 29,119
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Re: Changes vs Lions RD 7
Why would you drop Buckley? Was one of the best against the Doggies. Think there are other players that would be looked at before Bucks. Main concern is Harry playing one on one down back just seems to struggle to beat an opponent.
Changes for the Brisbane game -
In - Didak, Blair
Out - Ugle, Johnson (inj)
Jolly will get another week off, same with Thomas. Don't think Thomas's form really warrants automatic selection back into the side. Could be given a run in the VFL.
Why would you drop Buckley? Was one of the best against the Doggies. Think there are other players that would be looked at before Bucks. Main concern is Harry playing one on one down back just seems to struggle to beat an opponent.
Changes for the Brisbane game -
In - Didak, Blair
Out - Ugle, Johnson (inj)
Jolly will get another week off, same with Thomas. Don't think Thomas's form really warrants automatic selection back into the side. Could be given a run in the VFL.
- Oct 16, 2010
- 2,160
- 938
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Re: Changes vs Lions RD 7
Why does everyone have Ugle out? He should've been subbed on way earlier last night.
Why does everyone have Ugle out? He should've been subbed on way earlier last night.
carnthepies19
Club Legend
Re: Changes vs Lions RD 7
IN: Didak (if fit, if not, Paine), D.Thomas (if not fit then Seedsman)
OUT: Johnson, Fasolo (both inj)
I agree with not risking Jolly. The Geelong match will put one side ahead of the other points wise, so it really is a must win for us. We shouldn't risk Jolly, they've only got Longer and Hudson. Even today Black went up against Bellchambers inthe centre bounce! If Wood can't perform against them, I'd say his opportunity would be as good as gone.
It would possibly be beneficial to also not risk Thomas. Depending on who our opponent in the VFL is next week, I'd consider keeping him in Melbourne with Jolly to play VFL. If we are playing a challenging side, it would be better for them to play a full game against good opposition rather than against Brisbane.
Also a change of tactics, slightly, instead of using te key back who rotates forward, as an option, use them as a defensive forward. It probably won't be veryuseful against Lions, as they don't have anyone who really stars at rebounding. Though against Geelong, this could be a good idea, or even moving Harry O there, he does know his way around goals, so it could boost his confidence.
Overall I think this game will be easy for us, and a good confidence booster ahead of the Geelong match!
IN: Didak (if fit, if not, Paine), D.Thomas (if not fit then Seedsman)
OUT: Johnson, Fasolo (both inj)
I agree with not risking Jolly. The Geelong match will put one side ahead of the other points wise, so it really is a must win for us. We shouldn't risk Jolly, they've only got Longer and Hudson. Even today Black went up against Bellchambers inthe centre bounce! If Wood can't perform against them, I'd say his opportunity would be as good as gone.
It would possibly be beneficial to also not risk Thomas. Depending on who our opponent in the VFL is next week, I'd consider keeping him in Melbourne with Jolly to play VFL. If we are playing a challenging side, it would be better for them to play a full game against good opposition rather than against Brisbane.
Also a change of tactics, slightly, instead of using te key back who rotates forward, as an option, use them as a defensive forward. It probably won't be veryuseful against Lions, as they don't have anyone who really stars at rebounding. Though against Geelong, this could be a good idea, or even moving Harry O there, he does know his way around goals, so it could boost his confidence.
Overall I think this game will be easy for us, and a good confidence booster ahead of the Geelong match!
TradeDraft
Premium Platinum
- Thread starter
- #11
Re: Changes vs Lions RD 7
if they are all fit id go
in: Jolly, Didak, Thomas, Blair
out: Wood, Fasolo, Ugle, Johnson (inj)
Buckley goes for johnson whenever he is ready
Like the look of ugle but would take sinclair over him at this stage, keep him in if either of thomas or blair don't come in.
Fasolo just doesn't do enough, also seems to get in the way of the big guys alot instead of staying at their feet and crumbing. Can kick the odd miracle goal, but didak can do that better, can't think of anything else that fasolo can provide that isn't already covered. He can keep the spot warm until dids is ready if that's not this week. Edit: Some people are saying he's injured, not sure what he did but I'd have him in the outs either way. If he is injured and Didak isn't ready then bring in Paine or just keep ugle in the side.
if they are all fit id go
in: Jolly, Didak, Thomas, Blair
out: Wood, Fasolo, Ugle, Johnson (inj)
Buckley goes for johnson whenever he is ready
Like the look of ugle but would take sinclair over him at this stage, keep him in if either of thomas or blair don't come in.
Fasolo just doesn't do enough, also seems to get in the way of the big guys alot instead of staying at their feet and crumbing. Can kick the odd miracle goal, but didak can do that better, can't think of anything else that fasolo can provide that isn't already covered. He can keep the spot warm until dids is ready if that's not this week. Edit: Some people are saying he's injured, not sure what he did but I'd have him in the outs either way. If he is injured and Didak isn't ready then bring in Paine or just keep ugle in the side.
TradeDraft
Premium Platinum
Re: Changes vs Lions RD 7
I would like to see Ugle kick a goal to just get a spur on, a handball over the top will do. He just needs a little break through, so he can start to shine.
Didn't do a lot last night when he was on, but he did show that he can roost it a mile.
He could be very damaging for us once he gets a bit of a sniff.
In: Didak, Thomas, Jolly
Out: Johnson, Fasolo, Wood
If Fasolo is not injured (as he appeared to be) then I would probably drop Ugle instead.
Wood is stiff, he was good in the ruck and we got smashed when Dawes gave him a chop out in the third.
