'08 Pre-Season Votes

[Bartram_Class]

Split 12 as many ways as you want.

-------------------------------------------------

5 - Carroll (in everything, you name it, he did it)
4 - McLean (goes close to Chopper with his bar-hopping tour of Europe and donuts out at Trinity but avoided punishment)
3 - Sylvia (came into the votes late on with a strong finish, aggressive as ever but a bit disappointing overall though, we might have expected more from him)

Honourable mentions to David Neitz (for getting his mug into the paper a bit), John Meesen (for showing up most of the midfielders on the track) and Juice Newton (Necking himself up in Cairns to scare us shitless down here, then jumping up to play tag in the hotel pool later that night)

 

[Theseventhhamster]

Split 12 as many ways as you want.

-------------------------------------------------

5 - Carroll (in everything, you name it, he did it)
4 - McLean (goes close to Chopper with his bar-hopping tour of Europe and donuts out at Trinity but avoided punishment)
3 - Sylvia (came into the votes late on with a strong finish, aggressive as ever but a bit disappointing overall though, we might have expected more from him)

Honourable mentions to David Neitz (for getting his mug into the paper a bit), John Meesen (for showing up most of the midfielders on the track) and Juice Newton (Necking himself up in Cairns to scare us shitless down here, then jumping up to play tag in the hotel pool later that night)

See this is the problem with young Nathan Jones. It's not like it's his first season here or anything and he's still bringing nothing extra to the team! It's like he's invisible once the season ends, no value at all, soft.

 

[demonfan9]

Maybe we can create a 'Carroll McLean Award' for most/biggest indiscretions by an MFC player during each season.

 

[Supermercado]

My leaderboard was

12 - Davey
11 - Jones
8 - Sylvia
5 - Buckley
5 - Newton
5 - Valenti
4 - Miller
3 - Moloney
2 - Garland
2 - Carroll
1 - Johnson
1 - Bate
1 - Bell

So, as they were the only three who really deserved it I'll go

5 - Davey
4 - Sylvia
3 - Jones

 

[melbournemartin]

How come Valenti didn't get a game vs the Roos?

 

[Bartram_Class]

How come Valenti didn't get a game vs the Roos?

At this stage, he can't play Round 1 so why waste the spot when we could be playing a player in contention for a round 1 spot?

Also, he might have wanted to gel a bit with the Sandy side.