- Banned
- #426
I also disagree with this.
Why can't players be overrated, even after one year? If North fans were talking of Atley winning the Brownlow in 2013, and being in the top 20 players of 2012, are you saying it is nonsensical to rate him as overrated?
but how can you even talk of consistency if you wish to base your assumptions of his ability from only one season?
What happens if Atley has a terrific season in 2013 and you then say "I was wrong for calling him overrated" but at the start of 2014 he does his ACL and plays again 2015 but is nothing like the player he was the year before....can I then say he's overrated if we are only talking one year to judge players?