I would like to see Ugle kick a goal to just get a spur on, a handball over the top will do. He just needs a little break through, so he can start to shine.
Didn't do a lot last night when he was on, but he did show that he can roost it a mile.
He could be very damaging for us once he gets a bit of a sniff.
In: Didak, Thomas, Jolly
Out: Johnson, Fasolo, Wood
If Fasolo is not injured (as he appeared to be) then I would probably drop Ugle instead.
Wood is stiff, he was good in the ruck and we got smashed when Dawes gave him a chop out in the third.
mattys123
Hall of Famer
- Mar 24, 2008
- 31,426
- 20,283
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- LAK, NUFC, SAS, SFGiants, 49ers,
Re: Changes vs Lions RD 7
In: Thomas, Paine
Out: Johnson (inj), Fasolo (inj)
We need a 3rd marking tall, and Paine gives us that option.
Leave Jolly out until the Cats game, because after the Lions game we have a 6 day turn around, and realistically it's a 5 day turnaround by the time we get home (Sunday Morning).
Didak won't play by all reports, he needs at least one more run in the VFL, if not 2-3 more, he is simply not ready.
In: Thomas, Paine
Out: Johnson (inj), Fasolo (inj)
We need a 3rd marking tall, and Paine gives us that option.
Leave Jolly out until the Cats game, because after the Lions game we have a 6 day turn around, and realistically it's a 5 day turnaround by the time we get home (Sunday Morning).
Didak won't play by all reports, he needs at least one more run in the VFL, if not 2-3 more, he is simply not ready.
Heir_Apparent
Team Captain
Re: Changes vs Lions RD 7
s**t how could I forget Blair
IN: Blair, Thomas (lol at whoever said he should have a run in the VFL)
OUT: Johnson, Ugle (if Fas is fit)
s**t how could I forget Blair
IN: Blair, Thomas (lol at whoever said he should have a run in the VFL)
OUT: Johnson, Ugle (if Fas is fit)
TradeDraft
Premium Platinum
- Thread starter
- #17
Re: Changes vs Lions RD 7
I did not know Fasolo was injured. Paine would be a great choice to come in for him
I did not know Fasolo was injured. Paine would be a great choice to come in for him
Re: Changes vs Lions RD 7
INs: Daisy, Blair
OUTs: Johnson & Fasolo (both injured)
See Mattys post. Jolly should be rested. He doesn't need a 6 day break for Cats games. Dids needs more miles in the legs to ensure he comes back cherry ripe.
Keefe to play forward.
INs: Daisy, Blair
OUTs: Johnson & Fasolo (both injured)
See Mattys post. Jolly should be rested. He doesn't need a 6 day break for Cats games. Dids needs more miles in the legs to ensure he comes back cherry ripe.
Keefe to play forward.
- Jul 14, 2011
- 14,368
- 8,617
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- Colts, UVA, Anaheim Ducks
Re: Changes vs Lions RD 7
IN ; Blair, Thomas
Out ; Buckley, Ugle
IN ; Blair, Thomas
Out ; Buckley, Ugle
mattys123
Hall of Famer
- Mar 24, 2008
- 31,426
- 20,283
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- LAK, NUFC, SAS, SFGiants, 49ers,
Re: Changes vs Lions RD 7
Haha, yeah I forgot Blair too.
So, with that in mind;
In: Blair, Thomas, Paine
Out: Ugle, Johnson (inj), Fasolo (inj)
I still think we should rest Jolly again this week, Brisbane only have Hudson as their ruckman, and he was slaughtered by Bellchambers last night, so even Wood should be able to be competitive against him.
Haha, yeah I forgot Blair too.
So, with that in mind;
In: Blair, Thomas, Paine
Out: Ugle, Johnson (inj), Fasolo (inj)
I still think we should rest Jolly again this week, Brisbane only have Hudson as their ruckman, and he was slaughtered by Bellchambers last night, so even Wood should be able to be competitive against him.
jefffff34
Premium Gold
- Sep 20, 2001
- 17,772
- 4,138
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Re: Changes vs Lions RD 7
In - Blair, Thomas
Out - Johnson, Fasolo
What I think will happen, not what I want.
In - Blair, Thomas
Out - Johnson, Fasolo
What I think will happen, not what I want.
Re: Changes vs Lions RD 7
I forgot about Blair, obviously an automatic seletion if fit.
I forgot about Blair, obviously an automatic seletion if fit.
Re: Changes vs Lions RD 7
Keeffe as the third tall forward. Paine is probably not ready for AFL till his disposal is more polished.
Out: Johnson, Fasolo (inj)
In: Blair, Thomas
If people want Ugle out then Paine is probably an obvious replacement, but maybe Ugle deserves another week. O'Brien needs to sort his game out or he should lose his spot. Teams may try each week to isolate and expose him. Of course there needs to be a ready made replacement.
Keeffe as the third tall forward. Paine is probably not ready for AFL till his disposal is more polished.
Out: Johnson, Fasolo (inj)
In: Blair, Thomas
If people want Ugle out then Paine is probably an obvious replacement, but maybe Ugle deserves another week. O'Brien needs to sort his game out or he should lose his spot. Teams may try each week to isolate and expose him. Of course there needs to be a ready made replacement.
Yidaki
AFL Behavioural Awareness Officer
- Jul 24, 2010
- 27,886
- 29,119
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Re: Changes vs Lions RD 7
Totally agree. We need the the best team on the park to beat Brissy at home. Jols must play imo.
Totally agree. We need the the best team on the park to beat Brissy at home. Jols must play imo.
Similar threads
- Locked
- Locked
