Past #1: Hamish McIntosh - drafted at pick 9 in '02 ND - traded to Geelong for #36 in '12 trade period

who's the best ruckman

  • D.COX

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • H.MCINTOSH

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • D.JOLLY

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • M.CLARKE

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • A.SANDILANDS

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    0

Thewlis Dish

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Sep 9, 2003
Posts
25,362
Likes
18,513
Location
Five Star Laundry
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Other Teams
FGR
Sydney Swans (playing this weekend in case you missed it) say hi.
Our two ruckman don't though.

Hamish is very expensive ruck depth. He is 28 and with his history of leg problems, probably only has another couple of seasons (if that) at the top level. I think if a team like Geelong or Collingwood comes in and offers him a first ruck position, we wouldn't stand in his way.

I don't think we'll actively shop him but I think he will go.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Artaxx

All Australian
Joined
Mar 30, 2011
Posts
824
Likes
601
Location
Perth
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Hale, Gibson and pick 52 for Harper, Mabon, Black and Kennedy. I know the DoS trolling version includes Bastinac but it's a creative interpretation only.

Other than Harper we haven't proven anything yet. Hawks have plugged 2 big holes in their list.

Btw these trades all occured under Scott's watch not Dean's.
I know it was the current decision makers who got those trades done. which is what I meant. I think the current lot have shown that they know what they're doing.
Black, Harper, Kennedy and Mabon than Gibson and Hale? Not even close imo. Hale would be playing for Ballarat and Gibson would be the same player (unable to actually play on anyone, short and a knobhead) just not so overrated.
 

Joshen

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Apr 29, 2009
Posts
6,290
Likes
5,256
Location
Melbourne
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Other Teams
Seattle Seahawks
Talk of trading Hamish for Gillies, Simpson, Orren etc is laughable. The only trade I'd entertain would be something involving Mitch Duncan, that is not going to happen so move along please.
There are other players on the Geelong list I would happily take outside of Duncan.
 

Kimbo

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Dec 14, 2002
Posts
18,032
Likes
24,845
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Other Teams
Sturt, Liverpool
Are you suggesting we would trade picks 14 and 15 to get Caddy?
No, was speculating that rather than helping Geelong secure Caddy that it might help us if we got their compo pick to on-trade which those on the D&T board reckon might have greater currency than picks 11-14.

Still does not address the question under debate here, re our own ruck stocks.
 

Event Horizon

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Sep 24, 2002
Posts
18,714
Likes
6,611
Location
Melbourne
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Other Teams
Arsenal, Victory
:(, now I know what its like to be cyber bullied, Not as bad as they make it out to be on ACA, FWIW i think Joffa would be a better supporter
Nah, that wasn't cyber bullying at all, I don't think.
Cyber bullying would be if Teffie told you that you're fat, ugly and worthless, and he wished for you to die. I think that's how it works anyway. But don't worry, this is a pretty friendly place most of the time. ;)
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Hard_to_Beat

Brownlow Medallist
Suspended
Joined
Aug 9, 2012
Posts
11,162
Likes
6,002
AFL Club
North Melbourne
He does need to fill out but that's all he needs to do. Has a lot of ability and doesn't mind putting his body in either.

Ben has a great skill set and coordination for a big bloke. Moves well also.

I just can't see him finding another 20kgs in weight. He doesn't have a particularly good leap either, so the weight issue is crucial.

I have a lot more faith in Majak improving by 10-20% than Ben finding another 20kgs inside the next 2 years.

KPD is the only other option I see for Ben and at 200cm he is slightly disadvantaged for that role as well.

Nah, that wasn't cyber bullying at all, I don't think.
Cyber bullying would be if Teffie told you that you're fat, ugly and worthless, and he wished for you to die. I think that's how it works anyway. But don't worry, this is a pretty friendly place most of the time. ;)
Who is crying?

I fail to see how ignoring someone constitutes cyber bullying.:rolleyes:
 

Mailman

Club Legend
Joined
May 2, 2005
Posts
1,550
Likes
95
Location
Melbourne
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Other Teams
North Ballarat/Werribee
There is no doubt that we need 2 AFL capable rucks on the list next year. What i want to see is a more flexible approach where those rucks do not possess the same constraints around the ground, and the same selection pressure.
The 2nd ruckman plays in the seniors if there is a need, but alternatively we use a Pederson type (would rather not trade) if more mobility is required.
There is no doubt North felt pressure to play Hamish and Goldy early in the season, which forced desperate ideas like playing Goldy at CHB.

If North are sure they can bring in a up-and-coming AFL ruckman who will develop and perform in-and-out of the seniors, then I have no problem with trading Hamish so he can get more opportunities. He deserves it.
At his age he won't likely be there for our true premiership window. While i do understand the concept of needing quality players in order to open this window, if we can bolster our midfield as a result of this trade with an eye to our premiership window, then I believe this more than compensates. Even without Hamish there is no doubt we will have a window of opportunity.

Without understanding the entire trading strategy of the club this year no-one can make an informed judgement on whether trading Hamish is optimal for our success next year. I will just sit back and have faith that the football department/recruiting staff that are on track to form a strong playing list, capable of premierships in 3-4 years, know what they are doing.
 

Joshen

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Apr 29, 2009
Posts
6,290
Likes
5,256
Location
Melbourne
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Other Teams
Seattle Seahawks
is stefan martin leaving the dees ???
Apparently, to be honest I wouldn't mind a Pedo Martin straight swap. He was very decent last year. Friends with Goldy too with Basketball background. Also it would please me no end to see the Pies miss out on both utilities available.

Agree Hard_to_Beat they won't be trading any best 22 material. Having said that if they come knocking and Hamish is keen to leave - the ball is firmly in our court. Can't see it happening though to be honest.
 
Joined
Jun 9, 2001
Posts
20,854
Likes
50,089
Location
Windy Hill Safe Injecting Room
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Other Teams
St Johnstone
Moderator #3,319
KPD is the only other option I see for Ben and at 200cm he is slightly disadvantaged for that role as well.
Would dispute that too - I know that's what is printed in the stats guides. Just doesn't look it.

Ben has the other issue playing small. Has neat footskills but not convinced about his tapping and overhead work. As you say, maybe a KP for him if he really shows solid development in the next year.

Can't see him as an AFL ruck myself. Unless there's a sale on d-bol.
 
Top Bottom